Jury urged to find Melonie Biddersingh drowned in unclear circumstances

TORONTO -- The defence at a trial involving the death of a teenage girl whose body was found stuffed in a burning suitcase is urging jurors to accept forensic evidence that she drowned.

See Full Article

Lawyer Jennifer Penman tells the Toronto jury there is no evidence as to how Melonie Biddersingh drowned.

Given the uncertainty, Penman says jurors must acquit her father, Everton Biddersingh, 60, of first-degree murder.

Court has heard from the stepmother and brother about the terrible abuse 17-year-old Biddersingh endured before her death.

Penman says convicting her father on the basis of what she termed their self-serving testimony would be dangerous.

The defence called no witnesses and Biddersingh didn't take the stand in his own defence.

He has pleaded not guilty in the death of his daughter, whose charred body was found 21 years ago. It would be almost two decades before police were able to lay charges.

The Crown argues the teen died Sept. 1, 1994, essentially starved to death.

The trial has previously heard that the teen was confined for hours in a tiny closet, had her head placed in a toilet that was flushed, was chained to the furniture at times, was denied food and was kicked, punched and thrown against walls by her father.

After she died, the Crown has said, Biddersingh crammed his daughter into a suitcase, drove her to a remote area and set her on fire.

"The tragedy of this young woman's death may easily overwhelm our imaginations," Penman said in her closing argument. "A lot of terrible things went on in that apartment."

Penman said her weakened state might have been a factor in her death.

"That is not the same thing as saying starvation was the cause of death," the lawyer said.

Biddersingh's wife, Elaine, whom the defence said "hated" the teen, faces her own murder trial in April.



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Two Canadian border agents charged with drug smuggling

    Canada News CTV News
    TORONTO -- Two Canadian border agents are among five people arrested on suspicion of drug smuggling. RCMP and Canada Border Services Agency say the agents worked out of Toronto's Pearson International Airport. Authorities allege the pair facilitated the importation of more than 30 kilograms of cocaine between January last year and April this year. Source
  • Another court delay for 2 men accused of assaulting Dennis Oland in prison

    Canada News CTV News
    MIRAMICHI, N.B. -- The case of two Halifax men charged with assaulting Dennis Oland in a New Brunswick prison has been delayed yet again. Convicted killer Cody Alexander Muise and Aaron Marriott, who was convicted in a 2008 drug shooting, allegedly attacked Oland at Atlantic Institution in Renous, N.B. Source
  • Doctor dragged off United flight reaches settlement with airline

    World News CTV News
    A Kentucky doctor dragged off a United Airlines flight in Chicago has reached a settlement with the airline for an undisclosed amount. More to come... Source
  • Queen Elizabeth’s favourite treats may surprise you

    World News Toronto Sun
    What Queen Elizabeth wants, Queen Elizabeth gets. A new report suggests that the long-reigning monarch has more pedestrian tastes in food stuffs than you’d think. In the U.K., companies that supply the Queen and the royals for five years out of seven are rewarded with a royal warrant. Source
  • VIDEO: Baby penguin chicks make debut at London Zoo [Video]

    World News Toronto Sun
    LONDON - Two baby penguins are the latest additions to the penguin colony at London Zoo. One hatched on April 17, followed two days later by the other. The tiny Humboldt penguin chicks are being looked after by keepers because their parents were unable to care for them. Source
  • Not-guilty plea for doc in Detroit genital mutilation case

    World News CTV News
    DETROIT - A not-guilty plea has been entered for a Detroit-area doctor charged with performing genital mutilation on two Minnesota girls in a first-of-its-kind case in the United States. Dr. Jumana Nagarwala appeared in Detroit federal court Thursday, a day after being indicted. Source
  • Just over half of us OK with legalizing pot, poll finds

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    Canadians are shouting “don’t bogart that joint!” A new Forum Research poll reveals that 53% believe marijuana should be legal in Canada and half also believe there should be an amnesty for pot offences. The random sampling of 1,479 Canadian voters found 38% don’t think weed should be legalized and about one in 10 are unsure. Source
  • PM Trudeau’s approval rating tumbles

    Canada News Toronto Sun
    Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s “sunny ways” are falling flat with a growing number of voters, according to a new poll. A Forum Research poll released Thursday found Trudeau’s approval rating has fallen to 42% — a significant drop from last November when 58% of respondents gave the prime minister the thumbs up. Source
  • Tearful mom of international student missing in Vancouver asks for public's help

    Canada News CTV News
    VANCOUVER - The mother of a missing Ecuadorian man studying in Vancouver has issued an emotional plea for information that could help find her son. Lupe Carrera travelled to Vancouver from Ecuador and spoke at a news conference at the University of British Columbia. Source
  • Who is Toronto’s now-infamous 'Crane Girl'?

    Canada News CTV News
    The 23-year-old woman who appears to have spent hours suspended on a crane high above a downtown Toronto construction site early Wednesday is being described by a close friend as a “very adventurous girl.” Marisa Lazo, who has since been dubbed ‘Crane Girl,’ is believed to have slid down a cable to the crane’s pulley device, where she became stranded. Source