Judge tosses Pennsylvania woman's defamation suit vs. Cosby

PITTSBURGH -- A federal judge on Thursday dismissed a lawsuit filed by a Pittsburgh-area woman who claims Bill Cosby defamed her when he and his representatives responded to allegations that he drugged and sexually assaulted her and other women.

See Full Article

The October lawsuit filed by Renita Hill, 48, of Baldwin, was dismissed with prejudice, meaning she cannot try to amend and re-file it.

Hill went public with her allegations in November 2014 in an interview on Pittsburgh's KDKA-TV in which she said she was "emboldened" by other women who had made similar accusations against Cosby.

Her lawsuit said she was made out to be a "liar" and "extortionist" when the comedian, his wife and his attorney issued blanket denials.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab agreed with Cosby's attorneys that the statements were opinions protected by the First Amendment.

"Even considering these three statements together as a combined, single statement, this newly 'conjoined' statement does not lead to an inference that plaintiff is a 'liar and an extortionist,"' the judge wrote.

Cosby's attorneys referred questions to a spokeswoman who didn't immediately comment on the ruling.

Hill's attorney, George Kontos, promised to appeal saying he strongly disagreed with the judge's reasoning.

"The basis of his opinion is these are constitutionally protected, 'pure' opinions," Kontos said. "But, looked at as a whole, they contain all sorts of innuendo and undisclosed facts."

A day after Hill's interview, Cosby attorney Martin Singer issued a statement saying: "The new, never-before-heard claims from women who have come forward in the past two weeks with unsubstantiated, fantastical stories about things they say occurred 30, 40, or even 50 years ago have escalated far past the point of absurdity."

Cosby and his wife, Camille, made separate statements in the weeks that followed, with Cosby saying he refused to respond to "innuendos" and inviting the public to "fact-check" his accusers. Camille Cosby accused media outlets of violating rules of journalistic integrity by publishing some of the allegations without properly "vetting" Cosby's accusers.

Kontos had argued in an earlier court filing that those statements weren't pure opinions protected by the First Amendment because they included "undisclosed facts" -- namely, the implication that Hill and the other accusers are lying.

But Judge Schwab found the statements citing innuendo and fact-checking were "a far cry" from labeling the accusers liars and extortionists.

Cosby has yet to respond specifically to Hill's allegations that he drugged and molested her several times after they met on the TV show, "Picture Pages," in 1983. Hill claims that went on for about four years, starting when she was 16, and that Cosby helped pay for her college and would fly her to cities where he was performing, until she cut off contact with him about four years later.

Seven women are suing Cosby in federal court in Massachusetts for defamation. Like Hill, those women contend Cosby defamed them by allowing his representatives to brand them as liars.

In December, Cosby countersued, saying the women made "malicious, opportunistic, and false and defamatory accusations" against him for monetary gain.

Since then, Cosby has been criminally charged in suburban Philadelphia with sexually assaulting a woman in 2004 after giving her drugs that made her drowsy and unable to resist. A judge has set a Feb. 2 hearing on a motion by Cosby's attorneys to have those charges dismissed.



Advertisements

Latest Entertainment News

  • Duchess of Cambridge breaks all-black #MeToo dress code at BAFTAs

    Entertainment CTV News
    Though she’s often known for setting fashion trends, the Duchess of Cambridge is drawing criticism for bucking one at the British Film and Television Awards, where she was among the few who did not wear black in support of the #MeToo and “Time’s Up” movements to end sexual misconduct. Source
  • Court told Geoffrey Rush inappropriately touched actress

    Entertainment CTV News
    SYDNEY, Australia -- A lawyer accused Oscar-winning Australian actor Geoffrey Rush in court Monday of touching an actress inappropriately on an Sydney stage three years ago while he was starring in a production of "King Lear. Source
  • Drake touts giveaways, urges fans to do something nice, too

    Entertainment CTV News
    NEW YORK - Drake wants to spread the love, and he's challenging his fans to do the same. The new video for the rap star's single, "God's Plan," announces upfront that Drake gave away the $996,631 budget to film the clip. Source
  • As 'Black Panther' shows, inclusion pays at the box office

    Entertainment CTV News
    NEW YORK -- A lavish, headline-grabbing premiere. Lightning word-of-mouth stoked by glowing reviews. Packed movie theatres with sold-out shows, long lines and fans decked out as characters from the film. The phenomenon of "Black Panther" had the look and feel of a classic, bona fide blockbuster in route to its record-setting $192 million debut over the weekend, or an estimated $218 million Friday through Monday. Source
  • Original Picasso print stolen from Milwaukee art gallery

    Entertainment CTV News
    MILWAUKEE - An original Pablo Picasso print worth up to an estimated $50,000 was stolen from a downtown Milwaukee art gallery. WITI-TV reports appraiser Bill DeLind says his business partner noticed the original 1949 print was missing from DeLind Fine Art Appraisals on Friday. Source
  • 'I'm shaking': Fans flock to opening of Justin Bieber exhibition in Stratford, Ont.

    Entertainment CTV News
    Fans of pop idol Justin Bieber lined up for hours just so they could be among the first to see a museum exhibition in his hometown of Stratford, Ont., on Sunday. The “Steps to Stardom” exhibition features memorabilia like hockey jerseys and music awards that were lent to the museum by Bieber’s grandparents. Source
  • Black Panther's inspiring $192M weekend — in more ways than one

    Entertainment CBC News
    Black Panther has not only taken the box office by storm during its opening weekend, but is inspiring movements in fashion, voting and even random acts of kindness. The Marvel film, directed by Fruitvale Station and Creed filmmaker Ryan Coogler, hit $192 million US in ticket sales in North America over the weekend. Source
  • Wakanda forever: 'Black Panther' mauls box office with record debut

    Entertainment CTV News
    NEW YORK -- Already a much-celebrated pop culture milestone, "Black Panther" is now a record-setting smash at the box office, too. Studio estimates Sunday say the Marvel superhero film blew past expectations, with $192 million in ticket sales over the weekend. Source
  • Million-euro cello returned after knifepoint robbery

    Entertainment CTV News
    An 18th-century cello worth more than a million euros was returned to an award-winning French musician on Saturday after she was robbed at knifepoint in a Paris suburb earlier in the week. "I received an anonymous call late in the morning saying that my cello was inside a car in front of my house. Source
  • Roger Deakins wins cinematography award for Blade Runner 2049

    Entertainment CBC News
    Roger Deakins may be inching closer to making good on his 14th Oscar nomination after winning the American Society of Cinematographers' feature film award for Blade Runner 2049. His wife, James Deakins, accepted the award on her husband's behalf Saturday night, saying he was busy filming in New York. Source