Artist can sue UPS over lost paintings, court rules

FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. - The Florida Supreme Court ruled unanimously Thursday that an artist can sue UPS in state court over two paintings removed from their shipping tube while in transit and sold by the company UPS contracts to handle its lost-and-found operation.

See Full Article

The court ruled that artist Ivana Vidovic Mlinar's lawsuit can go to trial, rejecting UPS' argument that federal law applies.

Mlinar didn't purchase insurance in 2005 when she shipped her paintings, "Advice" and "The Messenger," from a South Florida package store that used UPS. The paintings, which she valued at $30,000, were headed to a New York City exhibit that she saw as a major opportunity to advance her career. When the shipping tube arrived at the gallery, however, it had been cut open and was empty.

Mlinar contacted UPS, which told her it couldn't help her directly because the package store was its customer, not her - even though she had been given a UPS receipt and tracking number. The package store gave her a $100 coupon and she partly blamed herself for not buying insurance.

But the situation changed in 2007. Mara Hatfield, Mlinar's attorney, said the artist was contacted by a Missouri man who had bought "Advice" from a company, Cargo Largo. UPS contracts with that Kansas City, Missouri,-based company to handle its lost-and-found operation. Any goods Cargo Largo can't return, it gets to sell.

Hatfield said Cargo Largo sold "Advice" to the Missouri man for $1,000 - a fraction of its value. He also acquired "The Messenger" from another party. Realizing the paintings' value, he listed them on Craigslist, offering to trade them for a used Mercedes-Benz. He also contacted Mlinar, who had placed an identification sticker on the back of her paintings.

This development led Mlinar to file suit in Florida court against UPS, Cargo Largo and the packing store, alleging they had profited from criminal activity - the theft of her paintings - and had violated her copyright. She also accused UPS of deceptive trade practices by having the packing store give her a UPS receipt and make it appear she was a UPS customer.

The buyer returned the paintings in exchange for being dropped from the copyright lawsuit.

UPS argued that under a century-old federal law governing interstate shipping, lawsuits involving lost goods must be tried in federal court. The company's lawyers argued that since the two-year federal statute of limitations had expired, Mlinar couldn't sue in federal court, either.

Florida's lower courts agreed with UPS, but the state Supreme Court reinstated the lawsuit Thursday and ordered it heard. The seven members ruled Mlinar has a possible argument that her paintings weren't simply lost, but that criminal activity took place. Under those circumstances, the lawsuit can be tried in state court.

UPS spokeswoman Susan Rosenberg said Thursday that the company looks forward to trying the case and that Mlinar has not provided any evidence substantiating wrongdoing by the company.

Cargo Largo did not return a phone message seeking comment.



Advertisements

Latest Economic News

  • Pfizer fined for hiking epilepsy drug price 2,600 per cent in U.K.

    Economic CTV News
    LONDON -- British regulators fined U.S. drugmaker Pfizer and distributor Flynn Pharma a record 89.4 million pounds ($112.7 million) Wednesday for increasing the cost of an epilepsy drug by as much as 2,600 per cent. Source
  • PrivateBancorp delays shareholder vote on takeover deal with CIBC

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO -- PrivateBancorp Inc. is delaying a shareholder vote on a proposed takeover of the company by Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (TSX:CM) that was set for Thursday. The U.S. bank, which says it remains committed to the deal, says a new date for the meeting is expected to be set for early in the first quarter of next year. Source
  • Thousands of Bangladesh kids working 64 hours a week: study

    Economic CTV News
    DHAKA, Bangladesh -- Thousands of Bangladeshi children who live in the capital's slums are working illegally for an average of 64 hours a week, with many employed by the garment industry making clothing for top global brands, according to a report released Wednesday. Source
  • Dollarama reports third-quarter profit and sales up from year ago

    Economic CTV News
    MONTREAL -- Dollarama Inc. (TSX:DOL) saw its third-quarter profit grow to nearly $110.1 million compared with nearly $100.1 million in the same quarter a year ago. The retailer says the profit amounted to 92 cents per diluted share, up from 78 cents per diluted share a year a year ago when it had more shares outstanding. Source
  • NHL to move to new 67-storey tower on Manhattan's west side

    Economic CTV News
    NEW YORK -- The National Hockey League is moving its headquarters to a 67-storey office tower under construction on Manhattan's west side. Developer Brookfield Property Partners announced Wednesday the NHL will move from its current location in midtown to the tower that will be known as One Manhattan West. Source
  • EU fines 3 banks $520 million over rate market rigging

    Economic CTV News
    BRUSSELS -- European Union regulators on Wednesday fined banks JPMorgan Chase, HSBC and Credit Agricole a combined $520 million for colluding to manipulate the price of financial products linked to interest rates. EU antitrust Commissioner Margrethe Vestager said the banks illegally exchanged sensitive information and colluded to make big profits in the market on the specialized financial products. Source
  • Consumer debt and delinquency rates climb in third quarter: Equifax

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO - A new Equifax Canada report says low interest rates and falling oil prices drove up consumer debt and delinquency rates in the third quarter. The credit reporting agency found that average debt increased by 3.6 per cent to $22,081 in the quarter ended Sept. Source
  • Bank of Canada to make final interest rate announcement of the year

    Economic CTV News
    OTTAWA - The Bank of Canada is set to make its last interest rate announcement of the year today. The central bank is widely expected to keep its interest rate target set at 0.5 per cent, where it has been since July 2015. Source
  • Asian stocks mostly higher on record Dow, telecom news

    Economic CTV News
    TOKYO -- Asian markets were mostly higher Wednesday, cheered by gains on Wall Street and optimism about the telecommunications industry. KEEPING SCORE: Japan's benchmark Nikkei 225 rose 0.5 per cent to 18,454.92 in morning trading. Source
  • Mother settles JetBlue lawsuit after son flown to wrong city

    Economic CTV News
    NEW YORK -- A New York City woman has agreed to settle her lawsuit against JetBlue Airways after it mixed up her 5-year-old son with another boy and flew him to the wrong city. Maribel Martinez's lawyer announced the settlement on Tuesday, saying the matter was resolved amicably. Source