Energy East application too hard to understand: National Energy Board

CALGARY -- The National Energy Board is directing TransCanada to rework its application to build the contentious Energy East pipeline because the document is too hard to understand -- even for experts.

See Full Article

The federal energy watchdog, in a letter to the Calgary-based pipeline builder (TSX:TRP), said it's not requesting a whole new application.

Rather, it wants the reams of information already filed to be repackaged in a way that is easier to navigate.

The company first submitted its application to build the Alberta-to-New-Brunswick pipeline in October 2014.

The document was 30,000 pages at the time -- filling 68 binders in 11 boxes -- and the NEB says it has since become even more unwieldy.

One of the more noteworthy changes was a decision to scrap a planned export terminal in Cacouna, Que., due to concerns over the impact on the beluga whale habitat. The project now includes only one marine export terminal in Saint John, N.B.

"When considering the numerous supplemental reports, project updates, errata and amendments coupled with the sheer volume of information presented in the application, the board is of the view that the application, in its present form, is difficult even for experts to navigate," the board wrote to TransCanada in a letter Wednesday.

"The board is concerned that it will be even more difficult for the general public to comprehend and navigate. The board is also concerned about the impact of this on the fairness and efficiency of the hearing process and the potential burdens on all parties."

TransCanada (TSX:TRP) has until Feb. 17 to provide a proposed table of contents for the revised version and let the board know when it plans to file the complete document.

"Public participation is a fundamental element of our hearing process," the board wrote.

"It is critical that, during the hearing process, participants are able to understand the application and easily locate sections of the application most relevant to their interests."

The $15.7-billion pipeline would ship a million barrels of western crude a day as far east as Saint John. The goal is to connect Canadian crude to domestic refineries as well as international customers.

TransCanada spokesman Mark Cooper said despite the additional work, the company is focused on a 2020 startup date for Energy East.

"This is an opportunity for us to restate our desire to have informed conversations with Canadians about Energy East," he said.

"Energy East is supportive of taking constructive steps to make the review process as accessible as possible. Therefore, we will take the NEB's direction and work to prepare consolidated applications in both English and French, to assist all Canadians in better understanding this important infrastructure project."


Latest Economic News

  • Asian stocks lower as investors examine company earnings

    Economic CTV News
    HONG KONG - Stocks retreated in most Asian markets on Thursday as investors assessed a fresh round of corporate earnings from major companies across the region. KEEPING SCORE: Japan's benchmark Nikkei 225 index slipped 0.5 per cent to 17,303.27 while South Korea's Kospi rose 0.3 per cent to 2,019.09. Source
  • Samsung profits plunge 17 per cent after Galaxy Note 7 recall

    Economic CTV News
    SEOUL, Korea, Republic Of -- Samsung Electronics says its third quarter profit has plunged 17 per cent as Galaxy Note 7 recalls nearly wiped out its mobile profit. The South Korean tech giant said Thursday that its July-September net income was 4.4 trillion won ($3.9 billion), down from 5.3 trillion won a year earlier. Source
  • Canadian government warns U.S. senators of potential lumber dispute consequences

    Economic CTV News
    WASHINGTON -- The Canadian government is warning U.S. politicians about the consequences of a possible new softwood-lumber dispute. A letter from International Trade Minister Chrystia Freeland and David MacNaughton, the Canadian ambassador to Washington, went out today to two dozen senators -- with a copy to President Barack Obama. Source
  • #GrabYourWallet boycott targets Trump family on the retail front

    Economic CBC News
    An eye-catching shoe piques your interest and draws you in. Upon closer inspection, the label leaps out at you — Ivanka Trump, in simple gold lettering — and you recoil as if stung. That's the kind of reaction behind a growing boycott of the products emblazoned with the brand of Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump as well as the popular, working women-targeted fashion line from his eldest daughter — who has arguably been his most influential and effective family member during the…
  • Tesla reports first quarterly profit in more than three years

    Economic CBC News
    Tesla Motors Inc. reported its first quarterly net profit in more than three years on Wednesday as record deliveries helped to offset rising expenses related to next year's roll-out of the company's mass-market Model 3 sedan. Source
  • First Nations filing lawsuit against Pacific NorthWest LNG project

    Economic CTV News
    Catherine McKenna, front right, Minister of Environment and Climate Change, speaks while flanked by Jim Carr, from left to right, Minister of Natural Resources, British Columbia Premier Christy Clark and Dominic LeBlanc, Minister of Fisheries, Oceans and the Canadian Coast Guard, after the federal government announced approval of the Pacific NorthWest LNG project, at the Sea Island Coast Guard Base, in Richmond, B.C. Source
  • Trans-Pacific Partnership trade deal doomed, ex-PM Brian Mulroney predicts

    Economic CBC News
    Former prime minister Brian Mulroney says the Trans-Pacific Partnership trade deal is doomed to fail because of hostility in the U.S. Congress. Mulroney made the prediction today after taking part in a ceremony to formally announce plans for the Brian Mulroney Institute of Government at his alma mater, St. Source
  • 'Muted' Canadian wage hikes seen next year: Conference Board

    Economic CBC News
    Canadian workers in non-union jobs can expect 'muted" wage hikes next year, with the lowest increases going to workers in Alberta and in the oil and gas industry, the Conference Board of Canada said Wednesday in a new report. Source
  • Apple struggling to keep up with demand for iPhone 7 Plus

    Economic CBC News
    Apple Inc's shares slipped as much as four per cent after the company said it was struggling to keep up with demand for its large-screen, higher-margin iPhone 7 Plus, potentially reducing sales and profits in the Christmas shopping period. Source
  • Global gender gap list puts Canada at 35th

    Economic CBC News
    Canada has come 35th — sandwiched between Luxembourg and Cape Verde — in the latest World Economic Forum annual report on gender-based disparities around the world. Iceland, Finland, Norway and Sweden are the top four countries on the WEF's Global Gender Gap index, which measures differences between men and women in economics, education, health and political empowerment among 144 countries. Source