Crown lawyers say no new trials needed for Shafia trio

TORONTO -- Crown lawyers are asking Ontario's top court to reject an attempt by a man convicted in the murders of four family members to bring fresh evidence that he claims proves he was a minor at the time of the deaths.

See Full Article

Even if the court does accept the evidence, the Crown says there's no need to grant new trials for Hamed Shafia and his parents, who were all tried together for the murders of the couple's three daughters and another family member.

Shafia has asked the Ontario Court of Appeal to grant him a fresh trial in a youth court because of newly discovered documents that he says prove he was actually 17 and not 18 at the time of the offences.

But Crown lawyer Gillian Roberts calls the documents unreliable and says Shafia's trial itself was "fair, the verdict reliable and there's no reason to have another trial or trials for him and his parents."

She says if the court accepts that Hamed Shafia is a year younger than previously thought, he would be entitled to a new sentencing hearing, but there has been no miscarriage of justice in the case.

Shafia's age argument is being made while he and his parents all seek new trials, claiming jointly that their original one was tainted by "highly prejudicial" testimony on so-called honour killings.

The three were convicted in 2012 of four counts of first-degree murder -- killings the trial judge described as being motivated by their "twisted concept of honour."

The Crown will be making its own arguments against the issues raised about the original trial later Friday.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Montreal police accused of trying to silence whistleblowers

    Canada News CTV News
    Montreal chief of police Philippe Pichet is asking Quebec’s provincial officers to investigate after allegations that some members of his force fabricated evidence in order to silence whistleblowers within the force. Pichet told CTV Montreal on Wednesday that he is “very concerned about the fact that people said that we are fabricating some evidence” following a report Tuesday on the French-language station TVA. Source
  • Canadian educator in northern Quebec among finalists for Global Teacher Prize

    Canada News CTV News
    MONTREAL -- A teacher from northern Quebec is in the running for the prestigious US$1-million Global Teacher Prize. The Varkey Foundation says Maggie MacDonnell has been named a top-10 finalist for the award, which will be handed out in Dubai on March 19. Source
  • Ontario science teacher takes stand in defence of anti-vaccination allegations

    Canada News CTV News
    TORONTO -- An Ontario science teacher accused of pushing anti-vaccination views and berating a public health nurse assigned to work at his high school has taken the stand in his defence. Timothy C. Sullivan is testifying before the Ontario College of Teachers on the second day of his disciplinary hearing on allegations of professional misconduct. Source
  • 5 federal by-elections in April will be the 1st major test of Trudeau government

    Canada News CBC News
    Prime Minister Justin Trudeau today announced five byelections will be held on April 3, the first major electoral test for the Liberal government since its election more than 16 months ago. The byelections will be held in the ridings of:Saint-Laurent (Quebec). Source
  • Charge laid months after 14 dogs die in Sask. kennel of heat exhaustion

    Canada News CBC News
    A 50-year-old man has been charged with negligence after 14 dogs died of heat exhaustion at a Saskatoon dog kennel last year.Former Saskatoon kennel employee says 14 dog deaths could have been avoided'We are heartbroken,' says manager of Saskatoon kennel where 14 dogs diedAn investigation by the Saskatoon SPCA and Saskatoon Police Service found the dogs were left unattended overnight at the Playful Paws Pet Centre in September 2016. Source
  • Canadian promise to bring in Yazidis hailed by refugees

    Canada News CTV News
    DOHUK, Iraq - Canada's promise to welcome hundreds of Yazidis by the end of the year is being welcomed inside Iraq, where Yazidi women and girls have endured horrific abuse and persecution at the hands of the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant. Source
  • Pedestrian killed by CTrain was likely distracted by cell, headphones: police

    Canada News CTV News
    Police say a man who was fatally hit by a light rail transit train Monday in Calgary was likely distracted by his cell phone and headphones at the time of the accident. The 30-year-old man was killed after being hit by a CTrain at Calgary’s Whitehorn LRT Station around 8 p.m. Source
  • Black Canadians you probably don't know, but should

    Canada News CTV News
    Most Canadians are familiar with black Canadian icons such as Harriet Tubman, who helped slaves find freedom along the Underground Railroad, or Viola Desmond, a businesswoman who publicly challenged racial segregation, but there are a number of lesser-known black Canadian entrepreneurs, business leaders and community advocates who also deserve attention for their society-shaping contributions to this country’s history. Source
  • Thousands flee, freeway shut in flooding near San Francisco

    World News CTV News
    SAN JOSE, Calif. -- Rising floodwaters sent at least 14,000 residents fleeing inundated homes in San Jose, California, and forced the shutdown of a major freeway Wednesday. U.S. 101 was closed in both directions south of San Francisco because of water across lanes and officials said there was no estimate when the key commuter artery into Silicon Valley would reopen. Source
  • Trump lays out tougher approach to illegal immigration

    World News CTV News
    WASHINGTON -- Donald Trump the presidential candidate made no secret of his desire to crack down on illegal immigration, but once elected, he repeatedly offered varying interpretations of just how tough he would be in the White House. Source