Terminated Ont. contractors given $125,000 in lieu of notice

TORONTO -- Ontario's top court has shut down another attempt by a kitchen company to get out of paying severance to two workers it alleged were contractors, not employees.

See Full Article

In its decision Wednesday, the Appeal Court agreed that Canac Kitchens owed Marilyn and Lawrence Keenan $125,000 in lieu of 26 months notice.

At issue, the court said, was the nature of the relationship between the couple and company based in Thornhill, Ont., which shut down abruptly in March 2009, and what might be a reasonable notice period.

Court documents show Canac employed Lawrence Keenan from 1976 installing kitchen cabinets. He worked his way up to foreman supervising installation crews. His wife, who had been helping her husband informally, began working for Canac in 1983 as a supervisor.

In 1987, the company told them they would no longer be considered employees, but could carry on their work as contractors. As part of the agreement, they had to agree to devote their full-time and attention to Canac, which was a division of U.S.-based Kohler.

The Keenans went along with the plan, essentially because they had little choice and because not much actually changed under the new arrangement. They still considered themselves loyal Canac employees, wore shirts with the Canac logo, and used the company's business cards, court records show.

When Canac shut down in 2009 -- he was now 63 years old and she was 61 -- the company said their services were no longer needed. Canac argued the Keenans, as independent contractors, were owed nothing. The couple sued.

In a decision early last year, Superior Court Justice Graeme Mew found the arrangement started in 1987 had been "almost exclusively for Canac's benefit," and that the Keenans had been "dependent" contractors and therefore entitled to reasonable notice of termination, which he set at 26 months.

Even though they had done some work for another company in the two years before their termination, Mew ruled that did not change the situation.

On appeal, Canac argued the Keenans should not have been considered dependent contractors because they had not been working exclusively for the company before the relationship ended.

The Appeal Court rejected the argument.

"Of the approximately 32 and 25 years of service that Lawrence Keenan and Marilyn Keenan respectively gave to Canac, in all but two of those years, they exclusively served Canac," the court said.

"For over a generation, they were Canac's public face to the outside world. Over a period of approximately 30 years -- the entirety of their working lives -- the Keenans' income had come from Canac and they relied on that income to support themselves and their family."

Given the nature and length of their service and ages at the time of termination, the Appeal Court agreed that damages equivalent to 26 months notice was reasonable -- similar to an award given in another case involving a former employee of the company.

The court also ordered Canac to pay the Keenans $24,000 in costs.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Germany hosts summit on Libya, seeks to halt proxy fighting

    World News CBC News
    Germany brought together the key players in Libya's long-running civil war on Sunday, seeking to curb foreign military interference, solidify a ceasefire and help relaunch a political process to stop the chaos in the North African nation. Source
  • 'We have a truce': Oft-broken arms embargo for Libya conflict reaffirmed at Berlin summit

    World News CBC News
    Germany brought together the key players in Libya's long-running civil war on Sunday, seeking to curb foreign military interference, solidify a ceasefire and help relaunch a political process to stop the chaos in the North African nation. Source
  • Canada presses Iran to share black boxes from PS752 crash amid mixed signals from Tehran

    Canada News CBC News
    Foreign Affairs Minister François-Philippe Champagne is pressing Iran to share the black boxes from the downed Ukrainian airliner that killed 57 Canadians on Jan. 8. Back in Canada after meeting in Oman with Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif to discuss the disaster that occurred near Tehran, Champagne said he is aware of media reports that Iran is backtracking on its pledge to share the flight recorders for independent analysis. Source
  • Thomas Markle accuses Megan and Harry of 'cheapening' royals

    World News CTV News
    TORONTO -- The estranged father of the Duchess of Sussex, Thomas Markle, has accused Prince Harry and Meghan of “cheapening” the Royal Family by stepping down from their senior roles.Sign up for our Royal Dispatch newsletter for all the latest Royal news Source
  • Search resumes for N.L. man who went missing at peak of historic blizzard

    Canada News CBC News
    The search has resumed for a Roaches Line man who went missing as a blizzard intensified in eastern Newfoundland early Friday afternoon. Bay Roberts RCMP, the Avalon North Wolverines Search and Rescue and a CH149 Cormorant from 9 Wing Gander are all part of the search for 26-year-old Josh Wall, as is an RCMP police dog. Source
  • Family 'distraught' as search resumes for N.L. man who went missing at peak of historic blizzard

    Canada News CBC News
    The search has resumed for a Roaches Line man who went missing as a blizzard intensified in eastern Newfoundland early Friday afternoon. Bay Roberts RCMP, the Avalon North Wolverines Search and Rescue and a CH149 Cormorant from 9 Wing Gander are all part of the search for 26-year-old Josh Wall, as is an RCMP police dog. Source
  • Malindi Elmore could be Olympic-bound after shattering Canadian women's marathon record

    Canada News CBC News
    Malindi Elmore crushed the Canadian women's marathon record on Sunday, all but booking her spot on the team for the 2020 Tokyo Olympics. The 39-year-old from Kelowna, B.C., ran two hours 24 minutes 50 seconds at the Houston Marathon, shattering Rachel Cliff's mark of 2:26.56 set in March of last year. Source
  • Thousands without power as N.L. braces for more snow

    Canada News CTV News
    TORONTO -- Thousands of residents in Newfoundland and Labrador are without power as they attempt to dig out from a record-breaking snowfall before another storm hits the region Sunday night. According to Newfoundland Power, over 3,000 people remained in the dark Sunday morning as temperatures dipped to -20 C with the wind chill and the threat of another 10 to 15 centimetres of snow loomed in Sunday night’s forecast. Source
  • Man. government urged to do away with changing clocks twice a year

    Canada News CTV News
    WINNIPEG -- A small number of apparently passionate Manitobans have been giving Premier Brian Pallister an earful about having to change their clocks twice a year. The premier received six emails, unprompted, from members of the public between September and December last year on the subject of daylight time. Source
  • New Cree language app targets students, teachers and newcomers

    Canada News CBC News
    More than 150 elders from five northern Alberta First Nations have contributed to a new tool designed to preserve Cree words and phrases. The free app, KTCEA Elders Speak, is a product of the Kee Tas Kee Now Tribal Council Education Authority, which oversees six schools within five northern Alberta First Nations: Peerless Trout First Nation, Whitefish Lake First Nation, Loon River First Nation, Lubicon Lake Band, and Woodland Cree First Nation. Source