Employers can read private messages sent at work, European court rules

A European court has found that a private company was within its rights when it read an employee's personal messages he sent on a company phone during work hours and then fired him.

See Full Article

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled on Tuesday that the employee in question had breached the company's rules and his former employer had the right to monitor his messages.

Bogdan Barbulescu was fired from his position as an engineer at a Romanian firm after the company monitored his Yahoo Messenger chats for about a week in July 2007. The company showed Barbulescu had used the messenger app for personal contacts and professional ones.

The employer produced transcripts of messages Barbulescu had exchanged with his brother and his fiancée regarding personal matter such as his health and sex life.

Less than a month later, Barbulescu was fired from his job for breaching the company's rules that prohibited the use of company resources for personal purposes.

Barbulescu challenged the decision in a Romanian court, arguing that the employer had violated his right to a private life by reading his messages, but his complaint was dismissed.

In 2007, The County Court found that the employer had complied with the Labour Code rules when Barbulescu was fired and he had been properly informed about the company's policy that prohibited the use of company resources for personal purposes.

He brought the case to the European Court of Human Rights in 2008.

In its latest decision, the ECHR said it did not find it unreasonable that an employer would want to verify that employees were working on professional tasks during work hours. The court noted that the employers would need to access Barbulescu's records in order to check the Yahoo Messenger account.

"The employer had accessed Mr. Barbulescu account in the belief that it contained client-related communications," the ECHR said in a press release.



Advertisements

Latest Economic News

  • Barrick, Goldcorp joining forces to work on projects in Chile

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO - Two of Canada's biggest gold companies are creating a new joint venture to advance several mining projects clustered in northern Chile. The joint venture will be owned equally by Toronto-based Barrick Gold Corp. Source
  • What makes a cyberattack? Experts lobby to restrict the term

    Economic CTV News
    LONDON -- When U.S. senator John McCain told Ukrainian television that the allegedly Russian-backed breach of the Democratic National Committee's server was "an act of war," Michael Schmitt cringed. Schmitt, a professor of law at the U.S. Source
  • CEO of International Air Transport Association criticizes electronics device ban

    Economic CTV News
    MONTREAL -- The head of the International Air Transport Association says it's difficult to understand how banning electronic devices in carry-on baggage on flights will improve security. In a prepared text of a speech Tuesday, IATA CEO Alexandre de Juniac called on governments to work with the transport industry to ensure passengers aren't separated from their laptops, tablets and other devices. Source
  • Former Valeant CEO suing company over unpaid shares

    Economic CBC News
    Former Valeant Pharmaceuticals CEO Michael Pearson is suing his former employer for breach of contract for failing to deliver more than three million shares and consulting fees. In a lawsuit filed Monday in the U.S., Pearson alleges that Valeant breached his separation agreement by refusing to hand over 580,676 restricted share units and about 2.4 million performance share awards he was granted. Source
  • Cruise line stops port calls at Mexican resort of Acapulco

    Economic CTV News
    MEXICO CITY - The U.S. cruise ship line Holland America says it has halted port calls at Mexico's troubled resort city of Acapulco and will sail to other destinations in the country "due to recent security concerns. Source
  • Home Capital shares dive after company terminates CEO

    Economic CBC News
    Shares of Home Capital Group Inc. traded down more than seven per cent on the TSX on Tuesday, a day after the company said it had terminated its top executive. Home Capital announced Monday after stock markets had closed that that Martin Reid, its president and CEO, was out, effective immediately. Source
  • Elon Musk's latest venture: Brain-computer interfaces

    Economic CTV News
    NEW YORK -- Tech billionaire Elon Musk is announcing a new venture called Neuralink focused on linking brains to computers. The company plans to develop brain implants that can treat neural disorders and may one day be powerful enough to put humanity on a more even footing with future superintelligent computers, according to a Wall Street Journal report citing unnamed sources. Source
  • Former Valeant CEO Michael Pearson sues for breach of contract

    Economic CTV News
    MONTREAL -- Former Valeant Pharmaceuticals CEO Michael Pearson is suing his former employer for breach of contract for failing to deliver more than three million shares and consulting fees. In a lawsuit filed Monday in the U.S. Source
  • Ford investing $1.2B in 3 Michigan plants, adding 130 jobs

    Economic CTV News
    DETROIT -- Ford Motor Co. is investing US$1.2 billion in three Michigan facilities, including an engine plant where it plans to add 130 jobs. U.S. President Donald Trump applauded the move in an early morning tweet. Source
  • Purolator stops accepting new shipments as strike deadline nears

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO - Purolator stopped accepting shipments today ahead of a strike deadline this afternoon issued by the union representing some of the courier's employees. Teamsters Canada issued the 72-hour strike notice Sunday after its members voted to reject Purolator's final offer. Source