Alibi says prosecutor misled her about murder appeal featured in 'Serial' podcast

BALTIMORE -- An alibi witness for a convicted murderer profiled in the public radio podcast "Serial" testified Wednesday that a former Baltimore prosecutor misled her about the importance of her testimony and that he later gave a deceptive account of their conversation when he testified about it during a hearing.

See Full Article

Asia McClain, now known as Asia Chapman, testified Wednesday during a hearing for Adnan Syed, who was convicted of murder and is seeking a new trial in a case that was spotlighted by the popular podcast.

Chapman has said she saw Syed in a library within the time when prosecutors contend he was killing his high school girlfriend, Hae Min Lee, in 1999. But McClain was never contacted by Syed's attorney to testify at his trial.

Chapman told the court that years after Syed was convicted, Syed's defence attorney, who was working on an appeal, visited her at her home and left a business card. She called then-prosecutor Kevin Urick because she figured he'd be less biased than the defence attorney.

During their 34-minute phone conversation, Chapman said she took detailed notes and Urick told her that Syed "killed that girl."

"I walked away feeling like (the defence) was trying to manipulate the court to get him in front of a judge," Chapman testified, adding that Urick convinced her that Syed "was 100 per cent guilty, and it was a waste of my time to get involved."

But she says Urick later testified at Syed's first post-conviction hearing that his phone call with her lasted only five minutes, and said that she'd told him that her affidavit was false.

"He said I told him everything I said in the affidavit was not true, that I wrote the affidavit because I was pressured," Chapman said of Urick's testimony. "All of this was news to me. I was in shock. I was angry that I had allowed my thoughts and opinions to be represented by a third party."

After learning of Urick's testimony Chapman said she requested her phone records and verified that her conversation with Urick lasted 34 minutes.

Chapman also said she would have come to court to testify even if she hadn't been subpoenaed.

"I felt it was the right thing to do," she said. "For justice to be served all information has to be on the table."

A message left at Urick's office was not immediately returned Wednesday.

Earlier Wednesday, Syed's attorney Justin Brown told Judge Martin Welch that previous defence attorney Cristina Gutierrez made a mistake in failing to call the alibi witness. But Maryland Deputy Attorney General Thiru Vignarajah said there were reasons to think the witness might be unreliable.

Vignarajah argued that Gutierrez was a dedicated and effective attorney, and that Syed was convicted not because his lawyer was incompetent, "but because he did it." Vignarajah added that Gutierrez made a decision not to pursue McClain as a witness.

"There were all sorts of reasons that this was not a reliable witness, and perhaps a risky witness," Vignarajah said.

But Brown linked the decision to personal problems that were plaguing Gutierrez, who was later disbarred in connection with other cases.

"At the time of the Syed case (Gutierrez) was unable to handle her cases," he said. "Her health was failing, her family was in turmoil. What was happening at her business, it was becoming unwound. As a result of the wheels coming off the bus, the single most important piece of evidence, an alibi witness, slipped through the cracks."

Syed was present in court, dressed in light blue prison garb, wearing a long beard and a knit cap. His hands were shackled. Spectators filled a row reserved for the public, including friends, supporters and members of Syed's family.

The case had been closed for years when producer Sarah Koenig, a former Baltimore Sun reporter, began examining it in the podcast in 2014, drawing millions of listeners each week.

The podcast raised questions about the fairness of Syed's trial, gained a cult following and uncovered evidence that helped prompt a Maryland appeals court to grant a hearing on the possibility of a new trial.

Syed's motion for a new trial also involves cell tower data that defence attorneys argue is inaccurate.

The state, too, will have a chance to call witnesses.

A motion filed Tuesday shows that prosecutors intend to call Urick and other members of the prosecution team. An FBI agent who specializes in cell tower data is also on the state's potential witness list, as is an expert in criminal defence practices.

At a news conference Wednesday, Vignarajah read aloud a statement from Lee's family, which has shied away from commenting on the case.

"We believe justice was done when Adnan was convicted in 2000, and we look forward to bringing this chapter to an end so we can celebrate the memory of Hae instead of celebrating the man who killed her," it read.


Latest Entertainment News

  • Movie reviews: Latest 'Jack Reacher' action-packed, with dose of sentimentality

    Entertainment CTV News
    JACK REACHER: NEVER GO BACK: 3 STARS Who exactly is Jack Reacher? If you are a reader, he’s the protagonist of 20 books by British author Lee Child. If you’re a moviegoer, he’s a bone-crunching former major in the U.S. Source
  • Lady Gaga returns to bar where she launched career

    Entertainment CTV News
    NEW YORK -- Lady Gaga returned to the New York City bar where she performed years ago as an unsigned act on the eve of her new album's release, singing rock and pop songs for an audience including Robert De Niro, Helen Mirren, die-hard fans and music industry insiders. Source
  • Kanye West blasts Jay-Z for not reaching out after Kim Kardashian robbery

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Kanye West has taken aim at his mentor Jay Z for failing to personally visit him and wife Kim Kardashian following her terrifying armed robbery ordeal. The Stronger hitmaker got his start as a producer for Jay Z’s Roc-A-Fella Records before embarking on his own rap career, but relations between the longtime pals have been particularly strained in recent years after Jay and his wife Beyonce decided against attending Kanye’s European wedding to reality star Kim in 2014. Source
  • Lady Gaga: 'I'm nothing like Madonna, I write my own songs'

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Lady Gaga’s ongoing feud with Madonna has stirred up again after the Poker Face singer accused the veteran of not writing her own tunes or playing her instruments. The divas first fell out when critics compared Gaga’s Born This Way to Madonna’s Express Yourself and the pop icon accused the younger star of ripping off her tune. Source
  • 'I saw an obnoxious erratic individual:' RZA breaks silence on Azealia Banks-Russell Crowe drama

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Hip hop legend RZA has publicly addressed the scandalous fall-out between Azealia Banks and Russell Crowe for the first time. The Wu-Tang Clan star broke his silence on the matter in a lengthy Facebook post on Thursday, dismissing Banks’ claims she was the victim of the Gladiator star’s unprovoked violent and racist attack at a party he threw at the Beverly Hills Hotel last weekend. Source
  • Kim Kardashian's jewel thieves caught on video?

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    The thieves who robbed Kim Kardashian in Paris last month have been caught on surveillance video, has learned. French website M6info released the bombshell video, taken shortly after 2 a.m. on Oct. 3, this morning. Source
  • Canadian comedian reads WikiLeaks' Assange the news

    Entertainment CTV News
    Julian Assange may be without internet access but a Canadian comedian Bobby Mair stepped in to make sure the WikiLeaks founder didn’t miss too much. Mair, who is from Seaforth, Ont. but is now living in London, U.K. Source
  • Kanye West laments that his kids haven't played with Jay Z's daughter

    Entertainment CTV News
    SEATTLE -- Kanye West is lamenting that his kids have yet to play with the daughter of his friend, mentor and collaborator Jay Z. Fan video from West's show in Seattle on Wednesday night shows the rapper complaining about business disputes with Jay Z before telling the crowd: "Our kids ain't never even played together. Source
  • 'Ouija: Origin of Evil' review: Horror prequel a cheeseball disaster

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Ouija: Origin of Evil is sadly derivative, totally stupid, routinely cheeseball and ultimately disappointing. Exactly as I expected this horror prequel to be, given that it is a third-rate rip-off of William Friedkin’s 1973 classic, The Exorcist. Source
  • 'Mean Dreams' review: Josh Wiggins impresses in crime thriller

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Mean Dreams is a coming-of-age drama that evolves into a crime thriller. There’s too much going on here, and the story eventually falls apart under its own weight, but there’s still a lot to like about this engaging film. Source