Crown lawyers say no new trials needed for Shafia trio

TORONTO -- Crown lawyers are asking Ontario's top court to reject an attempt by a man convicted in the murders of four family members to bring fresh evidence that he claims proves he was a minor at the time of the deaths.

See Full Article

Even if the court does accept the evidence, the Crown says there's no need to grant new trials for Hamed Shafia and his parents, who were all tried together for the murders of the couple's three daughters and another family member.

Shafia has asked the Ontario Court of Appeal to grant him a fresh trial in a youth court because of newly discovered documents that he says prove he was actually 17 and not 18 at the time of the offences.

But Crown lawyer Gillian Roberts calls the documents unreliable and says Shafia's trial itself was "fair, the verdict reliable and there's no reason to have another trial or trials for him and his parents."

She says if the court accepts that Hamed Shafia is a year younger than previously thought, he would be entitled to a new sentencing hearing, but there has been no miscarriage of justice in the case.

Shafia's age argument is being made while he and his parents all seek new trials, claiming jointly that their original one was tainted by "highly prejudicial" testimony on so-called honour killings.

The three were convicted in 2012 of four counts of first-degree murder -- killings the trial judge described as being motivated by their "twisted concept of honour."

The Crown will be making its own arguments against the issues raised about the original trial later Friday.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Navy sailor killed at Pearl Harbor buried in California

    World News CTV News
    FILE - In this Dec. 27, 2016, file photo, USS Arizona Memorial, part of the World War II Valor in the Pacific National Monument, at Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam, Hawaii. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster, File) Source
  • Eritrean diaspora watches Ethiopia thaw with hope, mistrust

    World News CBC News
    The sudden thaw between longtime enemies Eritrea and Ethiopia is opening up a world of possibilities for the neighbouring countries' residents: new economic and diplomatic ties, telephone and transport links and the end to one of Africa's most bitter feuds. Source
  • Fredericton Police investigating after cyclist dies in collision with car

    Canada News CTV News
    FREDERICTON -- A 55-year-old woman has died, a day after she was hit by a car while riding her bicycle in Fredericton, N.B. The Fredericton Police Force says officers responded to the collision on Ring Road, west of Royal Road, Friday afternoon. Source
  • Are duck boats safe? Concerns raised after Branson, Mo. tragedy

    Canada News CTV News
    Safety experts are raising concerns about duck boats after one of these amphibious vessels sank in Branson, Mo., leaving 17 people dead. On Friday, strong wind gusts suddenly hit Branson and left a tourist duck boat stranded in the waters of Table Rock Lake, killing 17 of the 29 people on board. Source
  • Judge Brett Kavanaugh unveils his most important judgments to Congress

    World News CBC News
    U.S. President Donald Trump's choice for the Supreme Court has given members of Congress piles of material to help them start judging the judge. Judge Brett Kavanaugh responded to a Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaire that probes his career as an attorney and jurist, service in the executive branch, education and society memberships. Source
  • HMCS St. John's to return to Halifax after six-month deployment overseas

    Canada News CTV News
    HALIFAX -- The countdown is on for the homecoming of a Halifax-class navy ship and its 240-member crew. HMCS St. John's is expected to return to its home port of Halifax on Monday after a six-month deployment in the Baltic Sea, northern Atlantic Ocean and the Mediterranean Sea. Source
  • 2 Uncle Ben's rice varieties recalled in eastern Canada

    Canada News CBC News
    Mars Food Canada is voluntarily recalling select Uncle Ben's rice products, including its Fast & Fancy Broccoli and Cheddar, and Country Chicken flavoured rice, after learning about possible salmonella contamination in the seasoning pouches in both products. The recall only affects products sold in eastern Canada. Source
  • Democratic socialism surging in the age of Trump

    World News CTV News
    PORTLAND, Maine -- A week ago, Maine Democrat Zak Ringelstein wasn't quite ready to consider himself a member of the Democratic Socialists of America, even if he appreciated the organization's values and endorsement in his bid to become a U.S. Source
  • Ailing Sergio Marchionne replaced by Jeep executive Mike Manley at Fiat Chrysler

    World News CBC News
    Fiat Chrysler Automobile announced Saturday that CEO Sergio Marchionne's health had suddenly deteriorated following surgery and that its board of directors had chosen Jeep executive Mike Manley to replace him. Marchionne, a 66-year-old Italian-Canadian, joined Fiat in 2004 and led the Turin-based company's merger with bankrupt U.S. Source
  • DFO announces another fishing closure after recent right whale sightings

    Canada News CTV News
    HALIFAX - The Department of Fisheries and Oceans has announced another fishing closure in Atlantic Canada after two North Atlantic right whales were spotted in the Bay of Fundy. They say an area in the Grand Manan Basin -- a critical habitat area for the endangered species -- will be closed to fishing beginning Sunday at 6 p.m. Source