Employers can read private messages sent at work, European court rules

A European court has found that a private company was within its rights when it read an employee's personal messages he sent on a company phone during work hours and then fired him.

See Full Article

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled on Tuesday that the employee in question had breached the company's rules and his former employer had the right to monitor his messages.

Bogdan Barbulescu was fired from his position as an engineer at a Romanian firm after the company monitored his Yahoo Messenger chats for about a week in July 2007. The company showed Barbulescu had used the messenger app for personal contacts and professional ones.

The employer produced transcripts of messages Barbulescu had exchanged with his brother and his fiancée regarding personal matter such as his health and sex life.

Less than a month later, Barbulescu was fired from his job for breaching the company's rules that prohibited the use of company resources for personal purposes.

Barbulescu challenged the decision in a Romanian court, arguing that the employer had violated his right to a private life by reading his messages, but his complaint was dismissed.

In 2007, The County Court found that the employer had complied with the Labour Code rules when Barbulescu was fired and he had been properly informed about the company's policy that prohibited the use of company resources for personal purposes.

He brought the case to the European Court of Human Rights in 2008.

In its latest decision, the ECHR said it did not find it unreasonable that an employer would want to verify that employees were working on professional tasks during work hours. The court noted that the employers would need to access Barbulescu's records in order to check the Yahoo Messenger account.

"The employer had accessed Mr. Barbulescu account in the belief that it contained client-related communications," the ECHR said in a press release.



Advertisements

Latest Economic News

  • Taiwanese iPhone assembler Foxconn may invest $7B in U.S. plant

    Economic CTV News
    Foxconn, a major assembler of iPhones and other electronics, may invest $7 billion in a plant for manufacturing display panels that would create as many as 50,000 jobs in the U.S. Foxconn CEO Terry Gou discussed the potential expansion Sunday during a company meeting in Taiwan, the company's home country. Source
  • B.C. aims for diversified economy, as jobs targets missed on mines and LNG

    Economic CTV News
    VICTORIA -- Premier Christy Clark says her government's retooled jobs plan aims to make British Columbia the most diversified economy in Canada. The premier admitted during a five-year update on her jobs plan that the government missed previous targets for students, on growth in mines and for the liquefied natural gas industry. Source
  • Vancouver's housing market third most expensive in the world: survey

    Economic CTV News
    VANCOUVER -- An annual international survey rates Vancouver as the third least affordable housing market on the planet and it also has a warning about Toronto housing. The 2017 Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey gives Vancouver a rating of 11.8, meaning median home prices are 11.8 times higher than median household income. Source
  • Documents reveal concerns, effects of CPP benefit limits for widows and widowers

    Economic CTV News
    OTTAWA -- Sheila was 62 when her husband died. For three years she continued to work full time as a nurse, collecting survivor benefits under the Canada Pension Plan. When Sheila retired at age 65 and began collecting her CPP retirement pension, she bumped into the financial ceiling the government places on the amounts retirees can receive under the public pension scheme and the survivor pension disappeared. Source
  • Canada should distance itself from Mexico in NAFTA talks: Former U.S. ambassador

    Economic CTV News
    Canada should distance itself from Mexico as U.S. President Donald Trump seeks to abolish or renegotiate the three-nation North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), according to a former Canadian ambassador to the U.S. Derek Burney, who helped negotiate the Canada-United States Free Trade Agreement under then-Prime Minister Brian Mulroney, believes Canada and Mexico’s trade agendas share little common ground. Source
  • Striking Chronicle Herald workers mark one-year anniversary of labour dispute

    Economic CTV News
    HALIFAX -- The union representing striking workers at the Halifax Chronicle Herald are holding rallies throughout Nova Scotia Monday to mark the one-year anniversary of the labour dispute. The Halifax Typographical Union, which went on strike last Jan. Source
  • Why Trump will find it hard to make American economy greater

    Economic CTV News
    WASHINGTON -- President Donald Trump's economic plans are nothing if not ambitious: Annual growth of 4 per cent -- or more. A diminished trade gap. The creation of 25 million jobs over 10 years, including the return of good-paying factory positions. Source
  • Lawsuit: Donald Trump businesses violate U.S. Constitution

    Economic CTV News
    NEW YORK -- A lawsuit Monday alleged that U.S. President Donald Trump is violating the Constitution by allowing his business to accept payments from foreign governments. Trump is violating the so-called emoluments clause in the Constitution that prohibits him from receiving money from diplomats for stays at his hotels or foreign governments for leases of office space in his buildings, according to the suit filed by a legal watchdog group. Source
  • Brookfield moves to simplify North American property arm

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO -- The largest shareholder of Brookfield Canada Office Properties (TSX:BOX.UN) is offering to buy the rest of the real estate trust's equity for $30.10 cash per unit, a 14.8 per cent premium to Friday's closing price in Toronto. Source
  • Donald Trump signs executive order officially pulling U.S. out of TPP

    Economic CBC News
    The new U.S. president doubled down on some of his campaign promises on Monday, including punitive tax hikes for U.S. companies that ship jobs overseas and sharp reductions in corporate taxes, red tape and regulations. Source