Judge rules 'affluenza' teen can stay in juvenile facility

FORT WORTH, Texas -- The Texas teenager who used an "affluenza" defence in a fatal drunken-driving wreck won't be moved to an adult jail as he awaits a hearing to determine whether his case will be transferred to adult court, where he could face time behind bars, a judge ruled Friday.

See Full Article

Ethan Couch, 18, was booked into a juvenile detention facility in Fort Worth after he was deported from Mexico on Thursday. Authorities believe he and his mother fled the U.S. last month as Texas prosecutors investigated whether he violated his probation in the 2013 wreck that killed four people.

Prosecutors and the local sheriff wanted Couch moved to an adult jail. But during a brief hearing, Judge Timothy Menikos sided with Couch's attorneys and said the teen would stay at the juvenile centre until a Feb. 19 hearing.

Tarrant County District Attorney Sharen Wilson said her office would do everything it could to hold Couch accountable, but noted she was limited because Couch was sentenced only to 10 years' probation in 2013. The sentence came after a defence expert testified that Couch had been coddled into a sense of irresponsibility by his wealthy parents, calling the condition "affluenza."

Wilson urged the public not to focus on Couch or "feed his ego with notoriety."

"Behind every incident are the victims, and this should be their story," she said in a statement Friday.

The then-16-year-old Couch had a blood-alcohol level three times the legal limit for adult drivers when he swerved off a road near Fort Worth and hit a disabled car, killing its driver and three people helping her.

Among the most severely injured survivors was Sergio Molina, who was paralyzed and can communicate only by blinking his eyes. He was in the bed of Couch's truck, which was carrying eight people.

His brother, Alex Lemus, was at the Friday hearing and said Molina will attend Couch's hearing in February.

"It's very hard to deal with all the changes to Sergio, being in the state that he's in," Lemus said. "Yet it's frustrating because we have to deal with the understanding (that) if my brother was the one driving the vehicle with all these victims, my mother really believes he would have gotten the death penalty in Texas."

Tim McLaughlin, whose 15-year-old son was in the other vehicle but survived, said he also hopes Couch goes to jail because he needs "a wake-up call." Eric Boyles, who lost his wife and daughter in the wreck, was at the hearing but declined an interview request.

Couch's attorney, Scott Brown, said that he doesn't plan to fight transferring the case to adult court, though he wouldn't detail what he planned to argue at the February hearing.

Couch and his mother disappeared in December, after an online video appeared to show Couch at a party where people were drinking. Terms of Couch's probation barred him from drinking or leaving Tarrant County.

Mother and son were apprehended in the Mexican resort city of Puerto Vallarta on Dec. 28, after a call for pizza delivery tipped off authorities to their whereabouts.

Couch initially fought deportation, but he dropped the fight this week. His mother, Tonya Couch, was deported last month and charged with hindering the apprehension of a felon. She was released on bond after being fitted with an electronic ankle GPS monitor.

If Ethan Couch's case is moved to adult court, the judge could order Couch to spend up to 120 days in jail as part of an adult sentence, and then finish the remainder of his 10-year probation, according to district attorney spokeswoman Samantha Jordan. If he violates his probation during that time, he could get up to 10 years in prison for each of the four people killed in the drunken-driving wreck.

If his case remains in juvenile court, prosecutors could ask for a separate hearing to determine whether Couch violated his probation. If a judge rules that he didn't violate his terms, he would go free directly after the hearing and remain on probation until his sentence expires on his 19th birthday in April, according to the Texas Juvenile Justice Department. If Couch is found to have violated probation, the judge could either sentence him to a state facility operated by the Texas Juvenile Justice Department or leave him on juvenile probation until he turns 19.

If Couch is sentenced to the state facility, a judge would hold another hearing before his birthday to determine whether to transfer him to adult prison for up to 10 years or to adult parole.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Slim Republican majority on U.S. tax bill under threat after Marco Rubio defects

    World News CBC News
    The U.S. Republican Party's razor-thin margin for driving their sweeping tax package through the Senate was thrown into jeopardy Thursday when Republican Sen. Marco Rubio declared he will vote against it unless negotiators expand the tax credit that low-income Americans can claim for their children. Source
  • Veterans brace for battle and disappointment as pension decision looms

    Canada News CBC News
    The Liberal government's plan to give wounded ex-soldiers "the option" of a lifetime pension will be a complicated two-part rejigging of the current system, CBC News has learned. A series of sources with knowledge of the file say the first component involves recognizing the pain and suffering of injuries with either the existing lump sum award, or a monthly tax-free payment to a maximum of $1,200 per month. Source
  • UN envoy says 'golden opportunity missed' as Syria talks wrap up

    World News CTV News
    GENEVA -- The U.N. envoy for Syria said the latest round of Geneva talks ended without progress on Thursday after two fruitless weeks, calling it a "golden opportunity missed" and acknowledging that he needs to come up with new ideas to make headway toward ending Syria's nearly seven-year war. Source
  • Nephews of Venezuelan president's wife get 18 years in prison

    World News CBC News
    A New York judge has sentenced two nephews of the Venezuelan president's wife to 18 years in prison for their conviction on drug conspiracy charges. Judge Paul Crotty announced the sentences in Manhattan federal court after the men apologized for their crimes. Source
  • RCMP looking anew at 284 sexual assault cases from 2016

    Canada News CTV News
    OTTAWA -- The Mounties say they are going to take a new look at 284 sexual assault cases that they originally classified as unfounded. The decision comes after the RCMP reviewed 2,225 sexual assault files from 2016 in which police concluded that no violation of the law had taken place or was attempted. Source
  • Paul Ryan denies reports, says he's not leaving Congress soon

    World News CTV News
    WASHINGTON -- House Speaker Paul Ryan said Thursday he's not leaving Congress anytime soon, trying to squelch rumours that he will walk away in triumph after the Republicans' treasured tax bill is approved. Politico and The Huffington Post published reports speculating that Ryan would make this two-year Congress his last or even resign after lawmakers approve the $1.5 trillion tax bill, which is expected next week. Source
  • Britain First leader whom Trump re-tweeted arrested again in Belfast

    World News CBC News
    A leader of a British far-right group, whose anti-Islamic posts were retweeted by U.S. President Donald Trump causing outrage in Britain, was arrested in Northern Ireland on Thursday minutes after being bailed over a separate incident. Source
  • California police bust multimillion-dollar weed 'fortress'

    World News CTV News
    LOS ANGELES -- Police in Southern California raided a weed "fortress" on Wednesday, seizing 35,000 marijuana plants and shutting down an operation they believe was bringing in millions of dollars a month. Investigators first turned their sights on the illegal grow operation about two months ago after receiving complaints from neighbours. Source
  • No jail for fertility doctor who lied about using own sperm

    World News CTV News
    INDIANAPOLIS -- A retired Indianapolis fertility doctor accused of inseminating patients with his own sperm will serve no jail time after pleading guilty Thursday to charges that he lied to investigators. A Marion County judge gave Dr. Source
  • Ex-husband forged documents to hide millions in B.C. divorce case

    Canada News CBC News
    A woman who was earning just $900 a month working in a hotel laundry while her then-husband concealed a fortune has won nearly $1.3 million in spousal support. Quesnel businessman Dalbir Singh Sangha is "an admitted forger and perjurer" who fraudulently hid millions of dollars in assets from his ex-wife, Amarjit Kaur Sangha, according to B.C. Source