Lawyer says blacks 'don't feel at home' in N.S. courts after sex case dropped

HALIFAX -- A Halifax lawyer questioned the racial fairness of Nova Scotia's legal system after a sex assault case against him ended Thursday with the charge being formally withdrawn.

See Full Article

Lyle Howe, who was accused of sexually assaulting a 19-year-old woman in 2011, was originally found guilty by a jury in May 2014.

Howe spent two weeks in custody after being sentenced to three years in jail in July, 2014.

His conviction was overturned on appeal last fall and a new trial was ordered.

"My family and I went through hell," Howe said outside Nova Scotia Supreme Court following a short hearing.

"I feel a bit of a weight lifted off but to be quite frank there is still a weight there that shouldn't be there."

Howe was critical of a legal process that saw "zero African-Nova Scotian" jurors in his case -- the lone black juror was an international student -- and he added that he had "huge issues" with a system that has a lack of black judges.

He said it appears little had changed in the decades since the Donald Marshall inquiry found systemic racism in the province's legal system.

"As a black person coming into this building (court) . . . I don't feel at home," said Howe. "We should feel that when we step into the court that we are actually getting a fair shake equal to what a white person would and I don't feel that way."

Crown attorney Dan Rideout said the decision not to proceed with another trial was made out of respect for the wishes of the complainant and that without her testimony there was no realistic prospect of a conviction.

"We had considered the unique nature of the case including several days of gruelling testimony that she had to go through the first time as well as other things that would have impacted and influenced her decision," said Rideout.

Howe disputed the Crown's reasoning, saying it could have compelled the complainant to testify and didn't because "there was no case."

During the original trial, the young woman testified that she was impaired and did not consent to sex with Howe at her Halifax apartment.

Howe argued that the sex was consensual, and the appeal court ruled that the trial judge should have instructed Howe's jury to consider the defence of honest but mistaken belief in consent.

The complainant's name is under a publication ban, but was posted on Facebook by a supporter of Howe. David Winslow Sparks, 62, was fined $1,950 and sentenced to a year's probation for breaking the ban last March.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • GOP hopes Alabama loss is wakeup call for Trump White House

    World News CTV News
    WASHINGTON -- U.S. President Donald Trump managed to endorse two different losing candidates in the same Senate race, a setback that is highlighting an experience deficit within the White House political team. "As the leader of the party, I would have liked to have had the seat," Trump acknowledged Wednesday, a day after a special Senate election in Alabama led to a victory for Democrat Doug Jones. Source
  • 3 women accuse music mogul Russell Simmons of rape

    World News CBC News
    Three women have told the New York Times that music mogul Russell Simmons raped them, the latest in a cascade of serious allegations of sexual misconduct against powerful men in entertainment, media, politics and elsewhere. Simmons vehemently denied what he called "these horrific accusations," saying in a statement emailed to The Associated Press that "all of my relations have been consensual. Source
  • Plane crashes in Saskatchewan with 25 people on board, no fatalities

    Canada News CTV News
    FOND DU LAC, Sask. -- RCMP say a plane with 25 people on board has crashed in northern Saskatchewan. Police say the plane crashed shortly after taking off around 6:15 p.m. at the Fond du Lac airport. Source
  • Mistrial in Utah case of girl raped while mom smoked meth nearby

    World News CTV News
    SALT LAKE CITY -- A mistrial has been declared in the case of three men accused of sexually assaulting a 9-year-old girl at a Utah home while her mother was in the garage smoking methamphetamine. Source
  • Bitcoin boom seen as survival, not speculation, in Venezuela

    World News CBC News
    In the last month, John Villar has bought two plane tickets to Colombia, purchased his wife's medication and paid the employees of his startup business in Venezuela — all in bitcoin. As Venezuela's national currency loses value at a catastrophic rate, thousands have begun turning to the world of cryptocurrency to salvage what little value remains from their increasingly worthless bolivars. Source
  • Sister of Loretta Saunders needs liver transplant but deemed ineligible: family

    Canada News CTV News
    A 26-year-old woman whose sister was murdered in Nova Scotia three years ago is in hospital with acute liver failure, and her family says strict rules around substance abuse is preventing her from receiving a transplant she desperately needs. Source
  • Hillary Clinton praises Trudeau, celebrates Roy Moore defeat in Vancouver

    Canada News CTV News
    VANCOUVER -- Hillary Clinton says she feels "a tiny bit less" concerned about the United States following the Democratic party's surprise win in Alabama's senate race on Tuesday. The former presidential candidate is calling the electoral upset a turning point for Americans in pushing for accountability from U.S. Source
  • Man accused in bat attack is Toronto lawyer with influential roots

    Canada News CBC News
    CBC News has learned the man charged in connection with a baseball bat attack on an immigrant family is a Toronto personal injury lawyer and the great-grandson of former Toronto mayor Nathan Phillips. Mark Phillips, 36, was charged on Dec. Source
  • P.E.I. 'refining' how sexual assaults are investigated

    Canada News CBC News
    The P.E.I. government says it is committed to improving how sexual assaults are investigated after a review concluded nearly 40 per cent of cases reported to Island police departments were ruled unfounded. The numbers are based on sexual assault case files from the past three years for Charlottetown and Kensington's police forces, and the past six years for Summerside police and Island RCMP. Source
  • Alberta says Sask. has implemented licence plate ban on government job sites

    Canada News CTV News
    EDMONTON -- Alberta says Saskatchewan has served notice that as of right now no vehicles with Alberta licence plates are allowed on any Saskatchewan government job sites. That is a change from last week, when Saskatchewan said the ban would apply only on future government road and building projects. Source