Cosby will not be deposed next month in Massachusetts lawsuit, judge rules

WORCESTER, Mass. -- Bill Cosby will not be deposed next month in a lawsuit accusing him of defaming seven women who accuse him of sexual assault, but his wife will be, a federal judge ruled Wednesday.

See Full Article

U.S. Magistrate Judge David Hennessy agreed to hold off on the comedian's deposition, scheduled for Feb. 22, as Cosby now faces criminal charges in Pennsylvania. His wife, Camille, will instead be deposed that day, the judge said.

Camille Cosby had been set to be deposed by lawyers for the women this month, but, at her lawyer's request, Hennessy agreed to a postponement as her lawyers appeal his decision to deny their bid to throw out the subpoena altogether.

Hennessy on Wednesday also rejected a proposal by the comedian's lawyers that would have kept a significant amount of material in the case out of the public eye.

Instead, he proposed more limited protections focused on certain sensitive information that might be disclosed in depositions, such as Social Security numbers, bank accounts and addresses. The order would not affect other materials and documents gathered in the pretrial discovery phase.

Both sides in court agreed to put the procedure in writing by Jan. 20.

"It was a compromise, and I think it was fair," Joseph Cammarata, a lawyer for the seven women, said after the hearing. "This is an appropriate order protecting what may be legitimate concerns for confidentiality on a question-by-question basis. It's not a unilateral blanket protection. It's very limited in scope."

Cosby's lawyers, who declined to comment after the hearing, had originally sought to have all depositions and documents produced during the pretrial discovery phase kept confidential for up to 14 days. Either side would then be allowed to request the judge seal the records for longer.

Cosby's lawyers said in court filings that they proposed the order because the other side was seeking "irrelevant and extraordinarily invasive and intimate details" of Cosby's life and "have made clear they intend to publicize every aspect of discovery in the case."

Among the information being sought: the identities of all Cosby's sexual partners since 1968 who were not his wife, the dates of the sexual encounters and all Cosby's medical records over the past 35 years, including those specifically dealing with "erectile and/or other sexual dysfunction, sexual paraphilia and/or sexual fetish," according to Cosby's lawyers.

Cammarata, in his briefs, argued Cosby's proposal would damage transparency in a case of great public interest.

He also said there are valid reasons why he sought Cosby's medical and sexual histories, including Cosby's past statements that he obtained quaaludes for various joint and body pains.

The seven women are among approximately 50 across the country who have come forward with allegations that Cosby plied them with drugs and alcohol before sexually assaulting them. He denies the accusations.

In other developments, Cosby's lawyer Marshall Searcy said Wednesday that he was considering asking for a postponement in the defamation case in light of the Pennsylvania criminal charges.

"It's a new situation. It's a fluid situation. And we're trying to decide on the best approach," he said.

The 78-year old actor was charged Dec. 30 with drugging and sexually assaulting a woman inside his home near Philadelphia in 2004. It's the first criminal case brought against him.

In response, Cammarata called on the judge to set a deadline for when Cosby's lawyers should file that postponement request.

Cammarata also objected to his clients being subjected to depositions while Cosby is allowed more time.

"We want to keep the case moving," he said. "But we don't want it one-sided."

Hennessy didn't immediately rule on Cammarata's request.



Advertisements

Latest Entertainment News

  • Innovative jazz producer George Avakian dies at 98

    Entertainment CTV News
    NEW YORK -- George Avakian, a Russian-born jazz scholar and architect of the American music industry who produced essential recordings by Louis Armstrong, Miles Davis and other stars has died at age 98. Avakian's daughter, Anahid Avakian Gregg, confirmed that her father died Wednesday morning at his home in Manhattan. Source
  • Hollywood stars on the defensive as scandals prompt tough questions

    Entertainment CBC News
    Appearing on the red carpet was once a sign of prestige and glamour, but for many in Hollywood the old self-promotional standby is now a battleground better avoided than pranced upon. Normally at this time of year, the entertainment industry is gearing up for another awards season. Source
  • Gary Oldman gets Oscar buzz for portrayal of Winston Churchill

    Entertainment CTV News
    TORONTO -- It's a long distance from Sid Vicious to Winston Churchill, and a greater leap, still, from Dracula to "Darkest Hour." Gary Oldman, character-actor maverick, has taken up perhaps his biggest -- and most buttoned-down -- challenge. Source
  • Lawren Harris painting Mountains East of Maligne Lake fetches $2.5M at auction

    Entertainment CBC News
    Mountains East of Maligne Lake, a 1925 Rocky Mountains canvas by Group of Seven co-founder Lawren Harris, fetched $2.5 million in Toronto on Wednesday. The bidding war for the painting took place at Heffel's annual fall auction of Canadian art, held Wednesday evening at Toronto's Design Exchange. Source
  • Suit over erotic fiction about NFL player tossed

    Entertainment CTV News
    CINCINNATI -- A federal appeals court has spiked an Ohio couple's case against companies that distributed an erotic fiction book about a woman's desire for New England Patriots star Rob Gronkowski. The 6th U.S. Source
  • Musician Amy Sky says David Cassidy should be remembered for his 'generosity'

    Entertainment CTV News
    TORONTO -- Like many others who came of age in the 1970s, Canadian musician Amy Sky was a big fan of David Cassidy, the "Partridge Family" actor who died on Tuesday at age 67. So it was a thrill when she was cast alongside the TV star in a 1996 Toronto production of the musical "Blood Brothers. Source
  • William Shatner complains about Ontario condo using his name, likeness

    Entertainment CTV News
    HAMILTON - William Shatner is objecting to the use of his name and likeness to promote an upcoming condo development in Hamilton. The "Star Trek" star, best known for playing Captain Kirk on the original series, set his lasers on the project -- dubbed "Television City" -- on Twitter. Source
  • Christopher Plummer has this to say about retirement - never

    Entertainment CTV News
    NEW YORK -- At 87, Christopher Plummer isn't just working -- he's busy. He has five movies scheduled for release, including "A Christmas Carol" origin story called "The Man Who Invented Christmas." And he plans to work until the very end, literally. Source
  • Backstreet Boys singer Nick Carter faces sexual assault allegation

    Entertainment CBC News
    Nick Carter says he's "shocked and saddened" by allegations made by a singer who said he raped her about 15 years ago. Melissa Schuman of the girl group Dream wrote in a blog post earlier this month that she was "forced to engage in an act against my will. Source
  • Report: U.K. police investigating 2nd Spacey sex-assault claim

    Entertainment CTV News
    LONDON -- Police in London are investigating a second allegation of sexual assault against actor Kevin Spacey, British media reported Wednesday. The Metropolitan Police force said it had received a complaint "of sexual assaults against a man" in 2005 in the London borough of Lambeth. Source