Hearing opens in murder case profiled in 'Serial' podcast

BALTIMORE -- A defence lawyer's failure to call an alibi witness was a key point of contention as a convicted murderer returned to court Wednesday to argue he deserves a new trial in a case that gained fresh notoriety through the podcast "Serial.

See Full Article

"

A three-day hearing began in Baltimore for 35-year-old Adnan Syed, who is serving a life sentence for the murder of his high school girlfriend, Hae Min Lee, in 1999.

Syed's attorney Justin Brown told Judge Martin Welch that previous defence attorney Cristina Gutierrez made a key mistake in failing to call Asia McClain, who claimed to have seen Syed at a library during the time of the killing. But prosecutor Thiru Vignarajah with the Maryland attorney general's office said there were reasons to think McClain might not be reliable.

Vignarajah argued that Gutierrez was a dedicated and effective attorney, and that Syed was convicted not because his lawyer was incompetent, "but because he did it." Vignarajah added that Gutierrez made a decision not to pursue McClain as a witness.

"There were all sorts of reasons that this was not a reliable witness, and perhaps a risky witness," Vignarajah said.

But Brown said linked the decision to personal problems that were plaguing Guitierrez, who was later disbarred in connection with other cases.

"At the time of the Syed case (Gutierrez) was unable to handle her cases," he said. "Her health was failing, her family was in turmoil. What was happening at her business, it was becoming unwound. As a result of the wheels coming off the bus, the single most important piece of evidence, an alibi witness, slipped through the cracks."

Adnan was present in court, dressed in light blue prison garb, wearing a long beard and a knit cap. His hands were shackled. Spectators filled a row reserved for the public, including friends, supporters and members of Syed's family.

The case had been closed for years when producer Sarah Koenig, a former Baltimore Sun reporter, began examining it in the podcast in 2014, drawing millions of listeners each week -- so many that the public radio podcast shattered Apple's iTunes store's record for downloads, reaching 5 million faster than any other podcast program.

The podcast raised questions about the fairness of Syed's trial, gained a cult following and uncovered evidence that helped prompt a Maryland appeals court to grant a hearing on the possibility of a new trial.

Syed's motion for a new trial centres on the alibi witness who was never called to testify, and cell tower data that defence attorneys argue is inaccurate, misleading and should never have been entered into evidence.

McClain has said she spotted Syed at a library the day Lee was strangled. Last year, McClain filed an affidavit saying that she'd be willing to testify on Syed's behalf. McClain said that she contacted Syed in jail while he was awaiting trial, and Syed told his attorney, Gutierrez, to contact her. But the attorney never did.

McClain is expected to testify during the hearing. The state, too, will have a chance to call witnesses.

A motion filed Tuesday shows that prosecutors intend to call the original lead prosecutor in Syed's case, Kevin Urick, as well as other members of the prosecution team. An FBI agent who specializes in cell tower data is also on the state's potential witness list, as is William Martin, an expert in criminal defence practices.



Advertisements

Latest Entertainment News

  • Prosecutors can use Bill Cosby's deposition at trial, judge rules

    Entertainment CTV News
    PHILADELPHIA - Damaging testimony that Bill Cosby gave in an accuser's lawsuit, including admissions that he gave young women drugs and alcohol before sex, can be used at his sex assault trial, a judge ruled Monday. Source
  • Judge signs off on Angelina Jolie, Brad Pitt custody agreement

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    A Los Angeles judge has officially approved Angelina Jolie’s temporary custody agreement with her estranged husband Brad Pitt. The former couple appeared to be gearing up for a custody battle in September, after Jolie filed for divorce to end her two-year marriage to Pitt and requested sole physical custody of their six children, ranging in age from eight to 15. Source
  • Jessica Williams, Cate Blanchett star in Sundance permieres

    Entertainment CTV News
    LOS ANGELES - Former "Daily Show" correspondent Jessica Williams flexes her dramatic chops, Cate Blanchett pays homage to great 20th century artists and "Silicon Valley" star Kumail Nanjiani tells a very personal story in some of the films premiering at the 2017 Sundance Film Festival. Source
  • Prosecutors can use Bill Cosby’s deposition at trial judge says

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    PHILADELPHIA — Damaging testimony that Bill Cosby gave in an accuser’s lawsuit, including admissions that he gave young women drugs and alcohol before sex, can be used at his sex assault trial, a judge ruled Monday. The defence has insisted Cosby testified only after being promised he would never be charged over his 2004 encounter with accuser Andrea Constand. Source
  • Lady Gaga reveals she suffers from PTSD: 'I've never told anyone that before'

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Lady Gaga has been secretly suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) ever since she was raped at the age of 19. The Perfect Illusion hitmaker has been candid about her sex assault since going public with the news in 2014, revealing she was attacked by a producer at the start of her music career. Source
  • Director Bernardo Bertolucci tries to clear up 'Last Tango in Paris' controversy

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Filmmaker Bernardo Bertolucci has clarified controversial remarks he made about a rape scene in his film Last Tango In Paris, insisting late actress Maria Schneider was aware she would be taking part in the violent scene with Marlon Brando. Source
  • Where does 'Westworld' go from here? And other questions about the season finale

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    "Westworld" ended its season on a strange note. The episode was not exactly a cliffhanger, but it also did not offer much in the way of closure. The final moments were not unlike another story of A.I. Source
  • Jimmy Kimmel to host Academy Awards

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    NEW YORK — The Oscars finally have a host: Jimmy Kimmel will emcee the 89th Academy Awards. Kimmel will be hosting the show for the first time, the Academy of Motion Pictures said Monday. In September, he hosted the Emmy Awards for the second time. Source
  • Guillermo and mean tweets head to the Oscars? Jimmy Kimmel to MC Academy Awards

    Entertainment CBC News
    With two Emmy Award telecasts under his belt, late-night host Jimmy Kimmel is now heading to the Oscars. The Academy Awards show producers have tapped the Jimmy Kimmel Live star to MC Hollywood's annual celebration of cinema. Source
  • Justin Bieber: 'I'm single... but not looking'

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Justin Bieber has confirmed he’s a single man and isn’t “really looking” for a relationship. The 22-year-old singer has been linked to various famous faces including Lionel Richie’s daughter Sofia in recent months. But as he filmed an interview for U.S. Source