U.S. Federal Reserve betting it will avoid central banks' past errors

LONDON -- The Federal Reserve is poised to raise interest rates Wednesday for the first time in 9 1/2 years.

See Full Article

It may not take so long to know whether its decision was correct.

History is filled with cases, from the Fed in the 1930s to the European Central Bank in 2011, when central banks raised rates prematurely, sometimes with dire consequences. Raising rates or otherwise tightening credit too soon can slow borrowing, jolt confidence and choke growth.

When the global financial system started buckling in 2007, central banks cut rates to fight the worst economic catastrophe since the 1930s. As the crisis escalated in late 2008, many rates were slashed to record lows. The Fed cut its benchmark rate to near zero.

Mindful of the risks of higher rates and of the U.S. economy's lingering weaknesses, some economists have suggested that the Fed could wait a bit longer before raising rates, especially with inflation still low amid slumping oil and commodity prices. In a survey of top academic economists, the University of Chicago found that while 48 per centfavoured a rate hike, 36 per cent felt the Fed should hold off.

Andrew Levin of Dartmouth College is among those who think the Fed is acting too soon.

"The economy is not that close to normal yet," Levin says. "Inflation has been persistently falling short of the Fed's target."

Levin notes, too, that while the unemployment rate is a low 5 per cent, millions without jobs have given up looking for one. Levin says employers would have to add 200,000 jobs a month for at least another year to restore the job market's health.

For any central bank, the hardest task is to continually straddle a delicate balance:

Keeping rates too low for too long can inflate asset bubbles as investors seek returns that are higher -- but riskier -- than returns on government debt. Low rates can also weaken the ability of central banks to combat a new crisis or recession.

But equally, central bankers must take care not to increase rates too soon. Since the global financial crisis, several central banks, from Israel's to New Zealand's, have raised rates only to have to reverse course soon after.

Chair Janet Yellen summed it up in a speech Dec. 2. Yellen said delaying a first increase too long might later compel the Fed to raise rates faster than it would like.

"An abrupt tightening would risk disrupting financial markets and perhaps even inadvertently push the economy into recession," she said. "Holding the federal funds rate at its current level for too long could also encourage excessive risk-taking and thus undermine financial stability."

Here are some examples when history suggests central banks should have waited longer to tighten credit.


In 1936-37, during the Great Depression era, the Fed sought to normalize its policies by increasing the amount of money banks had to hold as reserves. Many blame that decision, along with a tougher budgetary stance from the U.S. government, for helping prolong the Depression. The economy fell back into a brutal recession in which around 2.5 million Americans lost jobs.

By 1938, President Franklin Roosevelt reverted back to the expansionist policies associated with the New Deal that he had been implementing since 1933. And the Fed rescinded the increased reserve requirement. The economy then enjoyed a spectacular recovery, helped by wartime spending.

In a 2012 speech, Charles Evans, head of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, warned of a "natural tendency" for policymakers to want to undo super-low rates.

"Such errors happened in 1937 when the Fed prematurely withdrew accommodation," Evans noted.


Ben Bernanke, the Fed chairman during the 2008 crisis, was a keen student of Japan's experience after the bursting of a stock and housing bubble in 1990. A quarter-century later, Japan still confronts the repercussions of that shock, notably deflation, or falling prices.

In August 2000, barely a year after the Bank of Japan adopted a zero rate policy, it raised rates for the first time in a decade. It justified that move by noting that confidence was returning and prices were rising. But a few months later, the central bank was compelled to cut rates again as Japan's economy slid back into recession and prices fell again.

Japan's experience reflects the risks of raising rates when inflation is negligible, as it now is in the United States.


The European Central Bank, which sets rates for the 19 countries that use the euro, is enacting a huge stimulus program intended to ease borrowing rates. The ECB's program marks a sharp policy reversal. In 2011, the ECB raised rates twice, boosting its benchmark rate to 1.50 per cent. The bank, then led by Jean-Claude Trichet, said it needed to reduce inflation pressures in the eurozone.

By year's end, the ECB, now led by Mario Draghi, changed course as the rate hikes and export-sapping appreciation of the euro pushed the economy back into recession. The region was also fighting a debt crisis that threatened the euro itself.

Critics regard the 2011 rate increases as a major policy mistake.

Paul Wiseman contributed to this report from Washington.


Latest Economic News

  • Lululemon warns Ottawa it could move headquarters out of Canada

    Economic CTV News
    Vancouver-based retailer Lululemon has threatened it could move its headquarters out of Canada if federal regulators don’t grant them an exemption to the Temporary Foreign Workers (TFW) program. The popular apparel company wrote a letter submitted to the House of Commons Finance Committee in late July seeking an exemption to the program in order to expand its business and remain in Canada. Source
  • Precision Drilling had $47 million net loss for third quarter

    Economic CTV News
    CALGARY - Precision Drilling Corp. had a $47 million net loss for the third quarter as revenue declined 45 per cent from last year. The loss amounted to 16 cents per share, which was an improvement from the Calgary-based drilling company's 2015 third quarter loss of $87 million or 30 cents per share. Source
  • Second wave of cuts as Bombardier slashes 7,500 jobs

    Economic Toronto Sun
    MONTREAL — A second large wave of job cuts is hitting Bombardier workers in less than a year as another 7,500 positions are to be eliminated around the world through the end of 2018. About 2,000 positions will be cut across Canada, including 1,500 in Quebec. Source
  • Death from overwork in Japan shows lessons unlearned

    Economic CTV News
    TOKYO -- Matsuri Takahashi's dream career at Japan's top ad agency, Dentsu, ended with her suicide as her overtime pushed past 100 hours a month. "I'm emotionless and only wish to sleep," she wrote, exhausted and depressed, in a Twitter post in October 2015, six months after starting the job. Source
  • Bombardier cutting 7,500 jobs over next two years

    Economic CTV News
    MONTREAL - Bombardier says it is cutting another 7,500 jobs around the world over the next two years, including about 2,000 across Canada. The Montreal-based plane and train maker says the reductions designed to save about US$300 million a year are part of its plan to restore its profitability by 2020. Source
  • Canadians becoming less dependent on banks: EY report

    Economic CTV News
    TORONTO - A new survey from EY suggests Canadians are becoming less dependent upon their banks as the main providers of financial services. The business consultancy firm says a quarter of those polled agreed with the statement, "I'm less reliant on established (financial services) companies and banks these days, as there are more options to self-manage my finances. Source
  • Deadline looming for Canada-EU trade pact

    Economic CTV News
    OTTAWA - They're listening carefully to the noisy argument spilling out of their neighbour's house - but for the moment they're giving the appearance of keeping their noses out of it. That essentially is the Canadian government's position with the deadline looming for European Union countries to approve their wide-ranging free trade deal with Canada. Source
  • BAT offers to buy Reynolds in $47B deal

    Economic CTV News
    LONDON - British American Tobacco has offered to buy Reynolds American Inc. in a $47 billion cash-and-stock deal. The London-based company offered Friday to buy the 57.8 per cent of Reynolds it doesn't already own for the equivalent of $56.50 per share. Source
  • $47B offer to create world's biggest tobacco company

    Economic CTV News
    LONDON -- British American Tobacco is offering to buy Reynolds American Inc. in a $47 billion deal that would create the world's largest publicly traded tobacco company and attempt to make up for a decline in smoking in the U.S. Source
  • Asian shares mixed on European Central Bank stimulus hopes

    Economic CTV News
    HONG KONG - Asia stock markets drifted Friday as oil prices slid. The dollar rallied after Europe's central bank kept the door open for more monetary stimulus, leaving investor sentiment mixed. KEEPING SCORE: Japan's benchmark Nikkei 225 index rose 0.3 per cent to 17,285.53 but South Korea's Kospi lost 0.3 per cent to 2,032.85. Source