Forcillo conviction stirs debate about 'trial by YouTube'

After Toronto Police Const. James Forcillo was found guilty Monday of attempted murder in the shooting death of teenager Sammy Yatim, the officer’s defence attorney called it a “trial by YouTube.

See Full Article

Lawyer Peter Brauti lamented to reporters outside the courtroom that every potential juror had heard of the shooting before the trial began, and therefore had probably formed an opinion of Forcillo’s actions.

After all, a cellphone video showing the shooting was posted to YouTube hours after the knife-wielding teen was killed on a streetcar on July 27, 2013, and it was widely circulated by those outraged at the officer.

However, an expert in social media’s effect on policing who studied the Yatim shooting for a book said it’s not clear that Forcillo was actually hurt by the video.

Prof. Chris Schneider told CTV News Channel that while the video did “frame how this entire case and circumstance was discussed by the news media and police,” the evidence doesn’t support Brauti’s view that the video caused most potential jurors to form negative opinions of Forcillo.

“There were numerous comments on YouTube in the early hours (of July 17, 2013) that said things like, “this was justified, Sammy Yatim had a knife, he was dangerous,” said Schneider, who teaches at Manitoba’s Brandon University.

Schneider did, however, think the video’s circulation had a negative effect in that it led to a “trial of public opinion.”

He said members of the public might have come to a conclusion of guilt based on the one-minute-long YouTube video, while jurors got to see other videos and additional pieces of evidence before deciding.

Ross McClean, a former Toronto Police officer, also thought the video’s release on YouTube may have helped Forcillo avoid a worse fate -- a murder or manslaughter conviction -- even though “it had everything to do with charges being laid.”

“He was cleared on those first charges,” McClean told CTV News Channel. “So I don’t think that (video) necessarily prejudiced (jurors).”



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Villain of Green Gables: Thief steals coins from P.E.I. wishing well

    Canada News CTV News
    CAVENDISH, P.E.I. -- P.E.I. residents are being asked to watch for muddy, dirty coins after thieves climbed deep into an historic wishing well to steal money from the bottom. Charlottetown RCMP say thieves damaged the well, at an Anne of Green Gables-related National Historic Site in Cavendish, and used a ladder to get to the bottom sometime in the last week. Source
  • Ontario lawyers agree to tackle systemic racism in the profession

    Canada News CTV News
    TORONTO -- Larger law firms would be expected to work toward racial diversification and have to report out on their progress under recommendations approved without opposition Friday by the profession's regulatory body in Ontario following hours of emotional debate. Source
  • Drone sighting delays flights at Toronto island airport

    Canada News CTV News
    Two airliners were forced to delay their landings at Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport due to reports of a drone near the airport on Friday morning. The Porter Airlines and Air Canada flights held over Lake Ontario before making their approach to the downtown island airport. Source
  • Amber Alert issued for Luisa Noyemi Alvarenga, 8, taken from Portage la Prairie

    Canada News CBC News
    Portage la Prairie, Man., RCMP have issued an Amber Alert for eight-year-old Luisa Noyemi Alvarenga. Police will provide an update just after 6:00 p.m. CT. At approximately 11 a.m. on Friday, Luisa was taken from her home in Portage la Prairie by her biological mother, Colleen Sheryl McIvor, 43, police say. Source
  • Trump's Carrier deal saves 800 jobs in exchange for $7M in incentives

    World News CBC News
    The $7-million incentive package Carrier Corp. will receive in a deal with U.S. president-elect Donald Trump and vice president-elect Mike Pence is a departure from how tax credits are commonly used in Indiana. The furnace and air conditioner manufacturer will receive $5 million in tax credits over the next decade in exchange for keeping hundreds of jobs at its Indianapolis plant, the Indianapolis Star reported. Source
  • Amber Alert for girl, 8, missing in Manitoba

    Canada News CTV News
    The Manitoba RMCP has issued an Amber Alert after an eight-year-old girl was allegedly abducted by her mother from Portage la Prairie, Man. The child, who has been identified as Luisa Noyemi Alvarenga, was last seen in a stolen black Chevy Sierra with the license plate FPB 968. Source
  • Calgary sisters meet woman saved by dad's heart [Video]

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    Thwump thwump thwump thwump. The sound of the beating heart was loud and strong, sending a message of love and gratitude. “That was their dad, Bob, talking to them, saying hi,” said Julie Lyons, after two strangers listened to her heart through a stethoscope in a crowded Toronto airport terminal. Source
  • Calgary senior mentally unfit for trial in wife's murder

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    Calgary senior Fred Van Zuiden, who is charged with murdering his wife, is mentally unfit to stand trial, his lawyer told court Friday. Defence counsel Alain Hepner said testing by Dr. Ken Hashman at the Southern Alberta Forensic Psychiatry Centre, show the octogenarian doesn't understand the legal process and is unable to instruct the lawyer. Source
  • Details emerge on Joe McKnight shooting

    Canada News CBC News
    Officials say Joe McKnight was shot three times — in the hand, shoulder and chest — and insist the shooter was not standing over the Saskatchewan Roughriders player. The 28-year-old CFL and NFL running back died Thursday afternoon following what was described as a traffic argument at an intersection in a suburb of New Orleans. Source
  • Woman charged with first-degree murder in Canadian scholar’s U.S. death

    World News Toronto Sun
    A woman arrested in the death of a Canadian legal scholar in Florida has been charged with first-degree murder for her alleged role in what investigators have suggested was a murder-for-hire rooted in a bitter divorce. A U.S. Source