Court upholds $118 million award against Livent auditor Deloitte

TORONTO -- The corporate auditor to the once high-flying Livent theatre company run by disgraced mogul Garth Drabinsky was partly responsible for the hundreds of millions of dollars creditors ended up losing, Ontario's top court ruled Friday.

See Full Article

In upholding an $85.6-million award against Deloitte and Touche -- $118 million with interest -- the Court of Appeal sided with a judge who found the auditor had been negligent in failing to detect, and act on, the fraudulent behaviour of Drabinsky and his partner, Myron Gottlieb, in the 1990s.

After all, there had been numerous red flags for several years that Deloitte essentially ignored, the court found.

"Deloitte knew that Drabinsky and Gottlieb were aggressive entrepreneurs who pushed the envelope in terms of accounting and financial measures," the Appeal Court said in a 100-page judgment.

"It is more likely than not that a careful and objective investigation into Livent's financial statements, pursued with 'an attitude of professional skepticism,' would have revealed the fraud."

Under the flamboyant Drabinsky, Livent Inc. brought popular shows like "Phantom of the Opera," "Show Boat," "Kiss of the Spider Woman," and "Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat" to stages across North America. But the apparent success was based on a massive sleight of hand that included cooking the books, kickbacks and manipulated expenses.

The shenanigans were discovered in mid-1998 when a new management team took over. Within months, Livent went bust -- leaving investors and banks about $500 million out of pocket. Drabinsky and Gottlieb went to prison for fraud and forgery.

Livent's bankruptcy receiver sued Deloitte -- which had audited the company's books from 1989 through to 1998 -- on behalf of those owed money.

In a novel ruling that followed a 68-day trial in April 2014, Superior Court Justice Arthur Gans found Deloitte largely liable for Livent's losses after August 1997, saying company creditors had been hapless victims of a fraud the auditor should have brought to their attention had it done a proper job.

Barring such a claim, Gans said, would deprive innocent parties a remedy for an auditor's negligence in those cases where the services of an auditor are most critical -- namely, the detection of wrongdoing by high-level management.

Deloitte appealed, arguing among other things that it should not have been held responsible for the fraud, or for the fact investors lost money.

The Appeal Court disagreed, siding with the judge's finding the auditor was liable for most of the post-August 1997 losses.

Deloitte knew the impresarios were using Livent's financial statements to help them raise money but failed miserably in scrutinizing those statements, the Appeal Court found. In addition, the court rejected Deloitte's argument that Livent's losses all flowed from the "inherent vicissitudes" of its risky business rather than from its failure do to a proper audit.

"The trial judge distinguished between losses generated from Livent's unprofitable but legitimate theatre business, operating within the changed environment, and those losses attributable to Deloitte's negligence," the Appeal Court ruled.

The court also dismissed a Livent cross-appeal that sought to extend the period of losses for which Deloitte should have been liable.

In a statement, a spokeswoman for Deloitte said it needed time to review the decision before deciding on any next steps.

"The audit and legal issues in this case are exceptionally complex and important -- not only to the audit profession but to the broader business community," Emily Richardson said.



Advertisements

Latest Economic News

  • Trans Mountain activity slowed by permits, Kinder Morgan Canada says

    Economic CTV News
    CALGARY -- Kinder Morgan Canada Ltd. (TSX:KML) said Wednesday that it's already facing potentially months of delay on the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion project because of the timing of permits and regulatory approvals. "If you just took the delays experienced to date, and just flowed that through the schedule, we believe that results in a nine-month delay," said CEO Steve Kean during a conference call following the company's third-quarter earnings release. Source
  • Dow Jones industrial average closes above 23,000 for 1st time

    Economic CBC News
    The Dow Jones industrial average closed above the 23,000 level for the first time on Wednesday, driven by a jump in IBM after the computing giant hinted at a return to revenue growth. The close above 23,000 came just 54 trading days after the Dow hit 22,000 on Aug. Source
  • CMHC sizes up worst-case scenarios for housing market and comes out unscathed

    Economic CBC News
    The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation has crunched numbers on the assumption that the economy could get rocked by any number of different calamities and come to the same conclusion: the corporation itself would be all right. Source
  • Big elevator companies blast Ontario bill, safety agency in new report

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO -- Canada's major elevator companies, which have come under scrutiny for breakdowns and delayed repairs, are warning that proposed Ontario legislation aimed at enhancing reliability of the devices in the country's largest market could have dire consequences if enacted. Source
  • Wooing Amazon with sun, fun ... and giant buttons

    Economic CTV News
    BOSTON -- Mayors from Toledo to Tulsa are so eager to woo Amazon's much-vaunted second headquarters that they're brandishing bourbon, selling the sun, whispering sweet nothings to the company and even pushing its buttons. Literally. Source
  • Last day Sears Canada will honour extended warranties

    Economic Toronto Sun
    TORONTO — Today is the last day Sears Canada Inc. will honour extended warranties as the retailer prepares to start liquidation sales Thursday. Sears Canada said earlier this week that only customers who bought a protection agreement within the past 30 days could get refunds from paying for extended coverage. Source
  • Delta says it did not play a role in Airbus-Bombardier deal

    Economic CBC News
    Delta Air Lines Inc.'s chief executive on Wednesday said the carrier did not play a role in pushing an industry-changing deal between planemakers Airbus and Bombardier Inc., as a regulatory spat between the United States and Canada threatened the future of a Bombardier plane program. Source
  • Delta says it had no role in Airbus-Bombardier deal

    Economic CBC News
    Delta Air Lines Inc.'s chief executive on Wednesday said the carrier did not play a role in pushing an industry-changing deal between planemakers Airbus and Bombardier Inc., as a regulatory spat between the United States and Canada threatened the future of a Bombardier plane program. Source
  • CMHC says it can withstand a severe shock as it passes stress test scenarios

    Economic CTV News
    OTTAWA -- Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. says stress testing has confirmed its mortgage loan insurance and securitization businesses are able to withstand a severe shock. The housing agency tested the strength of its businesses against several extreme scenarios. Source
  • Liberals continue tax change tour, narrow scope of passive-income measure

    Economic CBC News
    Finance Minister Bill Morneau is continuing to pull and pluck away at his government's controversial tax regime proposals, promising now to adjust the rules on passive income so only three per cent of the "most wealthy" privately owned corporations will have to pay higher taxes. Source