Jury urged to find Melonie Biddersingh drowned in unclear circumstances

TORONTO -- The defence at a trial involving the death of a teenage girl whose body was found stuffed in a burning suitcase is urging jurors to accept forensic evidence that she drowned.

See Full Article

Lawyer Jennifer Penman tells the Toronto jury there is no evidence as to how Melonie Biddersingh drowned.

Given the uncertainty, Penman says jurors must acquit her father, Everton Biddersingh, 60, of first-degree murder.

Court has heard from the stepmother and brother about the terrible abuse 17-year-old Biddersingh endured before her death.

Penman says convicting her father on the basis of what she termed their self-serving testimony would be dangerous.

The defence called no witnesses and Biddersingh didn't take the stand in his own defence.

He has pleaded not guilty in the death of his daughter, whose charred body was found 21 years ago. It would be almost two decades before police were able to lay charges.

The Crown argues the teen died Sept. 1, 1994, essentially starved to death.

The trial has previously heard that the teen was confined for hours in a tiny closet, had her head placed in a toilet that was flushed, was chained to the furniture at times, was denied food and was kicked, punched and thrown against walls by her father.

After she died, the Crown has said, Biddersingh crammed his daughter into a suitcase, drove her to a remote area and set her on fire.

"The tragedy of this young woman's death may easily overwhelm our imaginations," Penman said in her closing argument. "A lot of terrible things went on in that apartment."

Penman said her weakened state might have been a factor in her death.

"That is not the same thing as saying starvation was the cause of death," the lawyer said.

Biddersingh's wife, Elaine, whom the defence said "hated" the teen, faces her own murder trial in April.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Arctic sea ice hits another record monthly low

    World News CBC News
    Though this is when the Arctic is supposed to be refreezing, scientists say sea ice there hit record low levels for November. In the crucial Barents Sea, the amount of floating ice decreased when it would be expected to grow. Source
  • Chief feels 'abandoned' as Sûreté du Québec to pull officers from Lac-Simon

    Canada News CBC News
    The Sûreté du Québec is removing its officers from Lac-Simon, an Algonquin reserve near Val-d'Or, amid strained relations between police and the Indigenous community. The timeline for the withdrawal isn't clear. The chief of the Anishnaabe Nation of Lac-Simon told Radio-Canada the SQ will stop patrolling starting today. Source
  • Toddler dies after swallowing pill at relatives' home: police

    Canada News CTV News
    WHITBY, Ont. -- Police are warning people to lock up their medication following the death of a toddler east of Toronto. The incident took place on Nov. 19 after a Whitby, Ont., family visited relatives. Source
  • Tamara Lovett's father says she and Ryan were inseparable

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    Tamara Lovett was a loving mother who cared greatly for her son Ryan, her negligence trial was told Tuesday. Among those testifying was Lovett’s father, Donn, who battled tears to tell court his grandson was a healthy boy whose mother treated him kindly. Source
  • Trump is Time magazine’s Person of the Year

    World News Toronto Sun
    WASHINGTON — Time magazine on Wednesday named president-elect Donald Trump its Person of the Year. “It’s a great honour. It means a lot,” Trump said in a telephone interview on NBC’s “Today” show. The magazine’s managing editor, Nancy Gibbs, said on the program that Democrat Hillary Clinton was the No. Source
  • Alberta, Saskatchewan ranchers brace for impact of bovine TB cull and quarantine

    Canada News CBC News
    Farmers from more than 40 ranches in Alberta and Saskatchewan are wondering what kind of compensation and business lies ahead for them as the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) cracks down on a bovine tuberculosis outbreak in Western Canada. Source
  • Frantic rescue underway as quake kills dozens in Indonesia [Video]

    World News Toronto Sun
    BIREUEN, Indonesia — A strong undersea earthquake rocked Indonesia’s Aceh province early on Wednesday, killing at least 25 people and causing dozens of buildings to collapse. The U.S. Geological Survey said the shallow 6.4-magnitude earthquake that struck at 5:03 a.m. Source
  • 3 things Canada can't explain about the way it funds First Nations education

    Canada News CBC News
    Canada's parliamentary budget officer says the Liberal government cannot explain how it calculates the amount of funding it spends on First Nations education or why it is nearly $600 million dollars less than the average provincial education system. Source
  • Pakistani national carrier's plane missing after takeoff

    World News CTV News
    ISLAMABAD -- A plane belonging to Pakistan's national carrier crashed on Wednesday shortly after takeoff from the country's north with about 40 people on board, a spokesman and the police said. According to senior police officer Khurram Rasheed, the plane crashed in a village near the town of Havelian, located about 75 kilometres northwest from the capital, Islamabad. Source
  • Pakistani plane crashes after takeoff with 48 people aboard

    World News CTV News
    ISLAMABAD -- A plane belonging to Pakistan's national carrier crashed on Wednesday with 48 people on board, apparently killing all of them, police and an airline spokesman said. According to senior police officer Khurram Rasheed, the plane crashed in a village near the town of Havelian, located about 75 kilometres northwest of the capital, Islamabad. Source