The cash crunch of commitments: Uncosted spending vows lurk for Liberals

TORONTO -- The dimming economy is not the only challenge facing Finance Minister Bill Morneau as he puts together his first federal budget.

See Full Article

Morneau must also wrestle another major mathematical threat to Canada's bottom line: uncosted Liberal promises made during and since the election campaign.

The list is long, and many of the costs have not been made public -- something Morneau has committed to rectifying when he tables the fiscal blueprint this spring.

"What we will be doing is updating, in order to make sure that we have costings on every single one of our initiatives," Morneau told reporters last week in Toronto when asked whether he was willing to run annual shortfalls bigger than $10 billion.

"So that we can give Canadians a very clear and transparent understanding of our financial situation at the time of the budget."

The added costs would apply more fiscal pressure on a government that already appears poised to break its pledge to cap annual deficits at $10 billion over the next two years.

The government has acknowledged it faces challenges from the fading economic outlook and the fact, it says, that it inherited a weaker-than-expected fiscal situation from its predecessors.

The yet-to-be fully costed Liberal pledges include ending all boil-water advisories on aboriginal reserves within five years, delivering on all 94 recommendations from the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and lifting the two-per-cent cap on federal funding for First Nations communities.

It also promised a new federal-provincial health accord.

The Liberal platform does take into account the party's promise of $3 billion over the next four years to improve home-care services. However, the cost of a long-term funding deal with provinces and territories has yet to be determined.

The party has also referred to the need for a national housing strategy and improvements to affordable childcare, although some of those costs may be included in a plan to set aside $20 billion for social infrastructure.

During the election campaign, the Canadian Taxpayers Federation listed uncosted pledges by the major political parties. The Liberals, the group said, had yet to provide price tags for promises such as:

-- Increased funding for the Parliamentary Budget Officer.

-- Taking steps to address climate change.

-- Making environmental assessments more credible.

-- Installing electric-vehicle charging facilities in federal lots and rapidly expanding federal fleet of electric vehicles.

-- The creation of the Canada Infrastructure Bank, which would use the federal government's strong credit rating and lending authority to make it easier for municipalities to build infrastructure projects.

-- To re-engage on the 2005 Kelowna Accord, a series of agreements between the previous federal Liberal government, provinces, territories and aboriginal groups that would have provided billions of dollars to improve the standard of living for indigenous peoples.

In addition to the uncosted promises, the Liberals are also facing a common obstacle for new governments after they take power: unanticipated expenditures.

Those costs include the need for Ottawa to find $3.5 billion more to pay for the new bridge at the busy border crossing between Detroit and Windsor, Ont.

The information about the span, which will be named after hockey legend Gordie Howe, was included in a secret briefing note to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau obtained by The Canadian Press under the Access to Information Act.

The document said the extra cash is needed to make up for the sinking Canadian dollar and to establish a contingency fund to absorb the shock of any interest-rate increases.

The Trudeau briefing note also touched on another possible unexpected cost related to ongoing negotiations with the public service over sick and disability leave. The note said if a new plan isn't implemented in the 2015-16 fiscal year, then $900 million in savings for the government, booked by the Tories in last April's budget, may have to be unwound.

The Liberals also face the possibility of extra costs of their plan to resettle 25,000 Syrian refugees.

The program is expected to cost more than $1 billion over the next six years. The Liberal platform said it would cost $150 million over the next two years.

"I look forward to how Mr. Morneau is going to deal with all of those concerns," said economist Kevin Milligan, who helped cost the Liberal platform but stopped advising the party after the election.

Milligan, a professor at the University of British Columbia, said he never took a closer look at the platform's uncosted aboriginal-spending vows because he wasn't asked to do so.

But he said implementing the Truth and Reconciliation Commission recommendations would add to the government's costs.

Still, the government has also made pledges that it says will raise revenues.

Among them is a review of spending by the Harper government and a plan to target tax loopholes that particularly benefit the wealthiest Canadians. In total, the Liberals estimated the actions will generate $6.5 billion over four years.

Economist Jack Mintz said the country's struggling economy, battered by low commodity prices, only complicates the government's fiscal challenges.

"There were a lot of promises made that were not costed," said the University of Calgary economist, who also referred to the Liberals' Truth and Reconciliation Commission vow.

"What does that mean and how much is that going to cost? I mean, it will be quite an exercise if you just try doing that one alone."

Mintz said it's common for political parties to make lots of promises when they're trying to get elected.

"But you don't need to keep every one of them," he said.

"In fact, it's probably a good idea not to because some of them are impractical or not necessarily well-thought through."



Advertisements

Latest Economic News

  • Air Canada's Montreal to Japan direct flight expected to generate economic returns

    Economic CTV News
    MONTREAL -- Air Canada says it will introduce direct year-round service between Montreal and Tokyo which the business community and politicians expect will generate economic returns beyond tourism. The country's largest airline will operate year-round service starting next June to Narita airport. Source
  • Greenpeace accused of 'eco-terrorism' in lawsuit filed by Dakota Access pipeline developer

    Economic CBC News
    Energy Transfer Partners LP on Tuesday sued Greenpeace and other environmental groups, accusing them of launching an "eco-terrorism" campaign aimed at blocking the Dakota Access Pipeline, the center of months of opposition by Native American and green groups. Source
  • Twitter Canada searching for new director after Rory Capern abruptly steps down

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO - The managing director of Twitter Canada has unexpectedly stepped down a year and a half after taking on the job. Rory Capern said on Twitter that he was grateful for the chance to lead the division and was looking forward to what's next, without saying what that might be. Source
  • Realtors who break rules should face tougher penalty, says Ont. association

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO -- The Ontario Real Estate Association says it's time for higher fines for real estate agents that break the rules. The association is proposing that the fines for salespeople who violate a code of ethics double to $50,000. Source
  • Banks help lift Toronto stock index as U.S. markets give up gains

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO -- Shares of Canada's biggest banks and insurance companies are helping lift the Toronto stock market's main index today. The Toronto Stock Exchange's S&P/TSX composite index was up 67.17 points to 15,052.13, after 90 minutes of trading. Source
  • Toronto wealth management firm Wealthsimple launches 'Halal' investing portfolio

    Economic Toronto Sun
    TORONTO — Robo-adviser Wealthsimple has launched a new investment portfolio for observant Muslims, a move the company says builds off its success targeting smaller, underserviced groups of investors. The Toronto-based wealth management firm says its Halal investing portfolio is designed for those adhering to Islamic laws that prohibit investing in certain companies and financial products. Source
  • Walmart partners with Google on voice-activated shopping

    Economic CBC News
    Google is partnering with Walmart to allow customers to order thousands of products from Walmart via their smartphones or other Google devices such as the Home speaker. (Walmart) Walmart is diving into voice-activated shopping. Source
  • Record household debt to add pressure to credit cards in next downturn: Moodys

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO -- Unprecedented household debt levels will give Canadians a rude awakening on their unpaid credit card bills if another economic downturn materializes in the coming years, according to a new report issued Wednesday. Moody's Investors Service it will be closely watching Alberta and Saskatchewan for signs of increased delinquencies on consumer debt portfolios. Source
  • Wealthsimple launches Halal investing portfolio for observant Muslims

    Economic CBC News
    Robo-adviser Wealthsimple has launched a new investment portfolio for observant Muslims, a move the company says builds off its success targeting smaller, underserviced groups of investors. The Toronto-based wealth management firm says its Halal investing portfolio is designed for those adhering to Islamic laws that prohibit investing in certain companies and financial products. Source
  • Royal Bank hikes dividend after posting $2.8B quarterly profit

    Economic CBC News
    Royal Bank of Canada is reporting nearly $2.8 billion of net income for its fiscal third quarter and an unexpectedly large increase to its quarterly dividend. RBC's net income was down three per cent from last year when its bottom line was boosted by the sale of an insurance business, which also reduced the bank's overall revenue. Source