Judge tosses Pennsylvania woman's defamation suit vs. Cosby

PITTSBURGH -- A federal judge on Thursday dismissed a lawsuit filed by a Pittsburgh-area woman who claims Bill Cosby defamed her when he and his representatives responded to allegations that he drugged and sexually assaulted her and other women.

See Full Article

The October lawsuit filed by Renita Hill, 48, of Baldwin, was dismissed with prejudice, meaning she cannot try to amend and re-file it.

Hill went public with her allegations in November 2014 in an interview on Pittsburgh's KDKA-TV in which she said she was "emboldened" by other women who had made similar accusations against Cosby.

Her lawsuit said she was made out to be a "liar" and "extortionist" when the comedian, his wife and his attorney issued blanket denials.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab agreed with Cosby's attorneys that the statements were opinions protected by the First Amendment.

"Even considering these three statements together as a combined, single statement, this newly 'conjoined' statement does not lead to an inference that plaintiff is a 'liar and an extortionist,"' the judge wrote.

Cosby's attorneys referred questions to a spokeswoman who didn't immediately comment on the ruling.

Hill's attorney, George Kontos, promised to appeal saying he strongly disagreed with the judge's reasoning.

"The basis of his opinion is these are constitutionally protected, 'pure' opinions," Kontos said. "But, looked at as a whole, they contain all sorts of innuendo and undisclosed facts."

A day after Hill's interview, Cosby attorney Martin Singer issued a statement saying: "The new, never-before-heard claims from women who have come forward in the past two weeks with unsubstantiated, fantastical stories about things they say occurred 30, 40, or even 50 years ago have escalated far past the point of absurdity."

Cosby and his wife, Camille, made separate statements in the weeks that followed, with Cosby saying he refused to respond to "innuendos" and inviting the public to "fact-check" his accusers. Camille Cosby accused media outlets of violating rules of journalistic integrity by publishing some of the allegations without properly "vetting" Cosby's accusers.

Kontos had argued in an earlier court filing that those statements weren't pure opinions protected by the First Amendment because they included "undisclosed facts" -- namely, the implication that Hill and the other accusers are lying.

But Judge Schwab found the statements citing innuendo and fact-checking were "a far cry" from labeling the accusers liars and extortionists.

Cosby has yet to respond specifically to Hill's allegations that he drugged and molested her several times after they met on the TV show, "Picture Pages," in 1983. Hill claims that went on for about four years, starting when she was 16, and that Cosby helped pay for her college and would fly her to cities where he was performing, until she cut off contact with him about four years later.

Seven women are suing Cosby in federal court in Massachusetts for defamation. Like Hill, those women contend Cosby defamed them by allowing his representatives to brand them as liars.

In December, Cosby countersued, saying the women made "malicious, opportunistic, and false and defamatory accusations" against him for monetary gain.

Since then, Cosby has been criminally charged in suburban Philadelphia with sexually assaulting a woman in 2004 after giving her drugs that made her drowsy and unable to resist. A judge has set a Feb. 2 hearing on a motion by Cosby's attorneys to have those charges dismissed.


Latest Entertainment News

  • Judge rejects woman and girl's claims to Prince estate

    Entertainment CTV News
    MINNEAPOLIS -- A Minnesota judge ruled Wednesday that a woman and girl who claim to be Prince's niece and grandniece will not be considered heirs to the late music superstar's estate. Carver County Judge Kevin Eide ruled that Brianna Nelson and her niece, Victoria Nelson, are excluded as Prince's heirs as a matter of law. Source
  • Drake 'corny as f---' Kid Cudi's manager responds to 'Two Birds, One Stone'

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Kid Cudi’s manager has fired back at Drake, branding the Canadian rapper “corny” for mocking the troubled star’s mental health issues in a new song. The Hotline Bling hitmaker, real name Aubrey Graham, faced a backlash from music fans this week after debuting a track titled Two Birds, One Stone on his Apple Music OVO Sound Radio show on Sunday. Source
  • Justin Timberlake's voting booth selfie not under investigation

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    The District Attorney in Shelby County, Tennessee has dismissed reports suggesting Justin Timberlake is under investigation for his illegal voting booth selfie. The SexyBack hitmaker took to Instagram on Monday and shared a photo of himself casting his early ballot back home in Memphis, Tennessee, after flying in from Los Angeles, where he had just premiered his new movie Trolls on Sunday. Source
  • 'I hate this but I was slightly distant'; John Candy's kids reveal last moments with their father

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    It’s hard to believe, but if John Candy was still with us, he’d be turning 66 next Monday, Oct. 31. The funnyman died on March 4, 1994, at the age of 43 in Mexico while he was filming Wagons East, a western parody that co-starred Richard Lewis. Source
  • Judge bars Prince heir of estate claim for people claiming to be his niece, grandniece

    Entertainment CBC News
    A Minnesota judge says a woman and girl who claim to be Prince's niece and grandniece will not be considered heirs of his estate. Judge Kevin Eide ruled Wednesday that Brianna Nelson and her niece, Victoria Nelson, are excluded as Prince's heirs as a matter of law. Source
  • Tom Hanks' wife Rita Wilson loves his David S. Pumpkins 'SNL' character

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    LOS ANGELES — Rita Wilson’s phone has been blowing up — and it’s all David S. Pumpkins’ fault. Ever since her husband, Tom Hanks, appeared on NBC’s Saturday Night Live as the strange man in the pumpkin suit in that haunted elevator, Wilson has received all sorts of crazy David S. Source
  • Saskatoon mayoral candidate gets last-minute shoutout from Zach Galifianakis

    Entertainment CTV News
    SASKATOON -- A candidate for mayor in Saskatoon's municipal election today is getting a last-minute endorsement with a comedic twist. Charlie Clark has tweeted a decidedly amateur video of Zach Galifianakis urging voters to mark their ballots for the 10-year city councillor. Source
  • 'I can vote with my wallet:' boycott urges shoppers, retailers to drop Trump products

    Entertainment CBC News
    An eye-catching shoe piques your interest and draws you in. Upon closer inspection, the label leaps out at you — Ivanka Trump, in simple gold lettering — and you recoil as if stung. That's the kind of reaction behind a growing boycott of the products emblazoned with the brand of Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump as well as the popular, working women-targeted fashion line from his eldest daughter — who has arguably been his most influential and effective family member during the…
  • Robert Downey Jr. as Iron Man: Will Marvel replace its biggest star?

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Will Robert Downey Jr. play Tony Stark in Iron Man 4? What about Chris Evans? Will he return for another solo outing as Captain America? As Marvel steps firmly into Phase 3 of its Cinematic Universe with next week’s Doctor Strange, the question of what will happen with the studio’s biggest heroes is one that president Kevin Feige faces. Source
  • Joel McHale dares to make fun of millennials in new sitcom 'The Great Indoors'

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Joel McHale understands that every generation thinks the next generation is bogus. “Even when the Apache were fighting the Lakota or whatever, I'm sure they were like, 'Ugh! These kids! They don't know what the f--- they're doing! If you're going to throw your spear like that, don't come to me anymore!” McHale said. Source