Deposing Taliban regime was a mistake, former Canadian commander says

OTTAWA - The West made a mistake deposing the Taliban regime in the aftermath of 9/11 and should have simply trained its guns on al Qaeda, says the Canadian commander who led NATO into southern Afghanistan a decade ago.

See Full Article

Retired major-general Dave Fraser commanded both the Canadian task force and the military alliance's expanded mission to extend the authority of former Afghan president Hamid Karzai beyond the capital of Kabul in 2006.

At the time, it was just over four-and-a-half years into the Afghan war and three years into the larger, bloodier struggle in Iraq after the toppling of Saddam Hussein.

"We thought, naively, that regime change was the solution to the problem," Fraser told The Canadian Press in an interview to mark the 10th anniversary of the Canadian combat deployment into Kandahar.

No one, back then, seemed to appreciate how profound the power vacuum was and that the West had "created for ourselves a 30- or 40-year problem" in not only Afghanistan, he said, but throughout the Middle East.

"Looking backwards, I would have actually left the Taliban government in power and said (to them): 'Stay out of the way. We're here to find al Qaeda. And as long as you stay out of the way, the special forces will go in there, they will do what is necessary to get al Qaeda and we will leave,"' Fraser said.

"Had we done that, we wouldn't be where we are today."

The comments are unexpected and surprising, not the least because they come from a soldier whose troops were the first to face a Taliban resurgence in south; someone who championed the combat mission's aims and articulated the goal of bringing stability to the ungoverned region.

"We compounded the problem by getting rid of the Taliban regime," he said. "I didn't like the Taliban regime, but why did we go there in the first place? It was because of al Qaeda. Not because of the Taliban."

The reflections come just a day after the it was announced the Afghan government is expected to resume face-to-face talks with Taliban leaders next week in Pakistan. The negotiations are aimed at reviving a peace process that dissolved last summer after it was revealed that the Mullah Omar, the movement's reclusive leader, had died a few years ago - an event kept secret by the insurgent group.

Fraser said the West has only repeated the same mistakes over the last decade.

"We repeated it in Iraq," he said. "In Libya, we didn't put any ground troops in and we created an even bigger mess because there's no government whatsoever in Libya. We went back into Iraq and now for the very first time the international community is beginning to appreciate that regime change is not the solution - hence why we're not pushing to do a regime change in Syria."

The West has insisted that Syrian dictator Bashar Assad should go, but it has not pushed him out of power - one of the factors in that country's long, bloody civil war.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Explorers find WWII Navy destroyer, deepest wreck discovered

    World News CTV News
    MANILA, Philippines - A U.S. Navy destroyer that engaged a superior Japanese fleet in the largest sea battle of World War II in the Philippines has become the deepest wreck to be discovered, according to explorers. Source
  • Biden urges Western unity on Ukraine amid war fatigue

    World News CTV News
    ELMAU, Germany - U.S. President Joe Biden and western allies opened a three-day summit in the Bavarian Alps on Sunday intent on keeping economic fallout from the war in Ukraine from fracturing the global coalition working to punish Russia's aggression. Source
  • Norway mourns victims of Oslo shooting with memorial service

    World News CTV News
    Microsoft: Russian cyber spying targets 42 Ukraine allies Coinciding with unrelenting cyberattacks against Ukraine, state-backed Russian hackers have engaged in "strategic espionage" against governments, think tanks, businesses and aid groups in 42 countries supporting Kyiv, Microsoft said in a report Wednesday. Source
  • U.S. Pride parades march on with new urgency

    World News CTV News
    NEW YORK - Parades celebrating LGBTQ Pride kick off in some of America's biggest cities Sunday amid new fears about the potential erosion of freedoms won through decades of activism. The annual marches in New York, San Francisco, Chicago and elsewhere take place just two days after one conservative justice on the Supreme Court signaled, in a ruling on abortion, that the court should reconsider the right to same-sex marriage recognized in 2015. Source
  • Russia strikes Kyiv as troops consolidate gains in the east

    World News CTV News
    KYIV, Ukraine - Russia attacked the Ukrainian capital early Sunday, striking at least two residential buildings, the mayor of Kyiv said, as elsewhere Russian troops fought to consolidate their gains in the country's east. Associated Press journalists in Kyiv saw rescue services battling flames and rescuing civilians. Source
  • At least 20 dead in South African club; cause not yet known

    World News CTV News
    JOHANNESBURG - South African police are investigating the deaths of at least 20 people at a nightclub in the coastal town of East London early Sunday morning. It is unclear what led to the deaths of the young people, who were reportedly attending a party to celebrate the end of winter school exams. Source
  • Public safety minister eyes steps to strengthen oversight of the RCMP

    Canada News CTV News
    OTTAWA - The federal public safety minister says he is "deeply committed" to enhancing oversight of the RCMP by strengthening the role of the national police force's management advisory board. In an interview, Marco Mendicino expressed a desire to give the board the "independence and autonomy that it needs" -- possibly through legislative amendments -- to ensure adequate supervision. Source
  • As Senate-confirmed justices end Roe, how will voters react?

    World News CTV News
    WASHINGTON - The end of Roe v. Wade started in the Senate. It was the Senate Republican partnership with President Donald Trump to confirm conservative judges, and transform the federal judiciary, that paved the way for the Supreme Court's landmark ruling to overturn the constitutional right to abortion. Source
  • At least 20 people found dead inside South African nightclub

    World News CBC News
    South African police are investigating the deaths of at least 20 people at a nightclub in the coastal town of East London early Sunday morning. It is unclear what led to the deaths of the young people, who were reportedly attending a party to celebrate the end of winter school exams. Source
  • Quebec homeowners say Ottawa must address decades of erosion caused by ship traffic

    Canada News CTV News
    Every year, 100-year-old Angélique Beauchemin watches more of her land crumble into the St. Lawrence River. From her home along a busy stretch of river in Verchères, Que., on Montreal's South Shore, she watches waves from passing ships crash into the rock wall at the base of her property, sweeping chunks away and eating into the unprotected banks from below. Source