Infant murder case collapses after key evidence goes missing

A Newfoundland and Labrador man facing a second-degree murder charge in the death of his infant son has seen the charges withdrawn because a key piece of evidence - the baby's brain – can no longer be found.

See Full Article

Thomas Michel of Sheshatshiu First Nation was charged in November 2013 with second-degree murder in the death of his son, Matthew Rich.

The prosecution team had planned to call experts in forensic pathology and neuropathology to testify as witnesses in the case, the province’s justice department said in a news release.

The experts required access to the baby's brain so they could examine it and provide opinions for the prosecution. But the Chief Medical Examiner's office could not locate the brain of the infant.

They say the brain is presumed to have been destroyed.

Without the brain evidence, the province’s Public Prosecutions office said “there was no longer a reasonable likelihood of conviction.” As such, the decision was made to withdraw the second-degree murder charge.

“This was not an easy decision for Public Prosecutions to make and was only made after lengthy consultations with the expert witnesses,” the justice department said in its statement.

“…The Public Prosecutions Division of the Department of Justice and Public Safety expresses its sincerest condolences to the family of Matthew Rich.”



Advertisements

Latest Canada & World News

  • A second Alberta man told to remove pro-oil and gas shirt during Parliament tour

    Canada News CTV News
    TORONTO -- For the second time this month, a Calgary man was told to remove his “I love Canadian oil and gas” shirt while visiting Ottawa’s Parliament. Chris Wollin said a security officer told him that he couldn’t wear his sweatshirt, which displayed his support for the oil and gas industry, because the Senate prohibits political messages in the building. Source
  • University of Victoria opens counselling services after deadly bus crash kills two students

    Canada News CTV News
    VICTORIA -- University of Victoria students are grappling with the sudden deaths of two of their peers in a bus crash Friday evening en route to a marine research centre. Forty-five students and two teaching assistants were aboard the bus to Bamfield Marine Sciences Centre when it went off a gravel road and down an embankment about 40 kilometres from Port Alberni on Vancouver Island, according to a statement from the university. Source
  • Federal party leaders address gun violence after weekend shooting near Toronto

    Canada News CBC News
    After what police called an "ambush-style" shooting in Mississauga, Ont., killed a teenager and wounded five other people, federal party leaders were quick to offer condolences Sunday, but had little in the way of new ideas to address gun violence in Canada's cities. Source
  • Forecasters warn of U.S. coast rip currents caused by Humberto

    World News CTV News
    MIAMI -- Beachgoers on the southeastern U.S. coast should be wary of potentially dangerous rip currents caused by Tropical Storm Humberto, the National Hurricane Center said Sunday. On Sunday evening, Humberto was 170 miles (270 kilometres) east-northeast of Cape Canaveral, Florida, and moving north at 6 mph (9 kph). Source
  • Victoria university opens counselling services after deadly bus crash kills 2 students

    Canada News CBC News
    University of Victoria students are grappling with the sudden deaths of two of their peers in a bus crash Friday evening en route to a marine research centre. Forty-five students and two teaching assistants were aboard the bus to Bamfield Marine Sciences Centre when it went off a gravel road and down an embankment about 40 kilometres from Port Alberni on Vancouver Island, according to a statement from the university. Source
  • Saskatoon Heritage Society seeks city council help to revive part of historic Capitol movie theatre

    Canada News CBC News
    The Saskatoon Heritage Society is looking for city council's support in honouring a unique part of the city's past. The group wants to restore and publicly display artifacts from the Capitol movie theatre. For 50 years, the building reigned as the city's grand movie palace and doubled as a public gathering place until its bitterly-opposed demolition in 1979. Source
  • Church of Scotland sues for share of Viking treasure trove

    World News CTV News
    The Church of Scotland is suing a man for a share of a US$2.5 million Viking treasure trove he discovered with a metal detector on church land in 2014. Retired businessman and detectorist Derek McLennan uncovered the 10th-century hoard in a field in the Dumfries and Galloway region of western Scotland. Source
  • Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer promises a 'universal tax credit' if elected

    Canada News CBC News
    Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer unveiled a new tax cut plan Sunday that he says will save taxpayers hundreds of dollars a year, a key plank of the Tory platform to make life more affordable. Scheer said, if elected, a Conservative government would cut the tax rate on income under $47,630 to 13.75 per cent from 15 per cent. Source
  • Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer promises tax cut to save average taxpayer hundreds of dollars

    Canada News CBC News
    Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer unveiled a new tax cut plan Sunday that he says will save taxpayers hundreds of dollars a year, a key plank of the Tory platform to make life more affordable. Scheer said, if elected, a Conservative government would cut the tax rate on income under $47,630 to 13.75 per cent from 15 per cent. Source
  • U.S. Democratic presidential candidates call for Kavanaugh's impeachment

    World News CTV News
    WASHINGTON -- At least three Democratic presidential candidates are calling for the impeachment of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh in the face of a new, uninvestigated, allegation of sexual impropriety when he was in college. Source