Privacy czar sees middle ground in fight over access to Internet customer info

OTTAWA -- The federal privacy czar says there are instances when police may not need a warrant to obtain "very limited sets" of Internet customer information.

See Full Article

There could be a way to meet at least some law-enforcement demands for warrantless access to information while respecting a key Supreme Court of Canada ruling, privacy commissioner Daniel Therrien said in an interview.

In June last year, the Supreme Court ruled police must have a judge's authorization to obtain customer data linked to online activities.

The high court rejected the notion the federal privacy law governing companies allowed them to hand over subscriber identities voluntarily.

Police say telecommunications companies and other service providers -- such as banks and rental companies -- now demand court approval for nearly all types of requests from authorities for basic identifying information.

The Supreme Court judgment came amid mounting public concern about authorities quietly gaining access to customer data with little independent scrutiny.

Last month RCMP Commissioner Bob Paulson said police need warrantless access to Internet subscriber information to keep pace with child predators and other online criminals.

The top Mountie said the Supreme Court ruling curtailing the flow of basic data about customers -- such as name and address -- had "put a chill on our ability to initiate investigations."

Therrien noted that in keeping with the court's ruling, subscriber information largely raises reasonable expectations of privacy and therefore a warrant would be needed to obtain it.

"Normally it will, largely it will," Therrien said. "But there may be some elements of information that would not raise reasonable expectations of privacy. So there may be some room for an administrative regime for very limited sets or circumstances of information -- I recognize that."

Therrien said it was difficult to provide a specific example of the kind of information that might be accessible to police under an administrative scheme, but invoked the analogy of the public telephone book.

"Telephone numbers, perhaps, in certain circumstances might not attract a reasonable expectation of privacy. I wouldn't go beyond that, and even then it depends on the circumstances," he said.

"But if the RCMP is asking to have administrative access for large amounts of information, well, that clearly would go against what the Supreme Court said."

Rogers Communications has said that prior to the Supreme Court ruling, it was company policy when presented with a listed phone number to confirm basic customer information like name and address, so that police didn't issue a warrant for the wrong person or company.

Rogers also had a special process to help with child sexual exploitation investigations by confirming a customer's name and address when provided with a computer's Internet Protocol (IP) address. This would allow police to obtain a search or arrest warrant.

Since June 2014, the company said, it has responded to these two kinds of requests only when presented with a court order or warrant, or in emergency circumstances as defined by the Criminal Code.



Advertisements

Latest Tech & Science News

  • 'Jurassic Park' dinosaur expert's next big thing: holograms

    Tech & Science CTV News
    HELENA, Mont. -- Forget the grey, green and brown dinosaurs in the "Jurassic Park" movies. Paleontologist Jack Horner wants to transport people back in time to see a feathered Tyrannosaurus rex colored bright red and a blue triceratops with red fringe similar to a rooster's comb. Source
  • Emoji bee? New 'smiley face' bee named after University of Manitoba researcher

    Tech & Science CBC News
    A newly discovered bee with a silly grin has been named after the Manitoba researcher who found it. Called Epeolus gibbsi, the black and white insect bears the name of Jason Gibbs, University of Manitoba Assistant Professor of Entomology, who discovered the new species a few weeks ago. Source
  • NYC bill would give workers 'right to disconnect' from calls, emails

    Tech & Science CTV News
    NEW YORK -- The city that never sleeps could become the first to tell employees "take a break." That's if a "right to disconnect" bill sponsored by New York City councilman Rafael Espinal passes. Source
  • Cambridge Analytica liquidates

    Tech & Science CTV News
    NEW YORK -- Jennifer and Rebekah Mercer, daughters of Republican mega-donor Robert Mercer, are liquidating Cambridge Analytica, the troubled data collection agency that worked for U.S. President Donald Trump's 2016 election campaign and caused a global Facebook privacy scandal in recent months. Source
  • How to go plastic free and cut waste in the kitchen

    Tech & Science CBC News
    With plastic bags no longer accepted in Saskatoon recycling bins, and the city aiming for 70 per cent waste diversion by 2023, the average resident may be left scratching their heads about what to do with all the plastic. Source
  • How and when Rogers, Telus and Bell sell your location to third-party companies

    Tech & Science CBC News
    A joint venture between Canada's three largest telecom companies has been selling the real-time location of its subscribers to third parties — as long they have your consent, the company says. EnStream, a joint venture between Rogers, Telus and Bell, isn't new. Source
  • Sea otters make a comeback in southeast Alaska, and fishermen aren't happy

    Tech & Science CBC News
    Northern sea otters, once hunted to the brink of extinction along Alaska's Panhandle, have made a spectacular comeback by gobbling some of the state's finest seafood — and fishermen are not happy about the competition. Sea otters dive for red sea urchins, geoduck clams, sea cucumbers — delicacies in Asia markets — plus prized Dungeness crab. Source
  • Ancient fish species discovered in Nova Scotia as erosion reveals unique fossil

    Tech & Science CBC News
    A species of fish that lived 350 million years ago has been discovered in Nova Scotia, casting new light on a little-understood time period. The discovery was made in 2015 by Jason Anderson, a vertebrate paleontologist at the University of Calgary, at Blue Beach, N.S. Source
  • Archeologists find street of balconies in Italy's Pompeii

    Tech & Science CTV News
    Archeologists inspect excavation works in the archaeological site of Pompeii, Thursday, May 17, 2018. (Ciro Fusco /ANSA via AP) Source
  • Protect Canada's parks from being 'loved to death' says study co-author

    Tech & Science CTV News
    VANCOUVER -- Canada is a global leader in protecting its conserved land from human destruction, but its parks are in danger of being "loved to death" by thousands of people trekking through the backcountry, says a co-author of a study that details the degradation of one-third of the world's protected areas. Source