Infant murder case collapses after key evidence goes missing

A Newfoundland and Labrador man facing a second-degree murder charge in the death of his infant son has seen the charges withdrawn because a key piece of evidence - the baby's brain – can no longer be found.

See Full Article

Thomas Michel of Sheshatshiu First Nation was charged in November 2013 with second-degree murder in the death of his son, Matthew Rich.

The prosecution team had planned to call experts in forensic pathology and neuropathology to testify as witnesses in the case, the province’s justice department said in a news release.

The experts required access to the baby's brain so they could examine it and provide opinions for the prosecution. But the Chief Medical Examiner's office could not locate the brain of the infant.

They say the brain is presumed to have been destroyed.

Without the brain evidence, the province’s Public Prosecutions office said “there was no longer a reasonable likelihood of conviction.” As such, the decision was made to withdraw the second-degree murder charge.

“This was not an easy decision for Public Prosecutions to make and was only made after lengthy consultations with the expert witnesses,” the justice department said in its statement.

“…The Public Prosecutions Division of the Department of Justice and Public Safety expresses its sincerest condolences to the family of Matthew Rich.”



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • China reports 141 dead or missing in flooding since June

    World News CBC News
    The Yangtze River region has seen its second highest rainfall in more than a half-century so far this year as deadly flooding strikes much of China. Around 28,000 homes have been damaged and 141 people have died or are missing in the floods since last month. Source
  • China bans several U.S. officials for criticizing policies toward minority groups

    World News CBC News
    China on Monday said it will ban entry to U.S. Senators Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz, Rep. Chris Smith and Ambassador for Religious Freedom Sam Brownback over their criticism of the ruling Communist Party's policies toward minority groups and people of faith. Source
  • U.K. tries new campaign to prepare public for Brexit

    World News CTV News
    LONDON -- Brexit moved back to the front-burner of British politics on Monday, months after COVID-19 knocked it out of the headlines, with the government launching a new public information campaign to prepare the nation for departure. Source
  • Ontario will announce plans on Monday to move forward to Stage 3

    Canada News CTV News
    TORONTO -- Ontario Premier Doug Ford will unveil plans to move forward to the next stage of the province's reopening plan on Monday, CTV News Toronto has learned. Ford will make the announcement during his daily press briefing at Queen's Park. Source
  • Video that shows Pennsylvania officer with knee on man's neck sparks fury

    World News CTV News
    ALLENTOWN, PA. -- Video posted on social media that shows a Pennsylvania police officer with his knee on a man's neck while trying to restrain him has prompted protests and a demand from the local Black Lives Matter group to suspend the officers involved. Source
  • India reports another record surge of COVID-19 infections

    World News CBC News
    The latest:Masks will soon be mandatory in Quebec's indoor public spaces, Radio-Canada reports.Ontario set to detail Stage 3 of reopening plan today as COVID-19 cases decline.Florida shatters U.S. record for largest single-day increase in COVID-19 cases on Sunday. Source
  • N.W.T. ignored in Alberta monitoring suspension despite agreement: leaked emails

    Canada News CTV News
    EDMONTON -- Alberta suspended environmental monitoring for oilsands companies without notifying the Northwest Territories, despite a legally binding agreement to do so. The omission is revealed in a series of emails between the two governments obtained by The Canadian Press. Source
  • Oldest Canadian Coast Guard ship to return to service after lengthy refit

    Canada News CBC News
    The oldest ship in the Canadian Coast Guard fleet will return to service next month after spending three of the last four years in refit. The 57-year old CCGS Hudson is days away from completing a vessel-life extension and is now expected to remain in service until its 2024 retirement date. Source
  • Near final results show Polish President Duda wins 2nd term

    World News CBC News
    Poland's conservative President Andrzej Duda narrowly won a second five-year term in a bitterly fought weekend election, defeating the liberal Warsaw mayor, according to a near-complete count of votes. The state electoral commission said that Duda had 51.21 per cent of the vote based on a count of votes from 99.97 per cent districts. Source
  • Nunavut's high rate of police-related deaths 'obviously worth looking into,' says data expert

    Canada News CBC News
    Inuit in Nunavut are dying during interactions with police at a rate significantly higher than in Yukon, Northwest Territories and Ontario, according to data collected and analyzed by CBC and a statistical expert in criminology. That trend is especially apparent since 2010, with a rate of police-related deaths in Nunavut more than 14 times higher than both Yukon and Ontario and more than three times higher than the Northwest Territories. Source