Attorneys for Bill Cosby sex accuser defending defamation lawsuit

PITTSBURGH -- Attorneys for a western Pennsylvania woman who contends Bill Cosby repeatedly drugged and had sex with her in the 1980s have filed a response to Cosby's attempt to have a federal judge dismiss her defamation lawsuit against him.

See Full Article

Cosby's attorneys last week asked a federal court judge in Pittsburgh to dismiss the lawsuit filed in October by Renita Hill.

Hill sued claiming Cosby made her out to be a "liar" and "extortionist" when the comedian, his wife and his attorney issued blanket denials to claims that Cosby drugged and sexually molested several women shortly after Hill went public with her allegations in November 2014.

Cosby's attorneys claimed the denials constitute opinions that are protected by the First Amendment. But Hill's attorneys said Tuesday that those opinion were based on "undisclosed facts" -- namely, the implication that Hill is lying.

"Such facts include the implication that Plaintiff (Hill) knew she had not been assaulted and that she is an opportunistic liar who is attempting to extort money from Cosby," Hill's attorneys wrote in their 18-page response filed Tuesday.

Cosby's attorneys didn't immediately respond to the filing.

Hill, of Baldwin, sued claiming Cosby drugged and had sex with her several times after they met on a children's educational TV show.

She went public with her allegations in a television interview in late 2014 because she was "emboldened" after other women began renewing similar allegations against Cosby, her attorneys have said.

Cosby has yet to respond specifically to Hill's allegations that he drugged and had sex with her several times after they met on the TV show, "Picture Pages," in 1983. Hill claims that went on for about four years, starting when she was 16, and that Cosby helped pay for her college and would fly her to cities where he was performing and provide her with hotel rooms where he'd have sex with her, until she cut off contact with him.

But she contends statements from Cosby and his camp -- including a statement given to the Washington Post the day after her TV interview by Cosby attorney Martin Singer -- pertain to her.

Among other things, that statement said, "There has never been a shortage of lawyers willing to represent people with claims against rich, powerful men, so it makes no sense that not one of these new women who just came forward now for the first time ever asserted a legal claim back at the time they allege they had been sexually assaulted."

Cosby's attorneys argued that Hill couldn't be defamed by the blanket denials because none of them specifically referenced her, and that, even if they did, the statements weren't made with "actual malice" and concern a public figure -- Hill -- embroiled in a public controversy.

But Hill's attorneys contend it's reasonable to infer that the various Cosby denials refer to her because "she was a member of a very small group of women to whom the statements could possibly be directed."

Also, they contend Hill isn't a "public figure" despite the publicity her allegations and others have generated because the public didn't have a stake in the outcome of the controversy, the filing said.

Cosby's attorneys have until Jan. 5 to respond to Hill's filing.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab has not scheduled a hearing on the motion to dismiss the lawsuit and can choose to decide the matter on the written arguments alone.



Advertisements

Latest Entertainment News

  • Burt Reynolds makes rare public appearance at Tribeca

    Entertainment CTV News
    NEW YORK -- Robert De Niro helped Burt Reynolds onto the red carpet for the Tribeca Film Festival premiere of his new movie "Dog Years" Saturday night in New York. It was a rare appearance for the 81-year old actor, who at times struggled to walk. Source
  • Mike Myers had to rewrite 'Wayne's World 2' at the last minute

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Funnyman Mike Myers had to rewrite the script for Wayne’s World 2 after movie boss Sherry Lansing realized he had based the whole plot on a 1949 British comedy. In an extract from Stephen Galloway’s new Lansing biopic, Leading Lady, obtained by The Hollywood Reporter, the writer reveals the then-Paramount chief was furious to learn the sequel was a rip-off of Ealing comedy Passport to Pimlico and laid into Myers. Source
  • Channing Tatum: 'I don’t miss anything about stripping'

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Channing Tatum misses nothing about his stripper past. The 36-year-old drew on his past life as an exotic dancer for the Magic Mike movies, with his saucy former professional also used as inspiration for the live strip show revue in Las Vegas. Source
  • Canadian investors looking to LA, where celeb home prices rival inner-city Toronto's

    Entertainment CBC News
    As if housing market prices in Toronto aren't discouraging enough, it hurts even more knowing a celebrity pad in Los Angeles can be comparable in price to some homes in the downtown core. A Hollywood Hills house owned by Oscar-winning Dallas Buyers Club actor Jared Leto, for example, is currently listed for sale at $1.9 million US. Source
  • 'Fate of the Furious' still outpacing the competition at box office [Video]

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    LOS ANGELES — The Fate of the Furious sped into first place at the box office again, leaving new thriller Unforgettable and historical drama The Promise in the dust. Universal Pictures’ eighth instalment in The Fast and the Furious franchise earned US$38.7 million over the weekend, down 61% from its debut, according to studio estimates Sunday. Source
  • Caitlyn Jenner 'distant' from some of her children post-transition

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Caitlyn Jenner doesn’t speak to some of her children after her transition from man to woman. The 67-year-old former Olympian opened up about her life in the years that followed her shock Vanity Fair cover in 2015, where she finally revealed had left her former identity of Bruce behind, and was living as Caitlyn. Source
  • Margot Robbie to play Queen Elizabeth I

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Margot Robbie is set to join the royal list of actresses who have portrayed Queen Elizabeth I onscreen. The Suicide Squad star has officially signed on to join the cast of Mary Queen of Scots, opposite Irish actress Saoirse Ronan, who will portray Mary Stuart. Source
  • Mel B's first husband fears for their daughter

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Melanie Brown’s first husband Jimmy Gulzar insists his ex-wife has failed to keep their daughter Phoenix Chi out of danger. The Dutch-born dancer was married to the former Spice Girl from 1998-2000 and their child is now 18. Source
  • Rosario Dawson wants in on Star Wars

    Entertainment Toronto Sun
    Actress Rosario Dawson is calling on more fans to help make her Star Wars dreams come true by backing an online campaign to land her a role in a future project. The Sin City star has become a major fixture in the Marvel comics TV adaptations as medic Claire Temple in Daredevil, Luke Cage, Jessica Jones, and Iron Fist but she would love to expand her role with the productions’ parent company Disney and step into one of the planned Star Wars movies. Source
  • Burt Reynolds makes rare public appearance at Tribeca film festival

    Entertainment CBC News
    Robert De Niro helped Burt Reynolds onto the red carpet for the Tribeca Film Festival premiere of Reynold's new movie Dog Years Saturday night in New York. It was a rare appearance for the 81-year old actor, who at times struggled to walk. Source