Infant murder case collapses after key evidence goes missing

A Newfoundland and Labrador man facing a second-degree murder charge in the death of his infant son has seen the charges withdrawn because a key piece of evidence - the baby's brain – can no longer be found.

See Full Article

Thomas Michel of Sheshatshiu First Nation was charged in November 2013 with second-degree murder in the death of his son, Matthew Rich.

The prosecution team had planned to call experts in forensic pathology and neuropathology to testify as witnesses in the case, the province’s justice department said in a news release.

The experts required access to the baby's brain so they could examine it and provide opinions for the prosecution. But the Chief Medical Examiner's office could not locate the brain of the infant.

They say the brain is presumed to have been destroyed.

Without the brain evidence, the province’s Public Prosecutions office said “there was no longer a reasonable likelihood of conviction.” As such, the decision was made to withdraw the second-degree murder charge.

“This was not an easy decision for Public Prosecutions to make and was only made after lengthy consultations with the expert witnesses,” the justice department said in its statement.

“…The Public Prosecutions Division of the Department of Justice and Public Safety expresses its sincerest condolences to the family of Matthew Rich.”



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • Driver charged in death of Hamilton woman giving water to pigs at protest has first day in court

    Canada News CBC News
    A truck driver charged with careless driving causing death has his first day in court Monday after police say he killed an animal-rights activist who was giving water to pigs being led to slaughter. Police say the man, who police have not named, was driving his truck to Fearman's Pork plant in Burlington, Ont. Source
  • Meet Olaf Scholz, the man who might replace Angela Merkel as Germany's next chancellor

    World News CTV News
    Olaf Scholz has some big shoes to fill. The German Finance Minister has the best shot at forming a new German government after leading his Social Democratic Party (SPD) to a narrow victory in Sunday's parliamentary elections. Source
  • Indian farmers ramp up protests against farm laws

    World News CBC News
    now Source
  • Barbers in Afghanistan's Helmand Province are now prohibited from shaving beards and playing music

    World News CTV News
    Barbers in Afghanistan's Helmand Province are now prohibited from shaving men's beards and playing music in their shops, according to a statement issued by the province's Taliban-led department of virtue and vice. The new regulations mark the latest in a series of restrictions placed on the people of Afghanistan based on the Taliban's strict interpretation of Islamic Sharia law. Source
  • China to reduce abortions for 'non-medical purposes'

    World News CTV News
    BEIJING -- China will reduce the number of abortions performed for "non-medical purposes," the country's cabinet announced in new guidelines issued on Monday. The State Council said action would also be taken to avoid unwanted pregnancies and to encourage men to "share responsibility" in preventing them. Source
  • Edmonton family searching for answers after man in 'confrontation' with remand centre staff dies

    Canada News CBC News
    WARNING: This story contains a graphic photograph. A grieving family wants answers after 50-year-old Danny Robinson died following a confrontation with staff at the Edmonton Remand Centre. Robinson's family said he was pulled over by Edmonton police on Aug. 23, and taken into custody for unpaid traffic fines. Source
  • Landmark N.B. covered bridge to be demolished and replaced

    Canada News CBC News
    One of New Brunswick's most iconic covered bridges will be removed this week, following a lengthy fight by heritage advocates to protect it. The Vaughan Creek Covered Bridge in St. Martins was built in 1935 and has been closed to traffic for several years after inspections found it unsafe for heavy traffic. Source
  • India's farmers renew protests, challenging Modi government

    World News CTV News
    NEW DELHI -- Thousands of Indian farmers blocked traffic on major roads and railway tracks outside of the nation's capital on Monday, marking one year of demonstrations against government-backed laws that they say will shatter their livelihoods. Source
  • Fredericton housing crisis leaves some newcomers living in wretched conditions

    Canada News CBC News
    Hamadi Hamisi and his family spent 10 years trying to survive on meagre rations in a refugee camp in Kenya, living in a mud house with a bamboo roof. This year in Fredericton, as newly arrived refugees looking for a place to live, they stood in a dark, dank basement apartment, where mould grew on the walls, there was no proper ventilation, and the single, tiny window in one of the three bedrooms was broken. Source
  • Businesses, schools and cities to observe National Day for Truth and Reconciliation

    Canada News CTV News
    As the first National Day for Truth and Reconciliation approaches, Alana Hogstead has decided as a small-business owner to close up her shop in honour of the day. Hogstead co-owns Martha's Music in Camrose, Alta. Source