Jury to decide fate of Sask. couple accused of killing 4-year-old, neglecting sister

REGINA -- A jury will have to decide whether a couple accused of killing a four-year-old girl and neglecting her younger sister purposely hurt them and denied them food.

See Full Article

The defence and Crown gave closing arguments Thursday at the trial of Tammy and Kevin Goforth, who face charges of second-degree murder and criminal negligence causing bodily harm.

Lawyers for the couple told the jury that the Crown hasn't proven the pair intended to harm the children.

Tammy Goforth's lawyer said the couple threw birthday parties for the girls and took them to the park, museums and church.

"They didn't hide these girls," Jeff Deagle told the jury. "They weren't harming these girls. They were making them part of their lives."

The girls, who can't be identified because of a publication ban, were placed in the Goforths' Regina home in November 2011.

Shortly before midnight on July 31, 2012, the four-year-old was brought to Regina General Hospital "in crisis," court heard. She was taken off life support a couple of days later. An agreed statement of facts says she died of a brain injury after suffering cardiac arrest. She was also malnourished and dehydrated.

Her two-year-old sister survived.

Deagle acknowledged that the girls had lost weight, but said that can happen when someone is sick with the flu and doesn't eat much.

He said his client was trying to nurse the girls back to health. He pointed to evidence photos showing soup bowls on the kitchen counter the day the older sister was rushed to hospital.

"The real issue is not whether they were prevented from having food or deprived of having liquids," Deagle said. "Really, the issue is when should they have taken them to the doctor."

Kevin Goforth testified earlier this week that the children were never denied food. He said supper time at the family's home was important and the girls, who were big eaters, were always part of it.

Crown prosecutor Kim Jones said the girls weren't given enough food "for a prolonged period of time."

"This did not happen overnight," Jones told the jury.

"Physically, the girls were wasting away and that would have been readily apparent to anybody. Their faces became gaunt and their arms and legs were skin and bones."

Jones also said the girls were kept in poor conditions and sometimes restrained.

Court heard from Dr. Sharon Leibel with the child abuse unit at Regina Qu'Appelle Health Region. Leibel testified there were bruises, skin abrasions, open skin and scrapes across the four-year-old's body.

A forensic identification expert testified that he found duct tape in the Goforth home with hair stuck to it.

Const. Garth Fleece said he also found a large amount of dark hair in a knot on a piece of pink fabric, as well as cardboard with blood and feces in the girls' bedroom. The officer testified that he was looking for items such as rope or string that could be used as binding.

Defence lawyer Noah Evanchuk, who is representing Kevin Goforth, said police "had tunnel vision."

"They wanted to find evidence that would fit a theory. It's called confirmation basis -- find things that fit a theory, not find evidence and arrive at a theory," said Evanchuk.

Tammy Goforth testified bruises on the girls' ankles were caused by wearing high-cut shoes without socks, while contusions on their wrists were from mittens taped over their hands to stop them from scratching themselves.

Deliberations could begin Friday after the judge gives instructions to the jury.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Will Italy's political drama spawn a new eurozone crisis?

    World News CTV News
    LONDON -- Italy is facing political upheaval after Premier Matteo Renzi said he's resigning after a crushing defeat in a nationwide referendum. Investors, though used to political drama in Rome, are trying to gauge the impact on the country's economy and the wider eurozone. Source
  • Colombia plane crash survivor says there was no time to react

    World News Toronto Sun
    BOGOTA — One of the survivors of last week’s plane crash in the Andes said the passengers of the chartered flight had no idea their aircraft was running out of gas before it slammed into a mountainside. Source
  • Judge denies change of venue motion in murder-for-hire trial

    World News CTV News
    WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. -- The trial of a Florida woman accused of trying to hire a hit man to kill her husband will be heard by a local jury. Judge Glenn Kelley on Monday ruled that he thinks he can find an impartial six-member jury in Palm Beach County to hear Dalia Dippolito's retrial. Source
  • Man fatally shot wife for urging him to kill himself

    World News Toronto Sun
    CHICORA, Pa. — Police say a Pennsylvania man told them he fatally shot his wife after first trying to kill himself and then hearing her taunting him and encouraging him to shoot himself. Thirty-year-old Joshua Crawford was jailed Monday in Butler County on charges of criminal homicide and aggravated assault. Source
  • Weather warning issued as winter arrives to B.C.'s South Coast and Island

    Canada News CTV News
    Much of British Columbia's Lower Mainland and southeastern Vancouver Island are experiencing a blast of wintry conditions. Environment Canada has issued a weather warning, predicting up to five centimetres of snow for the region. Source
  • No new trial date yet for Dennis Oland in murder of his multimillionaire father

    Canada News CTV News
    SAINT JOHN, N.B. - Dennis Oland will have to wait until at least next month to learn if a date will be set for a new trial in his father's 2011 murder. Oland was convicted of second-degree murder last December, but that verdict was overturned by the New Brunswick Court of Appeal in October, which ruled the trial judge erred in his instructions to the jury, and a new trial was ordered. Source
  • Once young and promising, Italy's Matteo Renzi gets handed his hat

    World News CBC News
    If there was ever any doubt that Italy's referendum on constitutional reform was anything other than a verdict on Matteo Renzi as prime minister, the nearly 70 per cent voter turnout and resounding defeat of his proposals on Sunday blasted away the last scraps of uncertainty. Source
  • Oakland warehouse fire: 'I don’t know how many people are left in there' [Photos] [Video]

    World News Toronto Sun
    OAKLAND, Calif. — The death toll in the Oakland warehouse fire has grown to 36 and authorities say they expect the number to rise when they resume work later Monday following a temporary work stoppage. A wall is leaning inward, posing a safety hazard to those who have been searching the building which erupted in fire Friday night. Source
  • British 'Santa Safari' tour worker fatally stabbed in Arctic wilds of Lapland

    World News CTV News
    HELSINKI -- Finnish police say they are holding a 36-year-old foreigner suspected of fatally stabbing his female friend in the Arctic wilds of Lapland. Tourism officials say the victim was a British employee. Lapland police said that after Saturday's stabbing, the suspect fled into the forest in temperatures of -30 C (-22 F). Source
  • N.L. veteran under arrest in northern Iraq: report

    Canada News CTV News
    The mother of a former Canadian soldier says she believes he has been arrested in northern Iraq while taking part in a humanitarian mission. Kay Kennedy of St. Vincent's, N.L., told radio station VOCM that she was speaking with her son Mike on Tuesday evening, when she realized something was wrong. Source