Forcillo conviction stirs debate about 'trial by YouTube'

After Toronto Police Const. James Forcillo was found guilty Monday of attempted murder in the shooting death of teenager Sammy Yatim, the officer’s defence attorney called it a “trial by YouTube.

See Full Article

Lawyer Peter Brauti lamented to reporters outside the courtroom that every potential juror had heard of the shooting before the trial began, and therefore had probably formed an opinion of Forcillo’s actions.

After all, a cellphone video showing the shooting was posted to YouTube hours after the knife-wielding teen was killed on a streetcar on July 27, 2013, and it was widely circulated by those outraged at the officer.

However, an expert in social media’s effect on policing who studied the Yatim shooting for a book said it’s not clear that Forcillo was actually hurt by the video.

Prof. Chris Schneider told CTV News Channel that while the video did “frame how this entire case and circumstance was discussed by the news media and police,” the evidence doesn’t support Brauti’s view that the video caused most potential jurors to form negative opinions of Forcillo.

“There were numerous comments on YouTube in the early hours (of July 17, 2013) that said things like, “this was justified, Sammy Yatim had a knife, he was dangerous,” said Schneider, who teaches at Manitoba’s Brandon University.

Schneider did, however, think the video’s circulation had a negative effect in that it led to a “trial of public opinion.”

He said members of the public might have come to a conclusion of guilt based on the one-minute-long YouTube video, while jurors got to see other videos and additional pieces of evidence before deciding.

Ross McClean, a former Toronto Police officer, also thought the video’s release on YouTube may have helped Forcillo avoid a worse fate -- a murder or manslaughter conviction -- even though “it had everything to do with charges being laid.”

“He was cleared on those first charges,” McClean told CTV News Channel. “So I don’t think that (video) necessarily prejudiced (jurors).”



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Biden to address the U.S. following Texas school shooting

    World News CTV News
    Washington - U.S. President Joe Biden prepared to address the nation Tuesday night shortly after returning to the White House from a five-day trip to Asia that was bookended by "horrific" mass tragedy. Biden was on Air Force One Tuesday afternoon when officials said a gunman acting alone killed at least 14 students and a teacher at a Texas elementary school. Source
  • Kemp, Perdue duel could end with Georgia's GOP primary

    World News CTV News
    Atlanta - Georgia's Republican gubernatorial primary Tuesday could spell an end to the faceoff between Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp and former U.S. Sen. David Perdue, while Stacey Abrams was crowned the Democratic Party's nominee after running unopposed. Source
  • A look at some of the deadliest U.S. school shootings

    World News CTV News
    There have been dozens of shootings and other attacks in U.S. schools and colleges over the years, but until the massacre at Colorado's Columbine High School in 1999, the number of dead tended to be in the single digits. Source
  • Suspect under arrest in deadly New York City subway shooting

    World News CTV News
    NEW YORK - A man suspected of abruptly pulling a gun and killing a stranger on a New York City subway train was arrested Tuesday, with police saying his motive for the unprovoked attack was “a big mystery. Source
  • Province bailing out Laurentian University with long-term loan

    Canada News CTV News
    The Ontario government is providing Laurentian University with a long-term loan as the school works to emerge from insolvency. Previously, Laurentian had to get what is known as a DIP loan from private institutions at a higher rate of interest. Source
  • Seoul: North Korea launches ballistic missile toward the sea

    World News CTV News
    A new billionaire has been minted nearly every day during the pandemic The COVID-19 pandemic has been good for the wallets of the wealthy. Source
  • Underwater rescue: Spanish divers free whale trapped in illegal fishing net

    World News CBC News
    In a gripping underwater rescue, Spanish divers have freed a 12-metre long humpback whale entangled in an illegal drift net off the Balearic island of Mallorca. One of the divers, 32-year-old marine biologist Gigi Torras, said last Friday's rescue and a little gesture of appreciation from the giant mammal were also a birthday present for her — the "best ever" in her words. Source
  • Mass shooting inquiry: Two senior Mounties exempted from cross-examination

    Canada News CTV News
    HALIFAX - Two lawyers are criticizing a decision Tuesday to allow senior RCMP witnesses to avoid cross-examination before the inquiry investigating the 2020 mass shooting in Nova Scotia. The lawyers, Tara Miller and Josh Bryson, represent relatives of some of the victims gunned down by a killer disguised as a Mountie and driving a replica RCMP cruiser on April 18-19, 2020. Source
  • 14 students and teacher killed in Texas elementary school shooting, governor says

    World News CBC News
    At least 15 people are dead after a shooting at a Texas elementary school, officials said Tuesday. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott said 14 students and a teacher were killed in the shooting in Uvalde, about 135 kilometres west of San Antonio. Source
  • 18 students and 3 adults killed in Texas elementary school shooting, state senator says

    World News CBC News
    At least 15 people are dead after a shooting at a Texas elementary school, officials said Tuesday. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott said 14 students and a teacher were killed in the shooting in Uvalde, about 135 kilometres west of San Antonio. Source