Judge delivers final instructions to jurors who will decide Forcillo's fate

TORONTO -- Jurors deciding the fate of a Toronto police officer charged in the fatal shooting of a teen on an empty streetcar were asked Monday to assess the evidence in the case with an open mind.

See Full Article

In his instruction to the jury, Justice Edward Then said the Crown must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Const. James Forcillo is guilty of second-degree murder in the death of Sammy Yatim.

"If you believe that officer Forcillo is probably guilty but no more, then in those circumstances you must find him not guilty," the judge said.

Forcillo has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder and attempted murder.

The jury has heard that on a night in July 2013, Yatim had taken the drug ecstasy before boarding a streetcar where he pulled out a small knife, prompting panicked passengers to rush off the vehicle.

Videos and audio played at the trial have shown that Forcillo arrived on the scene, yelled repeatedly at Yatim to drop the knife, and after a 50-second confrontation fired nine bullets at the teen.

Crown prosecutors argue Forcillo's actions weren't necessary or reasonable but his lawyer contends the officer's actions were justified and carried out in self-defence.

The judge highlighted the fact that Forcillo had testified in his own defence, reminding the jury that the officer got "no special marks" for doing so.

"You assess his credibility in the same manner as you do with any other witnesses. What he says may be evidence for or against him," Then said.

He noted, however, that Forcillo's testimony had to be carefully considered.

"If you believe the evidence of the accused then you must acquit him," Then said.

"If you do not believe the evidence of the accused but are left in a state of reasonable doubt on the evidence of the accused, then you must also acquit him."

The jury also didn't need to find a motive or reasons for Forcillo's actions on the night Yatim died, Then said.

"It is for you to decide whether officer Forcillo had a motive or any motive at all, and how much or how little you will rely on it."

Forcillo has told the jury that he believed Yatim was going to rush off the streetcar and launch an attack when he said he saw the teen flick his knife towards him.

The jury has heard that when Yatim took a few steps back to the spot at the top of the streetcar steps, Forcillo -- who had warned the teen not to take another step forward -- fires nine bullets at Yatim in two separate volleys.

The teen collapses immediately. The entire standoff lasted about 50 seconds.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Iran's supreme leader says 'no talks with U.S. at any level'

    World News CBC News
    Iran's supreme leader announced on Tuesday that "there will be no talks with the U.S. at any level" — remarks apparently meant to end all speculation about a possible U.S.-Iran meeting between the two countries' presidents at the UN later this month. Source
  • Hidden asbestos: Hundreds of homes in Peterborough, Ont., suspected of containing toxic material from GE plant

    Canada News CBC News
    When Ernie Farris walked past his childhood home in Peterborough, Ont., this summer for the first time in years, he had an alarming thought. In the late 1940s, as a young teen, he had helped his father unload a truck full of fluffy, white scrap asbestos from the local General Electric factory, spreading it in the family's attic as cheap insulation. Source
  • Green leader gets stuck in the sands of World War II history

    Canada News CBC News
    Elizabeth May is an expert on climate change and the environment. She has a law degree from Dalhousie University. And for a time, she studied theology at St. Paul's University in Ottawa with an eye to becoming an Anglican priest. Source
  • New giant salamander species now the world's largest amphibian

    World News CBC News
    Scientists have discovered a new species of giant salamander and concluded that the largest amphibian ever recorded was a member of that species. For a long time, scientists thought all Chinese giant salamanders belonged to a single species, Andrias davidianus. Source
  • Is there a way out for Hong Kong? Not likely, as protesters become more inflamed

    World News CBC News
    After more than 100 days of protest, Hong Kong is one bitter place. Anger and resentment hang in the air and explode on the streets almost daily now. And not just outside the legislature and other symbols of a deeply unpopular government. Source
  • Bernier's in — and the federal election debates just got less predictable

    Canada News CBC News
    The stage is set for Maxime Bernier. His challenge now is to perform. The leader of the nascent People's Party of Canada (PPC) yesterday got his coveted invitation to take part in the two televised debates organized by the independent Leaders' Debate Commission. Source
  • Israelis vote in repeat election centred on Netanyahu

    World News CBC News
    Israelis began voting Tuesday in an unprecedented repeat election that will decide whether longtime Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stays in power despite a looming indictment on corruption charges. Netanyahu, the longest serving leader in Israeli history, is seeking a fourth consecutive term in office, and fifth overall. Source
  • Police respond to reports of shooting at Calgary area mall

    Canada News CBC News
    Airdrie RCMP and Calgary police are on scene at CrossIron Mills mall after RCMP received reports of shots fired at the mall at approximately 7:11 p.m. One male has been injured and the suspect is still at large. Source
  • Taiwan says Solomon Islands switches recognition to China

    World News CTV News
    TAIPEI, Taiwan -- The Solomon Islands switched diplomatic recognition from Taiwan to China on Monday, becoming the latest country to leave the dwindling Taiwanese camp. Taiwan's Foreign Ministry confirmed the move, saying the Solomon Islands Cabinet approved a resolution to recognize Beijing as the government of China. Source
  • White House orders two former aides to defy House subpoenas

    World News CTV News
    WASHINGTON -- The White House has instructed two former aides to U.S. President Donald Trump not to appear at a House Judiciary Committee hearing Tuesday, saying Rick Dearborn and Rob Porter are "absolutely immune" from testifying at what the panel is calling its first impeachment hearing. Source