Crown lawyers say no new trials needed for Shafia trio

TORONTO -- Crown lawyers are asking Ontario's top court to reject an attempt by a man convicted in the murders of four family members to bring fresh evidence that he claims proves he was a minor at the time of the deaths.

See Full Article

Even if the court does accept the evidence, the Crown says there's no need to grant new trials for Hamed Shafia and his parents, who were all tried together for the murders of the couple's three daughters and another family member.

Shafia has asked the Ontario Court of Appeal to grant him a fresh trial in a youth court because of newly discovered documents that he says prove he was actually 17 and not 18 at the time of the offences.

But Crown lawyer Gillian Roberts calls the documents unreliable and says Shafia's trial itself was "fair, the verdict reliable and there's no reason to have another trial or trials for him and his parents."

She says if the court accepts that Hamed Shafia is a year younger than previously thought, he would be entitled to a new sentencing hearing, but there has been no miscarriage of justice in the case.

Shafia's age argument is being made while he and his parents all seek new trials, claiming jointly that their original one was tainted by "highly prejudicial" testimony on so-called honour killings.

The three were convicted in 2012 of four counts of first-degree murder -- killings the trial judge described as being motivated by their "twisted concept of honour."

The Crown will be making its own arguments against the issues raised about the original trial later Friday.


Latest Canada & World News

  • Republican concedes Pennsylvania U.S. House race to Democrat amid anti-Trump surge

    World News CBC News
    Republican Rick Saccone conceded defeat to Democrat Conor Lamb on Wednesday night in a closely watched special election in Pennsylvania, more than a week after the end of a remarkable race that has shaken Republican confidence ahead of the November midterm elections. Source
  • White House issues threat over leaked Trump briefing papers

    World News CTV News
    U.S. President Donald Trump, right, and Russia's President Vladimir Putin talk during the family photo session at the APEC Summit in Danang, Saturday, Nov. 11, 2017. (Mikhail Klimentyev, Sputnik, Kremlin Pool Photo via AP) Source
  • RCMP get their man after chase with snowmobiles, helicopter

    Canada News CTV News
    VULCAN, Alta. -- RCMP in southern Alberta have arrested a suspected thief following a chase that included a helicopter, snowmobiles, a police dog team and the suspect's Labrador retriever. Mounties say an officer responded to reports of a stolen snowmobile and stopped a truck towing the machine on a highway. Source
  • Exhibit confronts Canada's rejection of Jewish refugees fleeing Nazis in 1939

    Canada News CTV News
    OTTAWA -- A new exhibition at the Canadian War Museum is shedding light on a dark chapter in Canada’s history, when more than 900 Jews aboard the St. Louis who were escaping Nazi Germany were rejected by Ottawa, and forced back to Europe, where 254 passengers were killed in death camps. Source
  • Former Supreme Court of Canada chief justice Beverley McLachlin to be judge in Hong Kong

    World News CBC News
    Hong Kong's top court has appointed former Supreme Court chief justice Beverley McLachlin to sit as a non-permanent common-law judge on the Court of Final Appeal. McLachlin, who recently retired from Canada's Supreme Court, will take up her new role once her appointment is endorsed by the Legislative Council, an elected body in Hong Kong that functions as a parliament or legislature. Source
  • 'This Wild West era's got to end': Facebook breach energizes UK lawmakers

    World News CBC News
    It is delicious irony that to uncover some of our worst fears about online data privacy and misinformation, it took old-fashioned journalists — the venerated British press — and an equally old-school method of whistleblowing. It's not for others' lack of trying. Source
  • Peru's president offers resignation amid political turmoil

    World News CBC News
    Embattled Peruvian President Pedro Pablo Kuczynski offered his resignation Wednesday ahead of an impeachment vote, seeking to put an end to a fast-moving political drama playing out just three weeks before the Andean nation is set to host U.S. Source
  • Icy waterfall rescue nets man on date a bravery medal, couple now engaged

    Canada News CTV News
    VICTORIA -- A hiking date for a Vancouver Island couple turned into a life-saving rescue that earned Janson Chapman a bravery medal and now a lifetime partner. Chapman, a golf course greens keeper from Colwood, was one of 46 people honoured today with medals of service by Gov. Source
  • Montreal man accused in U.S. airport stabbing faces new terrorism charge

    Canada News CTV News
    FLINT, Mich. -- U.S. federal prosecutors have added a terrorism charge to the case of a Montreal man who is accused of stabbing a police officer at a Michigan airport in June. Amor Ftouhi, a native of Tunisia, has been charged with stabbing an officer in the neck at Flint's Bishop International Airport while yelling "Allahu Akbar," the Arabic phrase for "God is great. Source
  • Parents turn to GPS tracking devices after Montreal boy disappears

    Canada News CTV News
    Montreal police have received more than 700 tips about a missing boy who vanished nine days ago, but investigators still don’t know what happened to the child. Ariel Jeffrey Kouakou disappeared on March 12 after walking to a friend’s house. Source