Judge in Oland preliminary hearing left with unanswered questions

SAINT JOHN, N.B. - The judge who committed Dennis Oland to trial for his father's murder said there were many unanswered questions about the case, and police were too quick to conclude that Oland was the killer.

See Full Article

Judge Ronald LeBlanc provided a lot of commentary in his 53-page preliminary hearing decision rendered in December 2014, but it was under a publication ban until the trial was complete.

LeBlanc said the Crown had failed during the preliminary hearing to establish motive, and the conclusion by police -- mere hours after Richard Oland's body was found -- that the younger Oland was the killer was unjustified as irrational.

LeBlanc said there were unanswered questions about the location of Richard Oland's cell phone, the murder weapon, the noises heard by people below Oland's office, and the handling of Dennis Oland's brown jacket.

But in the end, LeBlanc said he had to decide whether a properly instructed jury could conclude that Oland killed his father.

In December Oland was convicted of second-degree murder and has since been sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for 10 years.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Wildrose, Progressive Conservative parties to merge with 95% approval

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    The Wildrose Party approved unifying with Progressive Conservatives in an historic vote Saturday. Just over ninety-five per cent of Wildrose members voted yes for unity, well above the 75 per cent majority it needed to give the merger a go-ahead. Source
  • Princess Diana's last conversation with her sons recounted in documentary

    World News CTV News
    LONDON -- It was a typical phone call between two boys playing and their mother, who was on vacation in France. It was brief -- the boys wanted to get back to playing with their cousins, not spend time on the phone chatting. Source
  • O.J. Simpson's brand out of juice

    World News Toronto Sun
    Can O.J. have a fourth quarter comeback? Not without a game ball. O.J. isn’t the first celebrity to grace his mug on a mugshot, and many have made their way back to the top — Hugh Grant, Keifer Sutherland, Britney Spears and Robert Downey Jr. Source
  • Wildrose votes yes to unity with 95% of the vote

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    The Wildrose Party approved unifying with Progressive Conservatives in an historic vote Saturday. Just over ninety-five per cent of Wildrose members voted yes for unity, well above the 75 per cent majority it needed to give the merger a go-ahead. Source
  • What’s next for O.J. Simpson? [Photos]

    World News Toronto Sun
    At times, during O.J. Simpson’s parole hearing it seemed as though the battered old jock was moving his body like he was evading bruising linebackers. The big man on campus. Bobbing. Weaving. Jocular. Locker room O.J. O.J. Source
  • 9/11 victim's wife disgusted by $10.5M Khadr deal [Photos]

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    The widow of a Toronto businessman killed in the World Trade Centre on 9/11 says its sickening that the Liberal government has allowed terrorist Omar Khadr to play the victim card and collect $10.5 million. Maureen Basnicki’s husband, Ken Basnicki, was in New York City on business when he was killed in the North Tower on Sept. Source
  • B.C. transgender inmate wins women's prison transfer request

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    VANCOUVER — A transgender inmate in British Columbia has won a years-long battle to serve the remainder of her sentence for first-degree murder at a women’s prison. Fallon Aubee is one of the first federal prisoners to relocate under policy changes at Correctional Services Canada that allow inmates to transfer facilities based on gender identity and not physical anatomy, said Jennifer Metcalfe, a spokeswoman for the West Coast Prison Justice Society. Source
  • U.S. Congress strikes deal on sanctions bill, handcuffing Trump on Russia

    World News CBC News
    U.S. Republicans and Democrats have reached agreement on legislation that allows new sanctions against Russia, Iran and North Korea, leading congressional Democrats said on Saturday, in a bill that would limit any potential effort by President Donald Trump to try to lift sanctions against Moscow. Source
  • Williams Lake mayor hopes residents can return early next week

    Canada News CTV News
    The mayor of Williams Lake, B.C, a community evacuated one week ago due to the threat of raging wildfires, says he’s hopeful that some residents can return early next week. Mayor Walt Cobb told CTV News Channel on Saturday that the fires burning in the region have moved away from the city of 11,000, creating a “a much safer situation. Source
  • Trudeau marches in Halifax Pride Parade

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    HALIFAX — Throngs of people lined the streets of downtown Halifax Saturday to see a sitting prime minister walk in the city’s Pride parade for the first time. The rainbow-clad crowd erupted in cheers as Justin Trudeau marched in the procession with his family at his side. Source