ICBC found liable for malicious prosecution

VANCOUVER -- A British Columbia judge has awarded a woman who "experienced the wrath" of the province's insurance corporation nearly $400,000.

See Full Article

Supreme Court Justice Susan Griffin said in a written decision released Wednesday that the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia and one of its investigators are liable for malicious prosecution, and that their conduct in the case was high-handed and reprehensible.

Danica Arsenovski and her husband had recently come to Canada as refugees from the former Yugoslavia when they were struck by a car and injured while crossing an intersection in Burnaby in January 2000.

After the crash, Arsenovski gave a statement to ICBC through a translator because she does not speak much English.

The statement detailed the injuries she received and what she remembered about the crash, but did not specifically say whether Arsenovski herself had been struck by the car or whether she had fallen when her husband was struck and fell into her.

Arsenovski was later charged with making a false statement.

Griffin wrote in her decision that John Gould, the ICBC investigator in the case, wrote a misleading report to Crown counsel recommending the charge, intending to dissuade civil claims against the insurance agency.

The report alleged Arsenovski had "clearly" made a false statement "where she claimed she was knocked down and injured after her husband had been knocked into her."

The judge said Gould, a former police officer, "cherry-picked" evidence for the report and misstated what Arsenovski said in her statement.

She said Gould also encouraged other agencies, such as the health and immigration ministries, to take action against the woman, who was vulnerable, being new to Canada and unable to speak much English.

"Mr. Gould pursued Mrs. Arsenovski with a vengeance that was significantly out of proportion with any objectively reasonable concern he could have had as to whether or not she actually might make a claim," Griffin wrote.

The charge was eventually stayed on the day Arsenovski's trial for making a false statement was set to begin.

But the effects of the experience have stayed with her, the judge said, noting how the woman "choked up in court" and how she has not told anyone, including her siblings and adult children, about the charge, even after it was lifted.

"The stain she feels on her character as a result of being charged criminally might never be erased," Griffin wrote.

She awarded Arsenovksi $387,225.34 in damages and costs.

Cases such as this could dissuade people who have valid claims from pursuing them, the judge said in laying out her reasons for the penalty.

"A strong message of denunciation must be sent to ICBC," she wrote.

Griffin also had harsh words for the Crown corporation and noted that one of the agency's key purposes is to provide compensation to people who are involved in accidents.

"The corporation does not serve the residents of this province when it uses tactics of intimidation to discourage civil claims," she wrote.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Justin Trudeau news conference LIVE

    Canada News CBC News
    Hurricane Maria blasts through Puerto Rico Widespread damage to structures, vegetation Source
  • Trudeau tells UN of Canada's shame over Indigenous Peoples

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau used a speech to the United Nations on Thursday to probe a source of national shame: the historic struggles of Canada’s Indigenous peoples. He spoke of forced migration and forced family separation in residential schools, which he said left a devastating legacy on reserves to this day. Source
  • Trump vows more sanctions over North Korea's nuclear buildup

    World News CTV News
    NEW YORK -- U.S. President Donald Trump signed an executive order Thursday aiming to tighten an economic noose around North Korea, days after he threatened to "totally destroy" the country if forced to defend the United States or its allies. Source
  • 'Not the ending that we wanted': Family relieved body of missing man in Quebec Amber Alert case found

    Canada News CBC News
    Friends and family of Yvon Lacasse, the 71-year-old man who went missing last week while an Amber Alert was in place for a six-year-old Quebec boy, are taking solace after his body was located Wednesday. "It feels very sad . Source
  • Police searching for man who allegedly caused crash while impersonating officer

    Canada News CTV News
    TORONTO - Police in Toronto are looking for a man who allegedly caused a collision while impersonating an officer. They say witnesses reported that a man dressed in a police officer's uniform was directing traffic while dancing in a west-end intersection last Saturday. Source
  • Montreal-born James Campbell Clouston recognized for efforts at Dunkirk

    Canada News CTV News
    MONTREAL - The Montreal-born Second World War hero whose efforts at Dunkirk in 1940 saved the lives of hundreds of thousands of soldiers is being recognized today in his hometown. Cmdr. James Campbell Clouston's exploits were portrayed in Christopher Nolan's blockbuster movie, "Dunkirk," released earlier this year. Source
  • Canada is 'work in progress,' Justin Trudeau tells UN General Assembly

    Canada News CBC News
    Describing Canada as a "work in progress," Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told the UN Thursday about the country's failures and mistakes in its historical relationship with Indigenous people and his hope to right the wrongs of the past. Source
  • Google is linking secret, court-protected names - including victim IDs - to online coverage [Video]

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    Google’s powerful search engine is defeating some court-ordered publication bans in Canada and undermining efforts to protect young offenders and victims. Computer experts believe it’s an unintended, “mind-boggling” consequence of Google search algorithms. In six high-profile cases documented by the Citizen, searching the name of a young offender or victim online pointed to media coverage of their court cases, even though their names do not appear anywhere in the news articles themselves. Source
  • 'Clint Eastwood' fires warning shot, gets stolen beer back

    World News Toronto Sun
    COCOA, Fla. — Police say a Florida gas station owner chased a man and fired a warning shot, forcing him to return some stolen beer. Orlando television station WESH reports it was the fourth time store owner Sowann Suy used his gun in defence of his store in the Atlantic coast community of Cocoa. Source
  • Arkansas high school teacher accused of having sex with four students – including two in the same day

    World News Toronto Sun
    A married high school teacher has been arrested for allegedly having sex with four of her students. Jessie Lorene Goline , 25, is accused of sleeping with two of the boys in the same day. The former teacher worked at Mark Tree High School in Arkansas. Source