Director: Ohio unlikely to allow sediment dumping in lake

TOLEDO, Ohio -- The federal agency in charge of maintaining Cleveland's shipping channels is making the case again for dumping dredged sediment into Lake Erie, saying tests show the soil and mud isn't contaminated.

See Full Article

But the head of Ohio's Environmental Protection Agency said Friday he remains unconvinced and is unlikely to allow putting the sediment in the lake instead of a containment facility.

A final decision hasn't been made yet on whether to reject the request from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, said Craig Butler, the state EPA director.

The two sides have been locked in a long-running dispute over what to do with the sediment dredged from Cleveland's harbour.

Ohio's environmental agency says the sediment is loaded with PCBs -- a chemical linked to cancer -- and is a threat to water quality and fish. The Army Corps says the sediment is clean now and it would be much cheaper to dispose of it in the lake.

The Ohio EPA sued the federal agency last year after it threatened to stop dredging until Ohio paid $1.4 million to put the material in a containment facility. A federal judge ordered the dredging to continue, but the lawsuit over who pays is still to be decided.

Congress in late December approved a bill that included a stipulation preventing the Army Corps from dumping hazardous dredged material in the lake without meeting requirements set by the state.

The Army Corps said this week that its own review of sediment from the Cuyahoga River shows the level of PCBs is similar to that in sediment found in the lake off the Cleveland shore.

"Moving sediment from the river channel to an open lake placement site would not result in lowering Lake Erie's water quality," Lt. Col. Karl Jansen, commander of the agency's Buffalo district, wrote in a letter.

The Army Corps also called the Ohio EPA's tests on the same samples unreliable, saying they greatly overestimated the risk the chemicals within the sediment would pose.

Butler said that the state used methods approved by the U.S. EPA and that the Army Corps didn't raise any concerns with them about the data or the evaluation process.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • One-handed B.C. marksman reaches his target despite disability

    Canada News CTV News
    ABBOTSFORD, B.C. -- He works deftly, loading five bullets into a magazine. He steadies the .308-calibre rifle on a pair of sand bags and peers delicately through the scope. He fires, pulls back the bolt to reload, fires again. Source
  • Roman Polanski won't preside over César Awards, as originally announced

    World News CBC News
    Filmmaker Roman Polanski has decided not to preside over the French equivalent of the Oscars, after protests from France's women's rights minister and feminist groups because of decades-old U.S. sex charges. An official with the arts academy that holds the Césars Awards said Tuesday that Polanski won't take part in the Feb. Source
  • U.K. can't trigger Brexit without parliamentary approval: Supreme Court

    World News CTV News
    LONDON -- Britain's government must get parliamentary approval before starting the process of leaving the European Union, the Supreme Court ruling Tuesday, potentially delaying Prime Minister Theresa May's plans to trigger negotiations by the end of March. Source
  • Liberal efforts to stamp out sexual, domestic assault called 'massive disappointment'

    Canada News CBC News
    The Liberal government is developing a strategy to tackle sexual and domestic violence, but some front-line workers are calling the government's progress to date a "massive disappointment." Status of Women Minister Maryam Monsef, picking up on the work done by her predecessor Patty Hajdu, is expected to present a plan to address "gender-based violence" this spring or summer. Source
  • Memories from space: Roberta Bondar marks 25th anniversary of Discovery shuttle mission

    Canada News CBC News
    It's been 25 years since Roberta Bondar, Canada's first female astronaut, launched into space aboard the shuttle Discovery. After blasting off on Jan. 22, 1992, Bondar spent eight days orbiting Earth as a member of Mission STS-42. Source
  • Trump's simplistic talk on NAFTA ignores the threat of disruption: Don Pittis

    Canada News CBC News
    The concept behind the North American Free Trade agreement is wonderfully simple. In a similar way, U.S. President Donald Trump's campaign promises on NAFTA are clear enough for any fool to understand. But when you take those two simple ideas and put them together, you get something that one Canadian trade expert calls "a disaster. Source
  • Montreal private school accused of racism after Muslim student arrested, expelled

    Canada News CBC News
    A 15-year-old Muslim student mutters his frustration over a poor test result. A school monitor thinks she hears a threat to blow up the school. A chain of events follows that, according to lawsuit filed in Quebec Court, sees the student taken from his home in handcuffs, arrested, kicked out of his private school and his hopes of a university scholarship put on hold. Source
  • How do you negotiate a trade agreement with a president for whom facts don't matter?: Opinion

    Canada News CBC News
    Ultimately, it doesn't matter how big the crowd was at Donald Trump's inauguration, although, for the record, I was at Obama's in 2009, and I remember the National Mall being so packed it felt almost dangerous. Source
  • Death toll from avalanche in Italy officially 14, with 15 still missing

    World News CBC News
    The death toll from an avalanche in central Italy climbed to 14 on Tuesday as hopes began to fade that any of the 15 people still missing might be found alive under a mountain resort buried by tons of snow and rubble. Source
  • Iraqi forces look west in bid to recapture Mosul

    World News CBC News
    Iraqi forces have started preparing an offensive to capture the western side of Mosul from Islamic State, campaign commander Lt.-Gen. Abdul Ameer Rasheed Yarallah said. Popular Mobilisation "is preparing an operation in the next two, three days, to back up the operation to retake the right bank" of the city, on the western side of the Tigris river, Mosuliya TV cited him as saying on Tuesday. Source