Certification of proposed G20 class action before Ontario Appeal Court

TORONTO -- Ontario's top court will hear arguments on Monday about whether two lawsuits arising out of the mass detentions during the tumultuous G20 summit in 2010 should go ahead as class actions.

See Full Article

Police authorities in Toronto want the Court of Appeal to quash the proceedings, which have already been subject to two lower court rulings. The courts had originally ruled against certifying a class action, but Divisional Court overturned the ruling on initial appeal and instead split the action in two.

In its factum, the police services board argues Divisional Court overstepped its boundaries in expressing concern that the mass arrests could be seen as "one of the hallmarks of a police state" and therefore needed a thorough airing as class actions.

The board argues the original judge was correct in deciding the different behaviour of various summit protesters precluded their being considered a class.

"The Divisional Court translated its expressed concern about overbroad arrests into a common-issues hearing, which does not allow consideration of the individual conduct of those alleging false arrest," the board states in its factum.

"Conduct varied such that determining whether grounds existed in respect of one of the class member's arrests could not determine the answer for all."

The G20 summit over a weekend in June 2010 -- marred by vandalism from several dozen protesters -- saw more than 1,000 people arrested or detained in what was later described as one of the worst violations of civil liberties in Canadian history. Many were kept in appalling conditions at a makeshift detention centre. Almost all were released without charge within 24 hours.

Sherry Good, now lead plaintiff in one of the actions, was among scores of people police "kettled" in the torrential rain at a downtown intersection. Divisional Court also ruled that Thomas Taylor should represent those sent to the east-end detention centre.

Both want damages for false arrest or imprisonment, and violations of their constitutional rights. They maintain a senior officer gave orders for the indiscriminate roundup of anyone present at various downtown locations -- enough to warrant class certification.

"Arrestees included peaceful protesters, bystanders, journalists, legal observers, and Torontonians who were present simply by chance," their factum states.

"Without the possibility of a class action in this situation, police can arrest entire crowds and only risk a few lawsuits from a few determined and well-resourced people."

Lawyer Eric Gillespie, who represents Good, said the idea that the individual conduct of each class member needs to be examined is misguided and counter to well-established precedent.

"There are so many examples of class actions that are radically dissimilar on their facts but have been certified," Gillespie said. "We say this is about as cut and dried as you will ever get."

Co-counsel Murray Klippenstein said the encircling and arrest of large groups of legitimate protesters is illegal, and they should be allowed to sue as a group.

Arguing, as the police are doing, that people are free to sue individually makes little sense and is "just not feasible," Klippenstein said.

"It wouldn't help justice or the protection of Canadian freedoms."

The Canadian Civil Liberties Association, which is intervening in the appeal, also argues class actions are appropriate.

In green-lighting the two actions, the Divisional Court stressed the broader issue at stake.

"It is important to remember that the police cannot sweep up scores of people just in the hope that one of the persons captured is a person who they believe is engaged in criminal activity," the court said in its ruling.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Australia ends Hong Kong extradition treaty, extends visas

    World News CTV News
    CANBERRA, AUSTRALIA -- Australia suspended its extradition treaty with Hong Kong and extended visas for Hong Kong residents in response to China's imposition of a tough national security law on the semi-autonomous territory, the prime minister said Thursday. Source
  • 25 years on, Srebrenica dead still being identified, buried

    World News CTV News
    SREBRENICA, BOSNIA -- A quarter of a century after they were killed in Europe's worst massacre since the Second World War, eight Bosnian men and boys will be laid to rest Saturday in a cemetery just outside of Srebrenica -- their marble gravestones joining thousands more, each with the same month and year of death. Source
  • Trump wants schools reopened. He's getting rare support from virus experts

    World News CBC News
    Donald Trump's call to reopen schools is winning rare qualified support from a group that's included some of the U.S. president's harshest critics: virus experts. Epidemiologists who have castigated the president's pandemic handling agree with him that students should be in classrooms this fall. Source
  • Canadian barley exports surging on booming demand from China for beer

    World News CBC News
    Canadian barley farmers are the unintended beneficiaries of a diplomatic spat a world away, as exports of their product to China are picking up. China is engaged in a trade dispute with Australia right now, accusing the antipodean nation of dumping agricultural products. Source
  • Eliminating COVID-19 cases in Canada will exact too heavy a toll on society, health experts say

    Canada News CBC News
    Some public health and infectious disease experts are pressing for governments in Canada to shift to minimizing, not eradicating, COVID-19 while allowing society to resume functioning. The open letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and all premiers, dated July 6, says aiming to prevent or contain every case is not sustainable at this stage in the pandemic. Source
  • Victim waits for Jamie Bacon to plead guilty to role in Surrey Six slayings

    Canada News CBC News
    As far as Eileen Mohan is concerned, Jamie Bacon has been playing the justice system for a fool for the past decade. The mother of one of six people killed in B.C.'s most notorious gangland slaying says she may be in court to watch Thursday — but she'll get no satisfaction from seeing the gangster plead guilty to one count of conspiring to commit murder in relation to the 2007 Surrey Six killings. Source
  • Why the Conservatives are going after the Liberals' pre-pandemic spending now

    Canada News CBC News
    The federal balance sheet is a mathematical exercise that has real fiscal and economic implications. But outside of a debt crisis, the greatest value of a surplus or deficit estimate may be as a political idea. In that respect, the most interesting thing about the $343 billion deficit that Finance Minister Bill Morneau projected on Wednesday is how it might frame the federal debate for years to come. Source
  • How risky is my manicure? Your COVID-19 questions answered

    Canada News CBC News
    We're breaking down what you need to know about the pandemic. Send us your questions via email at [email protected] and we'll answer as many as we can. We'll publish a selection of answers every weekday on our website, and we're also putting some of your questions to the experts on the air during The National and on CBC News Network. Source
  • Why abolishing Olympics anti-protest rule could do more harm than good

    Canada News CBC News
    This column is an opinion by Jasmine Mian, a 2016 Canadian Olympian and a graduate student at the University of Calgary's School of Public Policy. For more information about CBC's Opinion section, please see the FAQ. Anti-racism demonstrations and the Black Lives Matter movement have revived concerns about Rule 50 of the International Olympic Committee's Charter. Source
  • Heavy rain hits central Japan, more damage in south

    World News CBC News
    Flooding and mudslides have stranded hundreds of people in scenic hot springs and hiking areas in central Japan, while rescue workers searched on Thursday for more people missing in the disaster that already has killed nearly 60 people in a southern region. Source