Director: Ohio unlikely to allow sediment dumping in lake

TOLEDO, Ohio -- The federal agency in charge of maintaining Cleveland's shipping channels is making the case again for dumping dredged sediment into Lake Erie, saying tests show the soil and mud isn't contaminated.

See Full Article

But the head of Ohio's Environmental Protection Agency said Friday he remains unconvinced and is unlikely to allow putting the sediment in the lake instead of a containment facility.

A final decision hasn't been made yet on whether to reject the request from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, said Craig Butler, the state EPA director.

The two sides have been locked in a long-running dispute over what to do with the sediment dredged from Cleveland's harbour.

Ohio's environmental agency says the sediment is loaded with PCBs -- a chemical linked to cancer -- and is a threat to water quality and fish. The Army Corps says the sediment is clean now and it would be much cheaper to dispose of it in the lake.

The Ohio EPA sued the federal agency last year after it threatened to stop dredging until Ohio paid $1.4 million to put the material in a containment facility. A federal judge ordered the dredging to continue, but the lawsuit over who pays is still to be decided.

Congress in late December approved a bill that included a stipulation preventing the Army Corps from dumping hazardous dredged material in the lake without meeting requirements set by the state.

The Army Corps said this week that its own review of sediment from the Cuyahoga River shows the level of PCBs is similar to that in sediment found in the lake off the Cleveland shore.

"Moving sediment from the river channel to an open lake placement site would not result in lowering Lake Erie's water quality," Lt. Col. Karl Jansen, commander of the agency's Buffalo district, wrote in a letter.

The Army Corps also called the Ohio EPA's tests on the same samples unreliable, saying they greatly overestimated the risk the chemicals within the sediment would pose.

Butler said that the state used methods approved by the U.S. EPA and that the Army Corps didn't raise any concerns with them about the data or the evaluation process.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Italy's interior minister says Malta should take rescue boat

    World News CBC News
    Italy's populist, anti-migrant interior minister said Friday that Malta should allow a Dutch-flagged rescue ship carrying hundreds of migrants rescued from rubber dinghies off the Libyan coast to make port there because the ship is now in Maltese waters. Source
  • Albertan who killed three people gets life, no chance of parole for 30 years

    Canada News CTV News
    An Alberta man who fatally shot three people in November, 2015, has been sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for 30 years. Mickell Bailey, 21, was convicted in April of three counts of second-degree murder in the deaths of his aunt Roxanne Berube, 36, her partner Daniel Miller, 46, and her 16-year-old daughter Jazmine Lyon. Source
  • After U.S., Israel also backs away from UN human rights body

    World News CTV News
    GENEVA - Diplomats say Israel has temporarily reduced its participation with the UN Human Rights Council, days after the United States pulled out. The diplomats in Geneva, speaking on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the matter publicly, said Israel had "lowered" its participation. Source
  • Union under fire at Wettlaufer inquiry for defending problem nurse

    Canada News CBC News
    Within hours of finding out Elizabeth Wettlaufer was suspended for making a medication error, the Ontario Nurses' Association (ONA) filed a grievance on her behalf, a public inquiry heard Thursday. There was no investigation about why Wettlaufer was being suspended or whether she had put patients at the Caressant Care nursing home in Woodstock, Ont. Source
  • Case of accused serial killer Bruce McArthur put over to July 23

    Canada News CTV News
    In this artist's sketch, alleged serial killer BruceMcArthur makes an appearance via video in a Toronto courtroom, Wednesday, April 11, 2018. From left, lawyer Samantha Saunders, part of McArthur's defence team, McArthur, Justice Wendy Agnew and Crown Michael Cantlon are shown. Source
  • Russia says evidence of Syria chemical attacks was faked

    World News CBC News
    Russia said Friday that the U.S. and its allies have relied on fabricated evidence to accuse the Syrian government of launching chemical attacks against civilians. Russia's foreign and defence ministries also charged the international chemical weapons watchdog with failing to objectively investigate the alleged chemical attacks and with being subject to political control. Source
  • Inflation rate holds steady at 2.2% in May despite soaring gasoline prices

    Canada News CBC News
    The cost of living increased at a 2.2 per cent annual pace in May, matching the increase seen a month earlier. Statistics Canada reported Friday that all eight components it tracks to come up with the consumer price index were higher during the month, but more than half of them grew by a slower rate than they did in April. Source
  • National Indigenous Peoples Day should be a week, Elijah Harper's son says

    Canada News CBC News
    The son of the man who originally called for the establishment of National Indigenous Peoples Day would like to see it extended to a week to better educate Canadians about the first peoples of this land. Source
  • N.L. confronts its archaic coat of arms depicting 'noble savage'

    Canada News CTV News
    Another archaic symbol of Canada's colonial past is under the microscope. The Newfoundland and Labrador government confirmed this week it plans to redesign the province's 400-year-old coat of arms, which depicts two Indigenous warriors holding a red shield. Source
  • EU retaliatory tariffs on U.S. goods go into effect

    World News CBC News
    The European Union is enforcing $3.4 billion US in tariffs on U.S. products as of Friday in retaliation to duties the Trump administration has put on European steel and aluminum. The goods targeted include typical American products like bourbon, peanut butter, and orange juice, in a way that seems designed to create political pressure on U.S. Source