Jury urged to find Melonie Biddersingh drowned in unclear circumstances

TORONTO -- The defence at a trial involving the death of a teenage girl whose body was found stuffed in a burning suitcase is urging jurors to accept forensic evidence that she drowned.

See Full Article

Lawyer Jennifer Penman tells the Toronto jury there is no evidence as to how Melonie Biddersingh drowned.

Given the uncertainty, Penman says jurors must acquit her father, Everton Biddersingh, 60, of first-degree murder.

Court has heard from the stepmother and brother about the terrible abuse 17-year-old Biddersingh endured before her death.

Penman says convicting her father on the basis of what she termed their self-serving testimony would be dangerous.

The defence called no witnesses and Biddersingh didn't take the stand in his own defence.

He has pleaded not guilty in the death of his daughter, whose charred body was found 21 years ago. It would be almost two decades before police were able to lay charges.

The Crown argues the teen died Sept. 1, 1994, essentially starved to death.

The trial has previously heard that the teen was confined for hours in a tiny closet, had her head placed in a toilet that was flushed, was chained to the furniture at times, was denied food and was kicked, punched and thrown against walls by her father.

After she died, the Crown has said, Biddersingh crammed his daughter into a suitcase, drove her to a remote area and set her on fire.

"The tragedy of this young woman's death may easily overwhelm our imaginations," Penman said in her closing argument. "A lot of terrible things went on in that apartment."

Penman said her weakened state might have been a factor in her death.

"That is not the same thing as saying starvation was the cause of death," the lawyer said.

Biddersingh's wife, Elaine, whom the defence said "hated" the teen, faces her own murder trial in April.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Number of snow days in N.S. schools amounts to a crisis: expert

    Canada News CTV News
    HALIFAX -- An education expert says it is "bizarre" how often Nova Scotia schools are closed because of weather -- and the number of days lost this year amounts to a crisis. Paul Bennett, director of Schoolhouse Consulting in Halifax, said there has been an average of 12 lost days this school year in the province due to inclement weather. Source
  • PC MPP apologizes for questioning zero-tolerance of sexual abuse of patients

    Canada News CTV News
    TORONTO -- Progressive Conservative MPP Jack MacLaren is apologizing for comments he made about the sexual abuse of patients. The Ottawa-area MPP had called a "zero-tolerance approach" to sexual abuse "dangerous" during a debate on Monday. Source
  • Driver returns birthday cash to woman who left purse on Calgary train

    Canada News CTV News
    CALGARY -- A woman who left behind a purse with $1,300 in birthday cash on a Calgary light-rail train says she can barely believe someone was honest enough to return it. Li Feng Yang had received the money for her 75th birthday and was planning to deposit it in the bank. Source
  • High school cheerleader in Oregon dies after being pinned beneath log along beach

    World News Toronto Sun
    Tragedy struck a coastal town in Oregon last weekend when a teen died after being pinned beneath a log at a beach. Aurora Sheffel and her friends were taking selfies on a 30-foot log when a strong tide swept it out from underneath them, pinning Sheffel. Source
  • 7 years for biting off dog's head, punching girlfriend

    World News Toronto Sun
    SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico — A man in Puerto Rico has been sentenced to seven years in prison for biting off the head of a Chihuahua and punching his girlfriend. Authorities said Tuesday that a judge also ordered Luis Arroyo to pay a US$3,000 fine in the case that included domestic abuse and mistreatment of an animal. Source
  • Puerto Rico man bit off head of girlfriend's dog

    World News CTV News
    SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico -- A man in Puerto Rico has been sentenced to seven years in prison for biting off the head of a Chihuahua and punching his girlfriend. Authorities said Tuesday that a judge also ordered Luis Arroyo to pay a $3,000 fine in the case that included domestic abuse and mistreatment of an animal. Source
  • Newfoundland and Labrador throne speech sets course through fiscal mess

    Canada News CTV News
    ST. JOHN'S, N.L. -- A throne speech today in Newfoundland and Labrador tries to turn a historic fiscal mess into an opportunity to do more with less. Lt.-Gov. Frank Fagan read the 32-page speech, which says the Liberal government took power in 2015 "at a fiscal breaking point. Source
  • Scotland to hold another referendum on exiting U.K.

    World News Toronto Sun
    EDINBURGH, Scotland — Scottish lawmakers voted Tuesday to seek a new referendum on independence, to be held within the next two years — an unwanted headache for the British government as it prepares to push the European Union exit button. Source
  • 'Carlos the Jackal' sentenced to life for deadly 1974 Paris attack

    World News CBC News
    A French court on Tuesday convicted the man known as "Carlos the Jackal," once the world's most-wanted fugitive, of a deadly 1974 attack on a Paris shopping arcade and sentenced him to life in prison for the third time. Source
  • Scottish MPs vote for new independence referendum

    World News CTV News
    EDINBURGH, Scotland -- Scottish lawmakers voted Tuesday to seek a new referendum on independence, to be held within the next two years -- an unwanted headache for the British government as it prepares to push the European Union exit button. Source