Forcillo conviction stirs debate about 'trial by YouTube'

After Toronto Police Const. James Forcillo was found guilty Monday of attempted murder in the shooting death of teenager Sammy Yatim, the officer’s defence attorney called it a “trial by YouTube.

See Full Article

Lawyer Peter Brauti lamented to reporters outside the courtroom that every potential juror had heard of the shooting before the trial began, and therefore had probably formed an opinion of Forcillo’s actions.

After all, a cellphone video showing the shooting was posted to YouTube hours after the knife-wielding teen was killed on a streetcar on July 27, 2013, and it was widely circulated by those outraged at the officer.

However, an expert in social media’s effect on policing who studied the Yatim shooting for a book said it’s not clear that Forcillo was actually hurt by the video.

Prof. Chris Schneider told CTV News Channel that while the video did “frame how this entire case and circumstance was discussed by the news media and police,” the evidence doesn’t support Brauti’s view that the video caused most potential jurors to form negative opinions of Forcillo.

“There were numerous comments on YouTube in the early hours (of July 17, 2013) that said things like, “this was justified, Sammy Yatim had a knife, he was dangerous,” said Schneider, who teaches at Manitoba’s Brandon University.

Schneider did, however, think the video’s circulation had a negative effect in that it led to a “trial of public opinion.”

He said members of the public might have come to a conclusion of guilt based on the one-minute-long YouTube video, while jurors got to see other videos and additional pieces of evidence before deciding.

Ross McClean, a former Toronto Police officer, also thought the video’s release on YouTube may have helped Forcillo avoid a worse fate -- a murder or manslaughter conviction -- even though “it had everything to do with charges being laid.”

“He was cleared on those first charges,” McClean told CTV News Channel. “So I don’t think that (video) necessarily prejudiced (jurors).”



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Playing down impeachment, Trump campaign voices confidence

    World News CTV News
    WASHINGTON -- U.s. President Donald Trump's reelection campaign on Thursday shrugged off the president's expected impeachment less than a year before Election Day, talking up the campaign's data collection efforts and declaring that no one in the Democratic field can compete with the incumbent. Source
  • Poll suggests travellers know little about air-passenger rights

    Canada News CTV News
    OTTAWA -- New polling results suggest many people boarding flights this holiday season don't know about the Liberal government's new regime outlining air passengers' rights. A Canadian Automobile Association-commissioned poll being made public today found that just over half of respondents said they hadn't heard or read anything about the rules aiming to protect flyers caught in travel nightmares. Source
  • Chile: Plane that vanished en route to Antarctica found

    World News CTV News
    SANTIAGO, CHILE -- Searchers combing Antarctic seas have recovered parts of a military transport plane and human remains belonging to some of the 38 people aboard who vanished en route to the frozen continent, Chilean officials said Thursday. Source
  • Hong Kong police slip on banana peel with tear gas tweet

    World News CTV News
    HONG KONG -- Hong Kong’s much-maligned police force has slipped on a banana peel by trying to make light of its liberal use of tear gas during the territory’s protest movement. Mimicking an artist who duct-taped a banana to a wall, the force tweeted a photo of a canister similarly taped, with the words: “Say NO to violence. Source
  • U.K.'s Johnson claims Brexit mandate as Tories secure majority

    World News CTV News
    LONDON -- Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s Conservative Party has won a thumping majority of seats in Britain’s Parliament -- a decisive outcome to a Brexit-dominated election that should allow Johnson to fulfill his plan to take the U.K. Source
  • Official: Jersey City attack was 'fueled' by anti-Semitism

    World News CTV News
    JERSEY CITY, N.J. -- New Jersey Attorney General Gurbir Grewal says authorities believe a shooting in Jersey City was “fueled both by anti-Semitism and anti-law enforcement beliefs.” Grewal told a news conference Thursday that authorities are investigating the attack as an act of domestic terrorism. Source
  • New Zealand recovers 6 bodies from toxic volcanic island

    World News CTV News
    WHAKATANE, NEW ZEALAND -- As grieving families sang traditional Maori songs, New Zealand military specialists wearing protective gear landed on a small volcanic island Friday morning and recovered six bodies of the 16 people who died in an eruption four days earlier. Source
  • Study reveals the real perpetrators of sexual assault against adolescent girls in Canada

    Canada News CTV News
    TORONTO -- A new study of Canadian sexual assault cases shows that raising the age of consent from 14 to 16 has not led to the prosecution of significant numbers of young men for engaging in sexual relationships with younger teenage girlfriends. Source
  • Krispy Kreme owners donate US$5 million to Holocaust survivors over family's Nazi past

    World News CTV News
    The family that owns well-known food brands like Krispy Kreme and Panera Bread announced a multi-million dollar charity donation after an investigation revealed that their Nazi ancestors used slave labor during World War II. The Reimann family, which owns a controlling stake in JAB Holdings, announced Thursday it's donating more than $5.5 million to Claims Conference, an organization that provides compensation payments to Holocaust survivors. Source
  • Mother rammed barber with car because she was upset with son's haircut: authorities

    World News CTV News
    ANTIOCH, CALIF. -- A San Francisco Bay Area mother suspected of ramming her car into her son's barber following a haircut surrendered to authorities, police said. Ruby Delgadillo, 28, brought an attorney with her when she turned herself in Wednesday and refused to give a statement to detectives, the Antioch Police Department said. Source