New Hampshire primary: Working class voters boost Sanders, Trump in polls

DERRY, United States -- A key to understanding the 2016 U.S. election was beneath the feet of two of its principal antagonists the other night, buried below the spot where they were standing.

See Full Article

Two storeys below the stage where Democrats Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders last debated, there's a museum display chronicling the de-industrialization of Derry, N.H.

It shows machines from old shoe factories that have disappeared, supporting jobs that have disappeared, held by people now disappearing: well-paid, low-skilled American workers.

The local historian who runs it recalls the once-bustling main street, filled today with a high-end shop here, a pawn shop there, and an empty storefront or two in between.

"These were all factories. Shoe factories. Gone," Rick Holmes said, gesturing at the street.

"Gone, with the middle class."

New Hampshire is actually an economic success story. It's among the richest states. It has a microscopic unemployment rate of 3.8 per cent.

But pop open the hood and underneath those numbers you'll find the same engine powering the discontent now threatening to overrun the establishment of both political parties.

This state has bled manufacturing jobs, like much of the country. And the two insurgent candidates who could win Tuesday's primary have seized upon that sense of loss as their central message.

Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders are leading big in New Hampshire polls, to the mortification of a political establishment that has derided both as unelectable.

The rumpled socialist and the bewilderingly coiffed billionaire may be different personalities, with different worldviews, proposing different solutions.

But they're pointing to the same issues, real or alleged: free trade, decent jobs shipped overseas or replaced with machines, and an indifferent political class distracted by the priorities of its campaign donors among the mega-wealthy one per cent.

For Sanders, the proposed fix involves a drastically expanded social-safety net: free college tuition, Canadian-style health care, and paid parental leave. For Trump, it's about kicking out millions of illegal migrants from Mexico, who are working under-the-table for cheaper salaries than Americans would.

They have one major policy in common: ripping up trade deals.

Holmes predicts they'll do well Tuesday.

"They both come across as angry men. And I think many of their voters are also angry," he said. "They're frustrated, trying to balance the family budget."

Signs of change surround his town. Around the corner, the last of the old abandoned factories is about to be demolished after it's stripped of salvageable scrap metal.

Down the street in a popular diner, one waitress says every person she knows is voting for the one of the two candidates: "All Bernie. And all Trump," Amanda Parker says. "One or the other. It's strange."

Another waitress feels their frustration. Linda Guilnet says people live paycheque to paycheque. Health insurance can cost half that paycheque, and politicians are too busy squabbling to help the American worker.

"You get to the point where you're tired of hearing it. (Politicians) are fighting against each other -- but you're not telling me what I want to hear," said the manager of Mary Ann's diner.

"People are concerned... People want to get back to where they should be. Instead of struggling."

Many people have benefited from the increasingly digital, global, service-oriented economy. This Boston bedroom community is surrounded by such evidence. It's dotted with McMansions erected during the dot-com and real-estate booms of the last two decades.

But the prevailing negative mood is amply chronicled in numbers -- in economic data, the national census, and surveys:

--More than 60 per cent of Americans believe their children's generation will be worse off -- the opposite of how people feel in growing economies in Asia, according to a Pew survey.

--The middle class is shrinking. Pew described a historic tipping point in another study: it said poor and rich people now outnumber the U.S. middle class, with middle-tier earners shrinking nine per cent since 1971. The result is a more unequal country -- with many rising to the top tier, and about half falling the other way.

--The biggest losers include two groups: the less-educated, and the young. People with only a high-school diploma have seen their share of the national income fall a whopping 22 per cent since 1971, and young 18-to-29-year-olds have seen it drop five per cent.

Take a wild guess who they're supporting.

Sanders took 84 per cent of the youth vote in Iowa, according to exit polls that showed Clinton winning richer, older voters. As for Trump, polls have shown him dominant among Republicans who never went to college. With those who have a degree, he's a fourth-place also-ran.

An expert on public opinion at the University of New Hampshire says the two men are appealing to very distinct subsets among the frustrated.

"The same economic angst underlies voters in both parties," Andrew Smith said. "But I don't think there are many people saying, 'Hmm, should I vote for Sanders or vote for Trump?'... The tone certainly is different."

A Sanders fan concurs, brushing off a comparison between the socialist who blames billionaires, and the billionaire who blames foreigners. Kim De Lutis says: "They are polar opposites. Trump divides, Bernie unites."

But there's enough anger at politicians for them to share. The approval rate of Congress has historically bounced around between the 20s and the 50s according to Gallup surveys.

It's now in the teens, and has been for years.

Holmes has prepared for the future. He's built an additional floor above his home -- for his kin to live in, with their children.

"(In the old days) everybody who worked could afford a house. Today, I don't think that's true," he said.

"A lot of people ... feel left out. (They feel), 'We are not part of what is happening to America anymore. America has changed... (And) they're lashing out."



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Sports and energy drinks unhealthy for kids and teens, Canadian pediatricians say

    Canada News CBC News
    Most children and teens shouldn't consume sports and energy drinks, and the products should no longer be marketed to them, the Canadian Paediatric Society says. In a new position statement released Tuesday, the society said sports drinks are high in sugar, which contributes to the obesity epidemic as well as dental cavities. Source
  • Trump associate denies Russia collusion ahead of House visit

    World News CTV News
    WASHINGTON - Longtime Donald Trump associate Roger Stone says there is "not one shred of evidence" that he was involved with Russian interference in the 2016 election. Stone is defending himself in a lengthy statement released ahead of a closed-door appearance before the House intelligence committee Tuesday. Source
  • Witness in murder trial run over in front of Vegas courthouse

    World News Toronto Sun
    LAS VEGAS β€” The sister of a murder victim was hit by a car Monday on a sidewalk outside the Las Vegas courthouse where the man charged in the killing is standing trial and she is on a list of potential witnesses, authorities said. Source
  • Police union blasts handling of Utah nurse arrest probe

    World News CTV News
    SALT LAKE CITY - Two officers under investigation in the rough arrest of a nurse have been unfairly made into pariahs after body-camera footage got widespread attention online, a Utah police union said Monday. The Salt Lake Police Association said in a letter to the mayor and police chief that it is "extremely concerned and dismayed" about handling that has "corrupted" the high-profile investigation, The Deseret News reported. Source
  • Smoke fills plane's cabin after landing at California airport

    World News Toronto Sun
    FRESNO, Calif. β€” Smoke filled the cabin of an Allegiant Air jet after it landed at a California airport on Monday, forcing coughing passengers to cover their faces with shirts and firefighters to board the plane, authorities said. Source
  • Man pleads guilty to sucker-punching disabled person

    World News Toronto Sun
    WEST CHESTER, Pa. β€” A man who was caught on video sucker-punching a man with cerebral palsy outside a Pennsylvania store has pleaded guilty to simple assault. Twenty-nine-year-old Barry Robert Baker Jr. of Georgetown, Delaware, entered his plea Monday. Source
  • Canadian describes harrowing tale of Dominica destruction in Hurricane Maria aftermath

    World News CTV News
    It’s been a week since Hurricane Maria pummelled Dominica, and Patrick Mullins still vividly remembers his experience on the ground as the powerful storm tore through the Caribbean island. The 67 -year-old Ontario resident was in Dominica working on a project with local youth when Maria made landfall. Source
  • Paralympian sues University of Regina over accident that left her a quadriplegic

    Canada News CTV News
    REGINA -- A Paralympian who was left paralyzed after a diving accident says she knew the injury was bad the moment it happened. Miranda Biletski testified Monday in Court of Queen's Bench in Regina, where she is suing the University of Regina for negligence. Source
  • Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko rejects call for anti-corruption court

    World News CBC News
    Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko says judicial reform aimed at rooting out corruption in his country will be introduced in two weeks, but the leader rejects calls for the creation of an independent anti-corruption court. "I am absolutely confident that it is vital for us to create anti-corruption system in the whole court institution of Ukraine," Poroshenko said in an exclusive interview with CBC's Rosemary Barton. Source
  • 'Save our liberty!' Protesters in wheelchairs disrupt hearing on Obamacare replacement bill

    World News CBC News
    Protesters in wheelchairs interrupted Monday's U.S. Senate hearing on the Republican health-care bill aimed at repealing and replacing "Obamacare." "No cuts to Medicaid! Save our liberty!" they shouted at the Senate finance committee meeting. The noisy protests forced committee chairman Orrin Hatch to recess the hearing just moments after it began. Source