Court upholds dismissal of veteran's suit over 'Hurt Locker'

LOS ANGELES -- A U.S. federal appeals court ruled Wednesday that an Iraq War veteran cannot sue the makers of the "The Hurt Locker" because he believes the Oscar-winning film portrayed him in a bad light.

See Full Article

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled a lower court's dismissal of Sgt. Jeffrey Sarver's 2009 lawsuit against director Kathryn Bigelow and screenwriter Mark Boal was proper. Sarver, a bomb-disposal technician who was shadowed by Boal in Iraq, contended the film defamed him by portraying him as obsessed with death.

The court disagreed, saying the film was protected by the First Amendment and its fictional protagonist, even if he is based on Sarver, was shown to be a heroic figure.

The ruling states the justices agreed that reasonable viewers of the movie "would be left with the conclusion that the character Will James was a heroic figure, albeit one struggling with certain internal conflicts."

The ruling further stated, " 'The Hurt Locker' is speech that is fully protected by the First Amendment, which safeguards the storytellers and artists who take the raw materials of life -- including the stories of real individuals, ordinary or extraordinary -- and transform them into art, be it articles, books, movies, or plays."

"This is a highly important precedent that will have major implications for the entire film industry," said attorney Jeremiah Reynolds, who represented Bigelow and Boal.

"The Hurt Locker" won six Oscars, including one for Boal's screenplay and another for Bigelow's directing. It also won for best picture.

Sarver's attorney, Michael Dezsi, says the ruling is disappointing, and he's considering how to proceed, including an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

"Sgt. Sarver courageously defended his country and the liberties of this nation in the most dangerous of circumstances, and has now been repaid by the failure of the judicial system to protect his rights," Dezsi wrote in an email.

Sarver sued over the film days before it won big at the 2010 Oscars. A Los Angeles federal judge dismissed his case the following year.

Boal was embedded with Sarver's unit in 2004 and wrote about Sarver and other bomb disposal experts in an article for Playboy magazine titled "The Man in the Bomb Suit."

Sarver said Boal wanted to stay with him exclusively because he didn't trust other bomb techs.



Advertisements

Latest Entertainment News

  • Bruce Springsteen surprises audience at Van Zandt concert

    Entertainment CTV News
    In this Saturday, May 27, 2017 photo, Bruce Springsteen, right, performs at the Count Basie Theatre in Red Bank, N.J., with rocker Steven Van Zandt, left, during the show's encore. (Amanda Stevens/Count Basie Theatre via AP) Source
  • Kim Kardashian doubts her mom will ever talk to Caitlyn Jenner again

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Kim Kardashian doubts her mother will ever be on proper speaking terms with her ex Caitlyn Jenner after the former couple fell out over the transgender star’s new memoir. Retired Olympian Caitlyn, formerly known as Bruce Jenner, caused a rift in her family with Kris Jenner following the April release of her autobiography The Secrets Of My Life. Source
  • Stranger than fiction: Where do House of Cards, Veep and other White House shows go in the Trump era?

    Entertainment CBC News
    For years, House of Cards has lured audiences in with its dark portrait of unscrupulous Washington schemers, while Veep's fanbase remains devoted to the outrageous White House satire. But what happens when the reality in Washington becomes as dramatic as fiction? Source
  • Jaden Smith: Hollywood headcase hits Hogtown

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Nutty narcissist Jaden Smith is the reigning poster boy for Hollywood heirs gone to hell. The uber entitled 18-year-old son of Will Smith and Jada Pinkett-Smith has a long history of being seduced by his own genius. Source
  • Kim Kardashian agreed to marry Kris Humphries because she began to 'freak out' over turning 30

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Kim Kardashian knew her marriage to basketball player Kris Humphries was doomed because she wed for all the wrong reasons. The reality TV star admits she began to “freak out” about being old and lonely after turning 30, so when the sportsman proposed in 2011, after a whirlwind romance, she said “yes”. Source
  • Jerry Seinfeld on Timbits, Netflix, returning to Just for Laughs in Montreal

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    TORONTO — The last time Jerry Seinfeld was at Montreal’s Just for Laughs festival was in 1989 and audiences were just getting introduced to his motley crew of TV characters and their droll observations about everyday life in New York. Source
  • Discrimination suits proceed against Fox, minus Roger Ailes

    Entertainment CBC News
    The sudden death of Fox News founder Roger Ailes won't slow the march of litigation swirling around the network, legal observers and lawyers involved in the suits said. Three new lawsuits by people alleging a hostile work environment were filed just days after his death at age 77. Source
  • Standing Rock film festival centres around pipeline protest

    Entertainment CBC News
    A film festival on the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation aims to bolster the anti-pipeline movement that blossomed there last year while also fostering connections between the Native American community and the film industry. The inaugural Standing Rock Nation Film and Music Festival, which runs this coming Friday, Saturday and Sunday at the tribal casino near Fort Yates, N.D. Source
  • Standing Rock film festival centres on pipeline protest

    Entertainment CBC News
    A film festival on the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation aims to bolster the anti-pipeline movement that blossomed there last year while also fostering connections between the Native American community and the film industry. The inaugural Standing Rock Nation Film and Music Festival, which runs this coming Friday, Saturday and Sunday at the tribal casino near Fort Yates, N.D. Source
  • Brenton Thwaites on working with Johnny Depp and joining the 'Pirates' franchise

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    BEVERLY HILLS — Brenton Thwaites remembers exactly how he felt shooting his very first scene with Johnny Depp in Pirates Of The Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales. “Absolutely terrified.” Thwaites, 27, stars in the new Pirates movie as Henry Turner, seafaring son of Will Turner (Orlando Bloom). Source